I don’t care, I’m going to say it.
A BTFM reader has just alerted me to an ordination invitation sent out by a minister-to-be over FaceBook that is a big joke. The text says something like, “Can you believe it? The __________ Church has gotten so desperate that they have even accepted So-And-So to be a member of their clergy! This must be the end of the world as we know it!” The graphic shows a church on fire.
The invitation didn’t go out to a few close friends, it went to hundreds of people in that faith tradition and beyond (and I need to send up a little praise to God that this is not my own faith tradition).
I cannot say strongly enough that I think this is in the worst possible taste and literally disgraceful. It should be pulled down immediately and replaced with something dignified and decent. It’s not funny, it’s tacky and immature and obnoxious and it disgraces the office of minister.
I question the judgment of any clergyperson who finds it appropriate to make a mockery of their own calling in such a manner, not to mention the incredible insensitivity of posting an image of a church in flames as a “funny” accompaniment to the puerile invitation.
Please don’t tell me to lighten up. My humor credentials are very much in order, thank you very much, and this is just a FAIL.
[Update: I just saw the actual FB invitation and it is even more appalling than I expected. The graphic of the burning church is an actual photograph of a church in flames, obviously Photoshopped. It astonishes me that this ordinand hasn’t received a barrage of complaints from his many loving friends who have replied that they will or won’t be able to attend. We protect such jack-assery at our own peril. – PB]

Amen! There is no defending this one…
And then we wonder why the folk in the pew don’t respect clergy….
Good lord, yes, that is totally, totally inappropriate. FB ordination invites are routine among my acquaintance, but they are just as regimented as the paper ones: you copy and paste the standardized text (which begins with “By the grace of God and with the consent of the people …”) and the picture is of a descending dove, or something.
Sheesh.
That is awful. Were I a Bishop I would cancel the ordination immediately.
Oh, please don’t let it be my faith tradition either!!!!
yeah, I’m with you.
I’m almost speechless.
This is just one more example of setting things in motion without taking the time to deliberate and reflect on possible consequences.
Unfortunately, this has the power to influence negatively the rest of this person’s ministry.
It should be pulled down immediately and replaced with an apology first, then with something dignified and decent.
If this was a someone being ordained in a congregational-polity “home church” I’d decline the offer and seek ordination in a first call, if that was an option. [Nope, not a congregational polity tradition. – PB]
Besides the insult to the congregation and the ministry profession in general…well, a church I attended as a child burned to the ground several years ago. I happened to drive by as it was still smoldering. a church on fire is nothing to joke about. It can be as traumatic as a house fire.
There are some life events that need to be treated with deep seriousness, even if they are joyous occasions–I’d say marriage and ordination are high on that list.
Wow, speechless…
It seems to me that the bigger issue is that this new clergy doesn’t have the confidence to “own” their call, and is making a joke in an “aw, schucks, little ‘ol me??” sort of way. Its inappropriateness is nearly (but not quite) overshadowed by a worry about what is going on with this candidate that they cannot be serious and confident about this. . .
That is so incredibly offensive–to the ordinand, to the calling church, to the denomination, to the office of the pastor. Yuck.
Solemnity is dead.
Ugh! I saw the real thing on FB (via your post there) and it looks like an invite to a frat party. Caroline Divine is not amused.
Carol, not in the Episcopal Church. 🙂
[Neither is the ordinand, dear. – PB]
I was thinking at the first read that this was a ‘friend’ of the ordinand who was trying to be funny. My impression now is that the ordinand sent this. In any case, unbelievable and totally inappropriate…but particularly if it is the latter.
A graduate of my seminary was called to a church that actually did burn down from being struck in an electrical storm shortly after she started. I hope that after everything else she’s had to work through in that ordeal that she doesn’t happen across this gross Facebook post. [I served a church that burned down and was rebuilt — ten years later the trauma was still felt, even though they got a beautiful, new building that better suited their needs out of the tragedy. Just tasteless. Tasteless. – PB]
This is indeed awful. It’s odd the way the respondents seem to overlook it. I was once at a dance recital during the Harvard 350th celebration. A dancer wearing just a codpiece had the unfortunate snap of the elastic and he finished the long dance with the codpiece affixed down one thigh and nothing over his dingle dangle region. No one reacted or even mentioned it afterward. Ironicallly, I believe he was the white whale in a dance based on Melville’s Moby Dick. So, the RSVPs don’t seem to mention the obvious.
The only positive thing about this is that it caused you to coin a fabulous new word – “jack-assery” – which made me laugh and laugh.
I second what beckydv said. This ordinand’s putative attempt to be self-deprecating and “modest” only ends up shining the spotlight (or the burning church light) on himself. Which may well be where he wanted it.
Fella, get over yourself. It’s about Christ and His Church. It’s not about you.
(Though it certainly will be about him if his church hierarchy chooses to act . . . and not in a way he’ll like.)
On the other hand, a wonderful classmate of mine was ordained on April 1, and put the verse about being a fool for Christ on her invitations. I thought that was completely appropriate for her and her ministry. And then there was the classmate who chose as the main scripture for her deacon ordination sermon, “And God appointed a worm” for Jonah. Even the lowliest of us are called to important, specific ministry. [I actually think those are sort of funny — and again, it’s so much different when it’s not posted on the internet. The fool and worm quotes are biblical, right? And therefore we might exegete them together during an ordination. While it might seem overly self-deprecating (a trend I find bizarre in ministry, but that’s another topic), at least it’s not jeering and accompanied by violent images of the church in flames. – PB]
I’ve been reading your blog for almost a year and stumbled upon this post just now. Not only is this man a member of my faith tradition, he is also a friend of mine from seminary (and I was invited to his ordination), and I am extremely grateful for his ministry. I think you would be too, if you took the time to get to know him, and I have to question the efficacy (and ethics) of this manner of addressing the FB invitation and your concerns. I understand your concerns, and am not asking you to “lighten up”, but only to reconsider your methods of addressing them. I don’t think it’s fair that you attack his character on your rather public blog when he isn’t invited to respond.
[I think this is a fair concern, and highlights some of the challenges of our new world of social media. Let me respond on a few points: first of all, part of what BTFM does is to lift up some of the “crimes” of public image committed by any and all of us, bring them to the clergy community for critical analysis, and make decisions together about whether they are inappropriate or appropriate for our work and our role in society. I, of course, am the convener and Chief Critical Analyst in this work and must make the executive decisions about what we look at. I have decided that we should fear nothing, look at everything — including bras and pantylines and toe fungus — and not shy from any subject of ministerial image. Although your friend’s invitation veers into the realm of ministerial conduct, which is a subject I try only to skim the surface of and only insofar as conduct is connected to presentation of self/clergy image, I decided that his invitation was appropriately considered in the category of Clergy Image especially because he makes such an egregious insult to his tradition in his invite, a big no-no for professional image. He set such a terrible, insulting example of What Not To Do that I was actually grateful he was naive enough to make his blunder public. Of course I left out his name and even the detail of his religious tradition but again, because his invitation was public (his biggest mistake right there), he was fair game for discussion. Finally, your friend’s example is a fantastic reminder to all of us that although we personally love each other, there are times when we have to confront inappropriate behavior. I find it shocking that dozens of people would respond to that invitation on FaceBook and that none of them would say, “Dude, I love you, but a church in flames? Kind of not funny, eh?” I can only hope that the ordinand’s besties might have done so in a private comment, but I saw days later the invite was still blazing away for all to see. So many of us are wonderful people but the whole point of this blog is to train us to be aware that when make big, public mistakes that degrade our office, that’s what the public sees. And in that public realm, it’s not about the small beloved community that knows and forgives, it’s about the image of the Church in society to which we are also accountable. I’m afraid that your friend has dealt a very low blow to his tradition, to the ordained ministry, and to the historic Church (and most egregiously harmful to those churches that have perished in fires). He needed to be called out on it. I hope to God he takes his obligations to the larger Church more seriously in the future. Welcome to the new world of how social media works: it’s not a protective community. If you make something public, prepare to have it discussed in public. Here endeth the lesson (for the ordinand, not for you). Thanks for writing. – PB]
First, I would like to thank Elizabeth for being bold enough to be the “voice of dissent” (never an easy task) as well as thank PB for clearly taking much time and thought in responding.
Now, I want to make it clear that I agree on two points:
First, the invitation was a “big no-no for professional image”. It is beyond problematic to people’s personal sensitivities not to mention, as was noted by a few, those churches that have suffered fires. I was surprised to see that the more egregious offense of church bombings was not mentioned. Now I’m not sure how much of an offense it was to the “Historic church”… we the church are very capable of tarnishing our own image without much help, but you’re right- it certainly could be offensive, and clearly was.
Second- the invitation being “public” invites public criticism. Duly noted and clearly taken advantage of (and I do not mean that in a negative sense).
However, I do side with Elizabeth and question the efficacy of only taking the measures that were taken- namely to write about this on a blog. Yes, it was a PUBLIC invite, which I believe means that anyone (you, myself, your readership… if internet subscribers are referred to as “readership”) could have responded to him and stated their disappointment and insult. It seems, reading above, that nobody chose to do that.
“And in that public realm, it’s not about the small beloved community that knows and forgives, it’s about the image of the Church in society to which we are also accountable.” Okay, understood- but isn’t it really both? Aren’t we, representatives of the church, always supposed to model both criticism and forgiveness? How can we change the hearts and minds of folk if we are not actually inviting them into the conversation?
What I read above is thoughtful criticism. But at the end of the day, the final outcome just seems to be a bunch of people noting frustration and wiping their collective brows that this person is “not in my denomination”. Is this really the way to be in conversation with one another? And can we really make effective and important change if we are not?
Again, by entering into the public sphere, we were given the ability and invitation to speak to someone whom we disagree with. It’s not often in any part of life that we are given the chance to do that with integrity and respect. However, to my understanding- no one did do that. And the decision to write to our own personal audience and waive the chance to enter into real dialogue and mutual learning experiences seems to me too to be a “horrible use of technology”.
I realize that this does not come off as a humble opinion and perhaps it isn’t. But I do pray that when we find something that we see as harmful to the church, that we gladly confront it, instead of whispering to our friends about the great offense of it all.
With respect,
Jonah.
[Thanks, Jonah. To be honest with you, I thought long and hard about responding directly to the ordinand. However, part of what happens when you create a public image of extreme sarcasm, disrespect and insult, it does not invite direct conversation. I frankly did not think it would do anything but earn me a snarky, dismissive reply. So I didn’t risk it. There are so many links that readers send me of faux pas made by clergy that are obviously made in an earnest spirit. These include unbelievably tasteless and ugly vestments, culturally appropriated symbols used in inappropriate and unintentionally insulting or religiously incorrect ways, and the occasional “oh my God i can’t believe you wore that” photos. I will, on occasion, write a note to such folks telling them that someone forwarded their photo to me and that I want to gently point out that one does not wear a yalmulke while preaching on Passover unless one is Jewish (I’m making up an example but you get the jist). Sometimes folks respond, sometimes they tell me to sod off, sometimes we have a great conversation. I myself have been criticized and attacked on folks’ websites, too, and I always let them know I’m listening in. This case was so particularly remarkable because the individual made it his key point to let folks know in a public way that he was mocking his own ministry, his own denomination and the church (and thank you for your point about fire-bombings — I was certainly thinking about arson fires when I shuddered at the image), thereby setting himself up as a person who sneers at protocol in general. To my mind, there is no point of entry in that conversation. I have to think that my readers felt the same way. Who wants to wade into a conversation with someone who is so far off the mark as to cause observers of his error to think, “Oh my heavens, thank the good Lord I’m not associated in any way with this clown?” Sad but true. I think many of us felt personally violated. When you take a dump on the floor of your shared home, I don’t know how you would expect conversation about it. Just clean it up, and fast, and figure out why in the world you were felt entitled to do something so ugly. Work it out with a spiritual advisor or something… the internet in this case could only condemn. The remedy must come from private effort. There comes a point at which a respectful response seems like just so much coddling of an obnoxious child. Sometimes the community has no obligation but to say STOP IT. – PB]