Women Do Not Wear Shorts

PeaceBang is Laying Down the Law, pigeons.

Only in the United States of America do grown-up females wear shorts and try to be taken seriously as professionals.

I think this is wrong and bad in every possible circumstance and have said so before.

Shorts are not grown-up wear, and no one over the age of 25 should wear them in a professional capacity. They are undignified in the extreme and completely inappropriate for clergy women.

Skirts and pants come in a huge variety of fabrics and lengths. Don’t come whingeing to PeaceBang about skirts being “torture” and such. That’s pure rubbish.

Women do not wear shorts unless they are doing sports things or on vacation or at the beach.

Period. End of report.

29 Replies to “Women Do Not Wear Shorts”

  1. Sing it, sister.

    It’s ok to wear shorts to work if your work is: camp counselor, softball coach, freelance writer who works at home, park ranger… yeah.

  2. Or if you drive for the Postal Service, FedEx or UPS. Note, though, that the shorts issued for these employees come to just barely above the knee…

  3. “Shorts are not grown-up wear, and no one over the age of 25 should wear them in a professional capacity.”

    This would seem to apply equally to men, who also look completely unprofessional in shorts unless their profession is camp counselor or mail carrier.

  4. Plus, they make me feel like a little German child. I only wear them in my house. [ LOL! But leiderhosen seems like such a *good* look for you! – PB]

  5. I’m with you here. I wear shorts in the house or to work in the yard, preferably the back yard. I think guys for the most part look OK in shorts but I actually find them uncomfortable typically. I have a golf type skort thing that I wear to my kids ballgames a lot that provides the coverage of shorts but looks better.

  6. Okay,point taken. But, how should we handle those times that fall someplace between “professional capacity” and “sports things?” Examples: youth group activities that may involve leading or playing games in which skirts/dresses/dress pants are not pratical. Church picnics, attending the sporting events of youth/children in the congregation as a spectator on a hot evening. These are real situations I wrestle with as a Christian educator and clergy person. [I always recommend dressing for the most formal event of the day and adjust from that outfit as you need to. I also don’t know why “casual pants” isn’t an option for playing games with the youth. Khakis are just fine. I don’t think shorts are, as I’ve already expressed in my not-so-humble way! – PB]

  7. PB – what is your opinion on the capri pants for men look? I’ve recently moved to a new state in the NE and have seen a number of clergymen sporting this look over the summer at ‘casual’ meetings, etc. I think they are goofy looking. Like these: http://www.hautehousecreations.com/product/capris/
    [They’re ridiculous and hideous. Why not just wear pants!? They are so unflattering! Beach only! – PB]

  8. I echo Jenfin’s question. Two difficult fashion challenges for me are: mission trips and street ministry. I’m a lay minister and want to look professional, respectful, and trustworthy. It’s not always easy to do that when you are hauling around a cooler of sandwiches, or else spend the morning riding in the back of a truck and the afternoon at a worship service. [Those are the WORST challenges. What do you mean by “street ministry?” What sorts of activity? – PB]

  9. I accept that most of these rules ARE the way things are, but I continue to be amazed that we’re all being encouraged to just follow along and roll with that. If comfortable and appealing clothing is considered undignified and inappropriate in the professional world, then it’s not our desire to wear comfortable and appealing clothing that needs to change – it’s the stupid asshat rules of the professional world that need to be changed. [I couldn’t disagree more. Not to knock you personally but I find this sort of remark objectionable for its assumptions that inevitably lead to the totally erroneous point that beauty and aesthetics don’t matter. I believe that they do and that they are, in fact, central to civilization itself. – PB]

  10. put me in the naughty corner, pb, because i sit here in starbucks in my “city” shorts, which are pinstriped and thus convinced me they are professional. oops!:)thanks for helping a girl out. [PHOTOS! Are they cute? Are they cut well? Let’s have a look, woman! – PB]

  11. IMO shorts can be a ‘yes’ on mission trips and casual work events like picnics.

  12. I shared a link to this blog entry via Facebook and initiated one of the most passionate exchanges I’ve seen in a long time. I can’t wait until you come and speak in Louisville this September, PB – this event is sure to include some lively discussion! [ OH GOOD!! – PB]

  13. I’d love to hear teh PB response to the picnics/street outreach/mission trips question. These are casual events that don’t call for a “professional” look.

    The big question behind them is, I think, “How do we dress when, as a professional, we attend non-professional events?” When I’m doing ministry with homeless youth, I most definitely am not dressing “professionally.” I’m always going for “appropriate,” but these casual events are always challenging for me as a professional.

    (And we won’t even get into Pride Parades as a pastor!)

    [OK, I will try to respond to this. I was going to point you to the archives, too, but you’re a long-time pigeon and you’ve been part of this conversation. So let’s re-visit it. It’s late in London so it will have to wait. Cheers. – PB]

  14. And now comes the part where I feel like it’s really important to point out that none of the stuff I’ve written here, on Facebook, or Twitter, etc. is the opinion of Leah Bradley, Louisville Seminary, or any person anywhere other than goofy old me, and my attempt to add my opinion wasn’t intended as disrespect to PeaceBang, this blog, my wife, Louisville Seminary, or anyone who holds a different opinion. Beyond that, Aric hit it right on the nose when he wrote that I was not trying to blow off Beauty and Aesthetics, but trying to bring up the idea that Beauty and Aesthetics (and “professionalism”) are not the purview of one culture in one place at one point in history.

    I’m disagreeing with you, not mocking, disrespecting, or ridiculing you. I apologize that my approach toward that end was imprecise, and that what I thought was a simple light discussion has now become a real problem both online and in my own home. [Oh, no! No offense taken by you at all, Mick. These are big questions and I’ve addressed them over a long period of time, and I hope we get more time to talk about them in person. Talk about a hot opener at Louisville! – PB]

  15. Good thing I met PB last winter when I was wearing a tunic, leggings & boots instead of summer when I always wear short shorts & a t shirt when I’m not working. [“When you’re not working” being the operative part of this sentence!! – PB]
    Granted I’m not in ministry the classic dressing required would have driven me nuts but part of this is if you look good in something, why not wear it? If I thought my legs were lousy I’d cover them up.
    I’m with the other people who disagreed with the no shorts idea, I think professional dress codes need to be loosened up too.

  16. If the whole world were the college town where I live and work and do errands on my bicycle, the sartorial issues wouldn’t be so vexing to me. But I’ve worked in Europe (in my distant past) and more recently have done mission work in Brazil, as well as a short trip to Haiti. All of those cultures set great store by personal appearance. [BINGO. Thank you for reminding people of this incredibly important fact — adults in so many other cultures do NOT wear shorts. It would be the height of disrespect for oneself and others. – PB] In fact, the less material wealth people seem to have, the more they spruce up for church and other events that are important to them. The loud floral shirt that says Good Times in the Tropics is an object of derision among Brazilians who see it on gringos. What’s a problem for me is that is that I’m a very sweaty gal, and the two halves of my personality – the half that gets “Appearance as Respect” and the half that would wear anything that wicks perspiration on a hot day – are constantly in conflict.

  17. Forgot to mention something (sorry). When at my office job I don’t wear shorts. I’m also selfemployed and then I always wear shorts in nice weather to work in & go out on sales calls to price jobs. In the winter I wear blue jeans. [Fine with me, I’m writing for clergy here but thanks for writing. – PB]

  18. I wear knee length shorts when it’s unbearably hot outside. I also wore them to our Vacation Bible School where I was running around with children, working with paint, and outside in 100 degree weather. I agree that shorts are not work wear, but they do have their place at certain times. I think capris are unattractive on men and women alike.

  19. I’ll weigh in on this conversation since it was 113 degrees here today, and I walk and use public transportation, so I’m out in the heat often.

    (First, let me say that at 113, even going naked would not be comfortable.)

    Today I wore a knee-length gray skirt and coordinating belt, a crisp white, button front cotton blouse (3/4 sleeve), and a colorful silk scarf, tucked under the blouse collar to keep it off my sweaty neck, and tied loosely in front. It was good for a typical summer weekday at church. After a long bus ride and walking in said heat for a mile to get to a meeting where I was speaking this afternoon, I believe I still looked appropriate for the occasion … and I survived just fine. (Kudos to Lands’ End for no-iron pinpoints!)

    Someone asked about street ministry, which is connected to some of my work, and I live in a neighborhood where I engage with people who are homeless on a daily basis. I dress pretty simply, but find it’s not so much what I wear, but what I don’t wear that matters — no flashy jewelry, no overly bright or “fussy” outfits that say “notice me.” I don’t dress for this ministry, per se, because it’s part of my everyday life, and the simple attire is part of who I am, too. Some days I’m more dressed up than others, but I hope what always comes across is a look of compassion, not fashion. I think a carefully chosen thrift store skirt, a simple Target top and a scarf in a flattering color, for example, can be both respectable and respectful.

    For casual/active occasions (think cookouts, mission trips), I often wear long pants in a “tech” fabric (cool, sweat-wicking), with a solid knit top or button-front blouse with built-in sunscreen, and casual shoes. I think it helps to stick with solid colors, and to wear sleeves.

    Today I saw a woman on the bus who got off and rode her bike wearing a solid maroon, short-sleeved knit top, with a flowing, mid-calf skirt in a subtle maroon print. She looked cool and comfortable – in a look that I believe would be equally at home for an outdoor church social or watching a game from the sidelines.

    [Thanks for contributing a great option, Sr. Twila. – PB]

  20. I don’t THINK anybody else has addressed this — but in the depth of summer, on the prairies, under the cassock and the surplice and the stole and occasionally even the chasuble…this child wears knee-length shorts. In the same solid colour as the clergy shirt. I can promise to re-think it, but not necessarily to come up with a different result. [Under a cassock and a surprlice in those conditions you would find me in a cotton nightie, I think. – PB]

  21. I believe that the capri pants for men are called in an earlier time, clam diggers. Ergo, some kind of work clothes for those gathering bivalves from the sandy shore.

    Not really casual wear, but work clothing. And really about as flattering as capri pants.

  22. Dear PB,
    I know it’s for clergy but I love fashion & I love your blog it is so much more how shall I say personalized than style.com and the other fashion mag web sites. I’m probably far from the only non clergy person on here.
    [OK, I love you too!! I just worry that lay people will think that I am critical of their clothes and I’m just so NOT! I’m so happy that they give what they give to the church and I never want to give the impression that I think shorts are inappropriate for women at all times and in all walks of life. – PB]

  23. I do wear shorts when “off duty” – but they are knee length (both denim and kakhi). I am short so most capris make me look like a hobbit, so I go for bermuda length. I do have one pair of longer beige capris that are very tailored for casual,off-duty wear to places like the zoo and such. My summer work clothes of choice are a skirt and nice knit top for weekdays.

    The other comments in this have raised the question on my mind most right now: how do I dress professionally in an extremely rural community? Especially when I may be doing more farm-related or youth orientated things?

    I’ve noticed this summer that most of the women wear jeans (working and casual) and capris (working, casual and church). Most of the men are in jeans for the work days and casual slacks/polos on Sundays. I am finding that my wardrobe (purchased for slighty rural Ohio) is much more formal than the the local population. And while wearing skirts for most things in the summer work, a skirt is most definately not appropriate doing a visit where I might take a couple of spins around the field on a tractor (which can be pastoral care around here!).

    Peacebang, watch for an email with specific questions!

  24. Loved Sister T’s comments and ideas!

    Regarding long pants in a “tech” or cooling fabric for a casual/active ministry event, if you check out a good quality uniform store that caters to medical people, they have come a loooooong way beyond those kelly green scrubs.

    You can find lightweight professional looking slacks that are durable and that do not cost a fortune. Yes, they are “scrubs” — but you would never know it by looking at them. They have bootcuts and flares, plus some very streamlined looking cargo pants styles, and you can get them in neutrals like charcoal, black, khaki, etc. Plus these are a lot cheaper than the similar tech fabric slacks I see at the sporting goods store.

    Again, I would think these would be appropriate for cookouts, mission trips, that kind of thing. Honestly, though, I was very surprised at how stylin’ some of those scrubs can be.

  25. @anna, what a great idea! I never thought of checking out medical uniform stores for pants that look that good. Thank you

  26. LOL! Yes, PB, I’ve read the vast majority of your archives. On this issue, count me among the unpersuaded, not the uninformed. I love following PB advice for all the times when “professional leader” is the look I’m going for, but I still sometimes believe in “plunging in” with my people-hauling away dirty furniture on a workday, get on the tractor, in the pool, etc, and that sometimes that is different than being, or dressing, “professional.” So I wrestle w/ what “appropriate” is instead.

  27. I am a bit late to the conversation, having been on holidays (yay!). I am guilty, guilty, guilty. I was even ordained in shorts. It was a cream colored suit with knee length shorts. I thought it was unique and professional looking, remaing true to who I was at 27. It was vetted by my most fashionable mom, so I remain unapologetically guilty. These days, I stick to skirts in the summer but I will wear shorts at Family Camp and other such events.

  28. Been reading with interest your thoughts on fashion and style, and I find that I don’t fit into the models you offer. Women are allowed to wear skirts in the summer to stay cool, and men must suffer in long pants? What about women like me who’s gender expression does not conform to typical “feminine” models? I look like a linebacker in a dress. Shorts for me – made of the same nice fabric as my Sunday preaching pants – allow me to be cool in the summer heat and periodic hormonal temperature spikes. Would you really have me wear long pants when it’s 90+ degrees outside, humid as hell and I’m having hot flashes? I think not. Looking professional need not mean wearing clothing that is oppressively uncomfortable. [I think you could be fairly expected to wear pants if skirts aren’t your thing. There are many fabrics that are not oppressively uncomfortable, and really, none of us is working outside in the hot sun all day. We mostly work in air-conditioned settings. I cheerfully insist that gender expression is no excuse for frumpy and unprofessional garb. Neither is menopause. Menopausal women all over the world manage to look mature and respectable and get through hot flashes without resorting to wearing shorts. – PB]

Comments are closed.