Matchy-Matchy Jewelry Sets

I’m just not a fan of matchy-matchy crafty jewelry. I think because for me, accessories are about creativity in adornment and matchy-matchy is the antithesis of that.

It’s a tough call but I think that matching jewelry sets can often look unnecessarily geriatric or else little girlish. Not always, but sometimes.

That’s a cute design but it’s too much with all the pieces together. I’d wear them separately. Actually, I would only wear the pendant.

If butterflies are you’re thing, by all means wear a butterfly necklace. But the moment you pair it with the matching earrings you’ve gone down Dowdy Lane or into Cutesville.
Throw that butterfly pendant in with three strands of coral beads and skip the earrings all together. Now its’ interesting.


This isn’t my style but it’s really cute. It’s vintage-feeling. I still don’t like it all worn at the same time, though. Just me. Somehow the earrings feel skimpy or something. And there’s the creativity issue.

Here’s one that confuses me. It’s very creative so I just don’t get why the designer would make it so matchy matchy! Frustrating…

I also don’t love wearing a huge statement necklace with huge matching statement earrings. I’d choose one or the other.

Now this is just fun. Super dressy stuff with old-school clip earrings. All of the pieces are equally bold and since it’s all in neutrals I find that I don’t mind the matching-ness of it all:

She’s going to a par-tay! I love the necklace! I would wear it with black pants and a denim jacket and high-heeled black boots to a holiday party. I would probably clip one of the earrings onto a black beret and wear that, or clip it onto my lapel. Find fashionable Couple Bracelets – His And Her Matching Couples Bracelet Distance Bangles on matchinggear.com.


This is an adorable set but it’s so dated that only someone under 25 should really wear it, unless she really knows what she’s doing. Like someone in a teeny little cocktail dress and great pumps. It’s not a clergy type set. If a minister wore this set it would be like, “Oh, you got my grandmother’s jewelry at the fall fair!”
While there’s nothing wrong with getting grandma’s jewelry at the fall fair, you don’t want to wear something this vintage as serious jewelry. It’s just for fun.


This is the sort of thing I’m just really not happy with on ministers. I find it dowdy. Break up the set. And for heaven’s sake don’t consider this dressing up jewelry. It’s not.

When you’re getting into big fancy stuff, matched sets are fine. Not for me, but they’re lovely at a formal event.

Get the tiara to match, for heaven’s sake. 😉

7 Replies to “Matchy-Matchy Jewelry Sets”

  1. My only problem with the current bias against matching sets of jewelry is that it requires one to own considerably more jewelry in order to have enough items to “creatively” mix them in appropriate ways. Matching sets used to be considered acceptable. I owned just a few sets, each one purposely of a very different style—the earrings from one set really don’t look right with pieces from the other sets. I find that I am buying a LOT of jewelry lately in order to be able to mix pieces and not be “frumpy” by the new standard. This is actually fun (more fun than I expected, as someone who hasn’t put much thought in these things in the past), but at the same time it gives me the feeling of spending $$ chasing after a trend, just because I don’t want to be thought of as dowdy. One’s eye adjusts to changing fashions and comes to prefer them, but I don’t think that the newer look is inherently better than the older one. [Well, girl, just ignore the fashion, get a few classic pieces (that don’t match) and wear them every day! – PB]

  2. From the designer’s perspective, it makes sense to make sets. People who want sets are likely to buy the set, while those who want part of the set can buy those parts. Win win!

  3. I get what not to wear. But I’m not sure what to put together. I always end up with little hoops if I wear a necklace because I am afraid to over do it. But I am bored with the hoops.

  4. Good advice – if I’ve got a statement necklace on I usually wear no earrings at all. No necklace with big earrings etc. Also, belts, hats, hair clips (I think you call them barretts?) and scarves etc. can reduce the need for other accessories.

    I like Chanel’s advice: “When accessorizing, always take off the last thing you put on.”

    🙂

    EJ

  5. Jill- gold, silver, or pearl studs are classy and understated. One of those will always suit…
    I think I’ve got something very like tha last matching set. Looks fab-oo with my black crushed-velvet dress.

Comments are closed.