My Favorite Anecdote About Insular Seminarian Ridiculousness

I went to the seminary cafeteria after class. The place was crowded. I chose a seat at a crowded table where ministers-to-be chatted animatedly about hospitality, the living God in their lives, the ministry of Jesus.

I sat inches away from them, literally at their elbows.
Never once during the half-hour it took me to slowly eat my lunch did any one of these people make eye contact with me, greet me, include me in the conversation or ever acknowledge my presence. Not a nod, not a smile.

The sarcastic thoughts I had as I listened to them blather on and on about their spiritual lives cannot be numbered. I had heartburn all day.

Now, I’m really giving it to the seminarians today but this is no different than the many, many coffee hours I’ve visited where the pastor stood in a circle of parishioners (if he or she showed up at all) and totally ignored the visitors, or to put it Biblically, the Stranger.

To be a religious person is to notice everyone, period. It is to risk a greeting, ask the person about themselves, and leave wide empty spaces to receive them as they are. It is not to eagerly jump on them, or to start a cozy insider conversation that assumes they’re comfortably like us, or to (God forbid) ask them what they “do.” Nor is it to anxiously barrage them with a list of programs the church has to offer them or their children, or to categorize them in some way that immediately objectifies them or classifies them (“Oh, we have a divorced persons ministry!”). That information can be offered after the hospitality of listening and welcoming has been offered with a full sense of reverence for whom God has called out of their Saturday night sleep and to our church that Sunday morning.

Okay? Let’s all work on it.

25 Replies to “My Favorite Anecdote About Insular Seminarian Ridiculousness”

  1. When I was visiting a parish without a collar and with our oldest when he was a baby I literally got knocked out of the way by someone who wanted to get to the coffee urn. Yuck.

  2. I don’t think this would happen in Chicago (Ok, well, maybe in Hyde Park) but for the most part in metro Chicago when we meet strangers, and especially when we sit with them at a table eating hot dogs for exampmle, we say, “hey, howya doin?’. Almost without exception I think.

  3. This is right on and something I struggle to do well with. I’d love suggestions from others of lead in questions that are not “what do you do?” I work at a large parish and am often completely unsure if this is the person’s first visit, fifth visit, or if they’ve been members for years and I haven’t met them yet, so a simple “what brought you to visit us today,” isn’t a safe question when reaching out to someone new. What do you other people ask?

  4. I am a pastor’s wife and I understand the point. The majority of the time my husband and I make a point of speaking to the unfamiliar faces. I sometimes do it with the right motivation but sometimes not. Yes, we should want to be sharing Jesus light with others (and that is a constant prayer request of mine) but sometimes you just want to be alone or with friends!

  5. The struggle at our church is getting a congregation, of which about 80% are strong introverts, to understand that the guest, the “stranger” is more out of their element coming to our church than our congregation is at receiving them.

    Shy and quiet can so easily be interpreted as snooty and disinterested.

  6. Oh, I’m so glad you bring this up. I went to a church for a month and the pastor never once greeted me or my family. Only one family ever talked to us. When we signed up for the the “Discovery Class” they only went on and on about what they offer, but they forgot to get to know us first! Needless to say, we joined a different church.

  7. Our church is know as being friendly, generally, but there have been people who have reported otherwise. In fact, the fill in preacher this past Sun said that the first time her family attended, no body talked to them at all. We attended a suburban church last year with a couple of relatives who belong there, so we sat with this aunt, four generations of us, sitting together. You’d think somebody would have noticed us. NO BODY said hello at all. The aunt dragged the pastor over to meet two of the family members who are pastors, so that was the only greeting we got. There didn’t seem to be a shaking hands line on the way out. But the worst reception I’ve experienced was about 25 years ago in a city church. No body greeted us. But I made a point of greeting people, saying we were visiting, to the pastors, the Sunday School people, the people at the forum, and we got NADA in return. sheesh. But it taught me a lot. The service and organ music and liturgy were perfect, but the Christian “fellowship” sucked.

  8. I have been a faithful reader of BTFM for quite some time, but this is my first comment (read: please kind to me if you feel the need to respond/critique what I’m about to offer :-)).

    This subject is one that I find particularly important and equally challenging. I was recently ordained and installed in my first call only a month ago and serve with a fairly large congregation where it is difficult to remember all of the faces and names. In response to Sarah, specifically, I have been thinking a lot about how to ask questions without assuming people are new. So far, the best option I’ve found is to ask, “How long have you (and your family) been worshiping with us?” For those who have been around for a while, this question offers an opportunity for them to share some of their story. For those who are actually new it can be a pleasant surprise that “I’m new!” isn’t plastered across their foreheads.

    Another one I like to ask, instead of “What do you do?”, is “How do you spend your days?” or “What makes you get up in the morning?” Sometimes work details are the obvious answers to these questions, but sometimes…those precious sometimes…the answer has nothing to do with employment. [How about, “How are you?” or “How have you been?” I like to ask questions that have nothing to do with how long they’ve been at the church or anything at all about the church. I like to say something that invites them to talk about where they are in their lives. The other day I asked a new couple, “So what’s going on in your lives right now?” But hey, any warm greeting that doesn’t categorize them or pin them to the wall about who they are and throw a bunch of program info at them is good! – PB]

  9. Gee, it sounds as if lots of people have been completey ignored when visiting churches! So sad. It really is not that difficult for church members to say, “Hello, I’m so-and-so” with a smile and a handshake. “I’m pleased to meet you.” Then listen carefully to the visitor. I’ve heard a lot of people’s spiritual journeys just by being ready to listen and accept them. And lots of visitors to my church have been to another UU congregation somewhere and/or have been to our website, so know something about our religion.

  10. The first three times that I visited a UU church only the minister spoke to me. Breaking through took determination. And unfortunately Bill, even Chicago suburban churches can be snooty (at least fifteen years ago that was the case.) One of the leading members of the suburban Chicago church where I did my internship said that one had to be assertive to become a UU. Meaning that we will ignore anyone who is not. It was a great attitude for visitors to encounter.

    What is really saddening is when a minister tells me about being the guest preacher at a church and a no one spoke to her after the service at the coffee hour. [It’s funny you should say that, Larry, because one of the PA churches you served was such a congregation! I preached for them in 1998 or so and was assiduously ignored by everyone at coffee hour… until a few people realized that I was the preacher and turned their saccharine attention to me. Wouldn’t step foot in the joint again. I know you found them a warmer group when you served them years later. – PB]

  11. How about being the supply priest and having no one at the service tell you that coffee hour is being hosted? No announcement, no notice in the worship bulletin, no verbal invite, nothing. I went to the sacristy with the altar guild and put my things away when someone brought up a cup of coffee and a muffin for the altar guild.

    It happens everywhere. Time to change the dynamic for the next generation!

  12. I remember when we would be on vacation and my children were small – we would visit a church and they would be ALL OVER us (every church once a young family with children) then when they found out I was a pastor (and therefore was not new fresh blood for them) they were TOTALLY uninterested. Also this happened when my husband was alive. When it was just me with my kids, not so interested.

  13. My worst one was when visiting another city, during the Peace part of a service: turned to shake someone’s hand and say, ‘Peace be with you’ and they spun round abruptly and walked away. As I was a total stranger and hadn’t done anything to them, I assume they had just spotted a long-lost friend and hared off without considering how incredibly rude that looked.

    They’re desperately short of ministers in that area, so if I ever get ordained I shall get my revenge by taking on a post there and holding three hour services in Latin until the air is deoxygenated with all the incense. (OK, not really.)

  14. @mdh

    I’d claim “newbie priviledges” like mad for the next wee while. Something like: “I’m sorry, I haven’t been here for long enough to have got to know everyone yet – are you a regular or are you new too?” With your absolute best smile.

  15. @Joan: LOL!

    @Joelle: I have the same experience with the “coffee hour attack” (my husband and I are in our early 30s and have a 2-year-old). I sometimes wear my collar when I go to church on vacation solely to send the message, “I’m already in the club, I get paid to be elsewhere most Sundays, please don’t pressure us to join the choir!”

  16. Most of the parishes who advertise themselves as “friendly” are friendly–to each other. They just aren’t friendly to people they don’t know. It is almost impossible to get this through their heads. I have learned to run the opposite way when a parish describes themselves as a family. This means they don’t want outsiders.

  17. OK, I have the opposite problem, inherited from my Mom.

    I say hello to someone, and IMMEDIATELY the festival of inappropriate sharing begins. Total strangers will tell me the intimate details of their lives, all while standing in the line at the Safeway.

    This problem is doubled when you are a music minister at a large parish.

    My day job is also rather unusual, but everyone’s heard of it. Many people end up wanting to share what they know and occasionally want to tell me how to do my job better.

    On the flip side, I’ve been shunned out of parishes, and as it says in the Gospels, “shake the sand from your sandals and move to the next town.” But please feel free to come back if it was me – I might have just had an exhausting counseling session, unprepared.

  18. What seems like ‘friendly’ to the ‘regulars’ can often seem ‘clique-y’ to newcomers, visitors, or those who attend only sporadically. The ‘family feel’ of some congregations can be very off-putting to some, either because they feel excluded as not part of the ‘in’ group, or because they feel overwhelmed by subtle and not-so subtle pressure to become ‘one of us’. How do we strike the balance and have the caring, family feel AND welcome those from the outside/fringe?

  19. PB, I think that we’re talking about the same congregation. [Oops! My bad! 😉 – PB]

  20. My favorite question when I don’t know how long someone has been coming, or if they know me but I don’t know them, is “How was your week?”

    It’s more specific than “How are things” (usually, “fine”) but less risky than introducing yourself only to be reminded that you had a conversation with that person a month ago and they’ve been a member for two years.

    Usually people will share something specific in response, either good or bad, but it’s a neutral question that gets people engaged, whether it’s their first time visiting or are the Pillar of the Community. [I like that! Thanks! – PB]

  21. I was surprised to discover in a previous call in a parish in a small church in a small town that people who had been worshiping side-by-side for years didn’t know each other’s names. They had long ago passed the stage of being able to ask a familiar face, what’s your name or what do you? We started having name tag Sunday once a month or so. The trick was to have people write their name AND their answer to some fun question on a nametag. (What’s your favorite hymn? What kind of animal would you like to be? etc.) The questions gave people who seemed to know each other an excuse to go and look at the nametag of someone they seemingly “knew” and strike up a new conversation.

    It also provided a way for people to talk to each other that wasn’t related to work. [NICE! Thanks! – PB]

  22. I am loving all these suggestions of conversation starters for talking to people! With you permission, I’d like to use them with my congregation, as I am in the process of encouraging them to build their hospitality practices. I am fortunate to serve a congregation that genuinely wants to be welcoming and is thrilled when new folks find their way in, but hasn’t yet learned the intentional skills that help others become find where they belong in the body. For me, it is very much a task oriented around lay people. My senior pastor and I do the hand-shake thing after every service, and, as it is possible, make contact with visitors in the week following their first and second visits, outside of the Sunday madness. Which brings me to the other reason I am commenting. –
    It pains me to think not only of all the times parishioners have failed to notice the stranger, but also to recount the number of times that, from across a crowded coffee time, I have watched a guest get their coffee, drink it and leave ungreeted, all while I am uncomfortably cornered by one parishioner or another, or darting to take care of urgent/immediate details (ok, putting out fires). I own my responsibility in this matter and ask for your suggestions to get out of such “cornered” moments, and also, beg that people be aware that the pastor cannot be everything for everyone all on Sunday morning.

  23. I wonder if their ridiculous seminarian insularity had something to do with them all knowing EXACTLY who you are and their not being interesting in being subjected to a judgmental condescending rant on a blog. [Nice try, but this was years ago. Way before BTFM. – PB]

    You are not unknown. Your Seminarian Advice is consistently mean spirited and unduly harsh. I know people you have made cry. I attend another seminary but when I have occasion to be at ANTS, I’m hardly eager to let you see my outfit or to discuss my vastly inferior thoughts.

    Perhaps their ignoring you is a bad sign about their future careers, but your example as an experienced pastor troubles me.

Comments are closed.