Frou-Frou Does Not Necessarily Equal Appropriate or Attractive: Or, “Don’t Fear the Suit”

Aloha, cookies.
I got another letter tonight that’s got me thinking about a mistake I think a lot of us gals are making in the way we think about looking professional and polished.

It’s about our attitude towards suits, and our lack of understanding of what I will generically refer to as “sportswear separates.” The writer of the letter has been invited to attend a special inter-faith event and has been asked to wear her clericals. She says she is thinking about wearing a pretty tunic in a feminine pattern with a mid-length skirt because she wants to avoid wearing a suit and she wants to look “pretty and feminine.”

And immediately, without even seeing the tunic, I grimace. And I think, “NAW. She should wear the most classic, beautiful, tailored pieces in her wardrobe and snazz them up with a pair of amazing shoes and a great make-up and hair job. And a super clutch bag.”

That is ALL you need, darlings. You are a CLERGY PERSON. GET OVER IT. We do NOT need to make it our first priority to look “pretty and feminine” at special events!!!!!!!

Did I yell that loud enough?
We should NOT try to dress for clergy appearances in the way that we would dress for a friend’s birthday party or a night out with our kids or Significant Other. We are there as clergy, and yes, we’re women.
What you want to look is polished, elegant, confident, handsome, and eminently photographable. You want to look like someone who could give an articulate, thoughtful quote to a newspaper reporter or appear on camera to present a religious perspective on the occasion.
Okay??

Print this out and pin it up on the wall in your closet. This is important.

I hear this a lot: “I don’t want to wear a suit because I want to look pretty and feminine.”
When I hear this I cringe, because so often what a female minister chooses in lieu of structured, tailored and classic looks is (1) tacky (2) frumpy (3) made of cheap fabric (4) too fussy and (5) unflattering. This is where we make our biggest errors. I see it again and again.

PeaceBang would much rather see you wearing a fantastic, well-fitted, well-made, classic suit and the same few basic wardrobe pieces for YEARS than she would see you in all the busy-flowy-“feminine” garments that we’re prone to buy when we have to step up our attire for a special event.

GET RID OF IT ALL. Unless you know how to master hair and make-up, it’s just going to look frumpy.

I think this may be one of the most important columns I’ve written in a long time, because I am just starting to figure out what’s so very wrong with clergy attire: not only are too many of us prone to looking tired, sloppy, unkempt, hippie-esque, dated, frumpy and just plain blah, we mostly do not understand that dressing up not only requires lovely garments, it requires lovely grooming and a touch of glamour.

I’m sorry. Kick and hiss and spit and yell, but it does. It just DOES. A woman with lank hair and no make-up except mascara and lip gloss looks unfinished and inappropriate at a dressier event.

And women ministers do this all the time: they slap on a “fancy” jacket or frou-frou blouse and think they’re all done up. It doesn’t work that way. It doesn’t matter how old you are or how great your skin is or how beautiful you are inside: if your hair and make-up (or for men, skin and hair) and shoes and hose and accessories and bag and posture and the whole picture aren’t polished and attended to, you will be far better off sticking to a black suit and clericals. In fact, I absolutely encourage you to adopt that as your uniform for all occasions if you refuse to put any effort or thought into the other items on the list I just enumerated. Wear a black suit and make sure it is impeccable in fit, style, and make and that it is dry cleaned frequently and you will look TOTALLY presentable. You will look handsome and elegant and like you know who you are. Just make sure the shoes are shined and that they’re not Cobbie Cuddlers. There is not a thing about an austerely groomed woman that communicates anything but self-respect and dignity. You still have to be groomed (hair shampooed and nails clean, etc.), but you can dispense with anything else and look totally right. That collar, my dears, makes the statement for you. It says, “I’m here for Jesus Christ. That’s why I wake up in the morning. So go look at someone else if you want a fashion fix. I’m not trying to be that.”

If you opt for this look — that is, the classic suit, sturdy but shiny shoes, well-groomed but not adorned or concerned with fashion- look — you still need to be savvy about that one suit you’re using as your uniform. Make it The Best you can afford. Choose the style carefully. It needs to fit you so elegantly that it looks like it grew on your body. You want to look iconic, not generic.

The trouble happens when someone with no clue about presentation goes out and buys a “great dress” or “super cool jacket” for a special event and then has no idea how to style the whole look, or even that she needs to. That’s how frumpy happens, and it happens all the time.

The problem with suit jackets isn’t that they look masculine or business-y, it’s that most of you gals aren’t shopping with any understanding of what to look for and wind up with some boxy, horrid thing that only “fits” to the extent that you can get everything buttoned and the arms aren’t too long or short. But my gosh, that’s not FIT, that’s just size. Getting a good fit means that the cut works for YOUR body. The seams are in the right place on the shoulder. The darts don’t run up into your bosom. There’s a waistline that defines your shape. The collar and cut are flattering. You’re not just settling. The details are in proportion to your size (no tiny buttons on large women – no big cuffs and buttons on a petite gal’s jacket).

I know it’s hard, gals. I really do. One of the reasons I shop for clothes is that I have such a difficult time finding anything that I think looks even remotely decent on me that I’m always on the prowl. If I was a size 6 I would absolutely be wearing a great pair of dark denim jeans, boots, black mock turtleneck and a perfect black blazer EVERY day with super short hair, great make-up and silver hoop earrings. That would be my uniform. When I think of all the nonsense in my closet I could smack my dog, I really could [never!!!]. The many garments are there not so much because I love clothes but because I’m too fat to find clothes that I really WANT to wear. I suspect that’s the same for all of us. However, if you’re not a really difficult size (20 petite, for example!!), I would think it extremely worthwhile to spend the time finding pieces that are Just Right and never buying anything that isn’t. It may take you a year to find the absolutely perfect black top with the sequin detail and a high-enough neck but once you do, you will be taking that sucker out six times every holiday season and wearing it with your black suit and huge rhinestone pin.

It is not vain to spend a few entire days at the outlet mall searching for the perfect trench coat and charcoal grey blazer if you’re going to be wearing them almost every day each autumn for years.

But please re-consider tailored separates and re-orient your thinking about dressy events from “Oh, I need something pretty and girly” to “I need something elegant and classic which I will make as pretty as I need to by paying special attention to my nails, hair, make-up and accessories.” If you do this, you can make it through the year with one suit (or really good looking jackets and pants or skirts separates) and one or two dressy details. You are a minister. You can wear the SAME, EXACT outfit to every event with no worries or shame. You are not trying to be a fashion plate or to keep up with the latest trend in frills (which, this year, is big bows). What you want to be is current AND classic, which isn’t hard to do if you go with the very best pieces you can find. Certain cuts and fabrics never go out of style. Learn which ones flatter you, acquire them as investments, and wear them to EVERYthing. Swap up your bags or shoes as you like and keep yourself connected to a great hair stylist and manicurist.

I have one more bit of advice. When in doubt, go take out every patterned piece of clothing in your wardrobe. Put the pile in another room. Now take out every garment whose color could never be found anywhere in nature, in any part of the globe. Give those garments away. Take a look at what remains. Everything there should fit well, be made well, and have classic, flattering lines for you. If they don’t, get rid of them. Stick for awhile with what’s left. Stay with solids. Study the lines and fit of what you’re wearing on a day to day basis. This will make you rely on grooming and accessorizing to feel attractive. Don’t rely on busy patterns or flowy garments to do that for you. If you do this you’ll start to educate yourself about how to work with your own looks to be at your best.

Now go be fierce for Jesus.

16 Replies to “Frou-Frou Does Not Necessarily Equal Appropriate or Attractive: Or, “Don’t Fear the Suit””

  1. I learned something the hard way: even the best suit probably won’t fit off the rack. find the cut and fabric you like, pay the ridiculous amount you must for it, get it a little big, then pay more to have it tailored to fit you. if you don’t like suits, it is probably because don’t have one that really fits right.

    One more thing. get a nice coat to go with the suit. It can be from goodwill (I got a good raincoat on ebay for 52 dollars plus shipping) but it needs to fit right over the suit.

    The thing about having one or two good dressy dresses to wear everywhere is so true. Have courage! This is what men do all the time.
    Thanks for saying this. It is hard, but true. It must be said, over and over. I must say it to myself again.

  2. I agree, especially for those of us who are younger. We already have to earn respect from people in a different way – looking put-together only helps this cause, in my opinion.

    I have clericals in simple, classic colors (black and blue) and wear those with black pants. I wear different jackets (depending on the occasion) which are stylish and flattering, but not too flashy, and it works. Do I love wearing black pants that much? Not really. But I’m the most confident and comfortable professionally in them, so I keep doing it because it works for me.

    By the way – do people ask men clergy to wear a certain outfit to events? Just curious. [In this case, she wasn’t asked to wear a certain outfit, she was asked to wear her collar. But it’s still a good question. – PB]

  3. PB, This is why I come to your blog! Everyone should read it. As a grad student I see a lot of bad dressing: both my students who confuse leggings with pants and my profs who only wore a suit for their interview. And even then it didn’t fit them very well. Thanks for letting me vent. And for showing that women should feel confident in their positions of authority.

  4. 😀

    Ahhhhhhhhh . . . now I feel MUCH less guilty about spending all that money on that black suit, dress and slacks.

  5. “Certain cuts and fabrics never go out of style” – yes! The photo you have at the bottom right (dark jeans, velvet blazer, great scarf)is a perfect example of this. That look is always in style no matter what.

    And PB, I love your description of your perfect uniform – who cares that you’re not a size 6? Those clothes would look great on you! I think it’s quite flattering when everything is cut well, no matter your size. [ I would! I would! If I could find the pieces, I would!! I am always on the look-out, though. – PB]

  6. I love what you say here- “You want to look like someone who could give an articulate, thoughtful quote to a newspaper reporter or appear on camera to present a religious perspective on the occasion.”

    If you look the part (wearing a suit) and someone, who is expecting the clergy to be male, comes up to you and says “Have you seen the minister?”, then its not your fault, its theirs.

  7. I second Gina’s comment; I do not see why the dark denim, blazer, turtleneck, boots and hoop earrings look would not work for you. It’s a structured look, clean lines, I think the key would be the same advice you give above, finding a blazer that is cut just right (a difficult task, I know — it takes me ages to find jackets that do not make me look like a linebacker or that do not hit me right at that line on my midriff that prompts tactless people to ask when I’m due).

  8. “The trouble happens when someone with no clue about presentation goes out and buys a “great dress” or “super cool jacket” for a special event and then has no idea how to style the whole look, or even that she needs to. That’s how frumpy happens, and it happens all the time.”

    Oh shoot, I think that’s me — especially the “or even that she needs to” bit. I’ve always been a chinos and mock turtleneck person. Recently, though, I’ve made an effort to be more aware of my appearance. It now occurs to me that I’ve likely bought stylish pieces that I don’t know how to style. Or, rather, that I didn’t realize that the clothing doesn’t do the styling. I do. The idea that there is a difference between size and fit comes as a revelation to me. Argh.

    Now, how exactly do you learn this stuff? I mean, really, how do I avoid making stupid mistakes? Maybe I need to find a brutally honest friend to go through my closet!

  9. Amen. I wear the hell out of my black/grey pinstriped Calvin Klein suit. Every funeral, lots of Sundays – sometimes just the jacket with dark jeans during the week.

    And I spent a shocking (to me) amount of money on good dress boots the first year I was in full time ministry. Like, more than my new bike money. But those boots have been fabulous; waterproof, dressy, stylish, good grippy sole and just the right amount of heel to wear all day if needed.

    I’ve got the fun pieces too, but even there I lean towards structured pieces, or wraps/shawls to wear with all the basic black that is the backbone of my wardrobe.

  10. advice that holds true for all women, imo. not just clergy. a good reminder for me as we head into budget/annual meeting time as the youngest female council president in our churches history (who is going to make waves by proposing giving away huge chunks of $$, but needs a congregational vote of approval first…)

  11. Quite possibly one of your best posts ever, PB. Printing this one out for my frequent reference.

    When I graduated from college (four years ago!), the first thing my mother did was take me to find The Perfect Suit. It is made of classic black separates from Banana Republic, with a skirt (knee length, A-line) and trousers. I forget the fabric, but it’s four-season wearable. It cost a pretty penny, but I paid for half with graduation gift money, and my mother ponied up the other half. When the jacket became too large (losing all my college weight, hurrah!) I went back to Banana Republic and got a similar style– but this time in black AND white. The white jacket is amazing in summer and to polish up dresses.

    I have another two blazers- one in deep teal velvet, another in a light pink tweed- that I use all year long. Bargain hunting on the accent blazers: the teal one was an expensive Nine West blazer (that fits me like a DREAM) that I got at Marshalls, and the pink one is an unexpectedly well-constructed piece from Old Navy. I pair them with trousers or jeans and they immediately polish up a look. It’s 110% worth the investment.

    One thing I’ve recently come to adore: scarves. Plain trousers, blah long-sleeved tee shirt (left over from college; my current income is still pinched tight)– and what else? A necklace? Sure, a big, bold, statement necklace will boost the outfit, but a FABULOUS scarf creates a polished, interesting, feminine look. Easy to find, easy to fit, and often not that expensive. VOILA.

  12. As far as how to learn how to style? I certainly recommended this blog to someone recently. I have a lot of latitude, since I am not clergy, and am a freelancer, but I’ve found a few style blogs I like.

    As with here, I don’t always agree with the blogs, but they have been valuable in steering me in the right direction, including encouraging me to be a bit more adventurous. An important thing for me to remember as I’m trying to figure out how to style myself is that since I’m trying new stuff (eg, different styles of clothing or different combinations), it’s not always going to work out right. But that’s the way it goes when you’re taking chances.

  13. Ok, I really enjoyed the article, and I believe you are right on, until I got to the pictures at the bottom. As with all fashion advice people, you tell us to fit our bodies, then show models who are all 5’8″ and a size 0!!! I have a great deal of difficulty fitting my body, and yet I NEVER see a model who is 5’2″ with a bit of a belly but nice legs. When we do see a ‘plus’ size model, her issue is almost always hips and thighs and not belly. Ok, I’ll get off my pulpet now. I do agree that if you can actually find a suit that fits, it should absolutely be the staple of your wardrobe.
    [I know, I know, Joyce. But here’s the thing: there aren’t many great plus-sized images out there to feature, and given that some of these jackets are actually plus-sized and these are the models they’re showing, you have to use your imagination and learn to look with a critical eye, like, “How would this look on ME?” You’re not likely to see a 5’2″ model with a tummy and nice legs (that’s my own body type, by the way). Manufacturers don’t cut clothes to that type, probably never will, and need models who can wear the clothes for catalogues. It’s up to us to get our tailors on the scene and adjust. If I was running this blog like a fashion magazine I would totally get my own models. But this is a volunteer effort and I use what images I can find. Please appreciate and don’t criticize. You get what you pay for.- PB]

Comments are closed.