Preaching in London, And On Body Dysmorphia

BOY, do I sympathize with you kids who preach without vestments! I’ve been preaching in various London chapels and while the worshipers are generally nicely but casually dressed, some of the settings are quite formal! Stained glass windows and all!

I wouldn’t wear a short-sleeved jacket again — I did this weekend because my long-sleeved blazer was dirty, and you can see that I’m too fat for the short-sleeved jacket and that’s not okay. However, there’s nothing you can do when you’re traveling and have a very limited wardrobe. You just stand up straight, wear constraining undergarments and do your best.

I do like the shoes, though:

We all know about anorexic people who look in the mirror and see fat where there is only a very bony, malnourished body, but of course body dysmorphia goes the other way, too. I say without shame that I obviously have it, as I always feel quite zippy and much, much slimmer in my body than my body actually is, and I’m always absolutely shocked when I see myself in photos or on the move in window reflections on the train or in windows. I don’t berate myself for this anymore, it just it what it is, but I am trying really hard to find ways to join inner image and reality for my health and my image. I generally don’t feel like the plompy plumpster that I am, but there you have it! Plompy Plumpsterina!

Anyway, no longer trusting that I have any clue what I actually look like in action (that doesn’t leave YOU off the hook, pigeons! My eye for your beauty fabs and flaws is unerring — look at all the famous stylists and designers who look a fright! I’m in good company!), I am considering adopting a uniform like Michael Kors’: all black all the time. Black blazer or sweater, black pants, black shirt and have fun with accessories, hair and make-up.

It certainly would be clerically appropriate! And frankly, I am so tired of trying to find things that I think look okay that I’d be happy to avoid the decision-making process for awhile.

I think I’m going to do a weight loss program based on body measurements instead of numbers on the scale. Because frankly, my body has shifted so much without gaining many lbs. that numbers aren’t of interest at this point. This isn’t a call for advice, just a musing aloud. Body dysmorphics-in-the-opposite-direction, let me hear ya! No self-abuse allowed, no meanness to your fine selves, just holla so we know we’re not alone. It’s the dangdest thing, ain’t it?

19 Replies to “Preaching in London, And On Body Dysmorphia”

  1. Yes! I have this also. Very severely in fact. I see something totally different in the mirror than appears in photos and occasional unexpected reflections. A much slimmer and taller person is what I see but am actually a 5’2″ complete plumperina. I have pretty much given up on actually knowing what I look like using mirrors, accepted this disability to see my actual reflection, and try to wear things that people have complimented me on and take photos of outfits I’m not sure of before wearing. Cell phone photos help, although can be disheartening too when I was feeling like I looked amazing and there in the photo? Ms. Plumpy. While I am in a weight loss phase, I am just focusing on goals like fitting into pants I had grown out of a couple years ago and exercising vigorously 4-5 days a week. Because according to the mirror, I look awesome! But healthwise and according to photos, a reality check is that I need to lose a number of lbs. Anyway, sorry to write a novel, but it is so nice to hear of someone else with the same trouble. I have to tell you though that apparently your instincts are good enough so that you generally look fabulous, so no all black wardrobe required. Unless you’re just in the mood.

  2. I have this, too. And it was very helpful for me to really, really realize it…made careful eating much easier. I hope it’s the same for you!

  3. I’d like to give a shoutout to google plus hangouts or any other sort of video chat. I’ve learned more about what makeup looks good on me, what my angles are and all my weird little facial ticks in the last few weeks than I had in the years before that.

    Not all of those lessons have been fun, but I’m starting to translate them to my non-google plus life and think “stop playing with your hair” to myself in non-video-chat situations.

  4. I’m not quite so bad, I have a good idea of what looks good on me, but I do think of myself as 30lbs lighter than I am. I am an ex-dancer/personal trainer, and have just had my second baby and I still see myself as slim. Then I see myself in pictures, and I’m like, “What? No way. That’s gotta be a bad angle.” I’m eating well, and sometime in the next year or so I’ll get back on a good exercise schedule and go on a diet (that’s what it took to lose the baby weight last time). So I feel I’m pretty realistic about the actual size of my body, it’s just in my mind’s eye that I’m the willowy, slim dancer I used to be.

  5. “I am considering adopting a uniform like Michael Kors’: all black all the time. Black blazer or sweater, black pants, black shirt and have fun with accessories, hair and make-up.”

    Would this limit your gift of finding really interesting shoes?

    With a cat and a dog, perhaps black is not such a good idea. I could see becoming very fond of a charcoal heather gray… [I LOVE charcoal grey. Good point. – PB]

  6. I too have this issue – I realize that I am a plumperina, but am always shocked that I am far, far plumper than I think I am when I see myself in a mirror or reflected in a window (I usually tell myself the window reflection is distored, like carnival glass).

    What I really need is a full length mirror!

  7. I have the same reverse body dysmorphia. I actually think you look great in the picture on this post. I can see from how you are holding your arms that you are constrained, but I think the colors and style look great on you. Maybe just a different size.

  8. All-black basics–pants, jackets, skirts, shoes, cardigan–make lots of sense, especially in northern climes. But the bright blue blouse looks so pretty on you, I hope you won’t give up on color all together!
    P.S., I think short-sleeved jackets are inherently dorky-looking, no matter what your size.
    P.P.S. I have a different kind of dysmorphia(dyschronia?). I think I’m 30 years younger than reality and am often shocked by the old woman I see when I glimpse my own reflection.

  9. Oh, those shoes!!! Stunning!!! Could you share what brand they are? Coveting, coveting….

    P.S. Thanks for all the inspiration & food for thought. Your blog is my near-daily go-to whenever I need a break & a breath of fresh air. Thank you!

  10. Dear Peebs –

    Firstly. I think women like listening to your advice about beauty and fashion BECAUSE you don’t have a perfect body and still look great. If you were this style-savvy AND looked like a supermodel, we would just have to hate you.

    Secondly. RE going all black for clothing. The joy and fun and artistry of clothing yourself is something I think you’d miss. Within seconds, perhaps.

  11. I have the same issue. I’m always surprised when I see pictures of myself. Why is it only in pictures or windows or mirrors in passing? I look ok in the mirrors at home.

  12. You wrote: “I generally don’t feel like the plompy plumpster that I am, but there you have it! Plompy Plumpsterina!”

    I’ve been reading your blog from the get-go, PB, and it surprises and troubles me to find you using this hurtful, unnecessary, and derogatory language about yourself. You’re a beautiful woman and a fine priest. Please treat yourself with the dignity you deserve…. so we can do the same for ourselves. We all are struggling with something.

    For a good look at what a plus-size professional wardrobe could look like, you might take a look over at the winter collection at eskandar.com Clearly we can’t afford to buy that stuff, but it is an education in line, color, and coordination. [ Aw, Pamela, I promise I’m not being mean. I’m just irreverent, and I like Plompy Plumpsterina! It’s an affectionate name I would use for my dog, and I think dogs are perfect. Thanks for the tip about Eskandar. I’ll go check ‘er out. – PB]

  13. The body shifting is aggravating, isn’t it? It’s started to happen to me – I guess it’s just the aging process. The scale is the same but stuff is starting to move around a little!

    And I do agree with your assessment that a program based on body measurements rather than weight is more useful, especially if you go with a serious weight lifting program. That’s been my focus for the last month and it’s pretty freeing not to worry about the scale and just look at how my clothes fit.

  14. Will you be interviewing the Rev. Joanna Jepson while in London to discuss vicar fashion? [ No.- PB]

  15. Well I have a similar situation about part of me. After years at the gym, my arms & legs are skinny but my midsection is not (it’s smaller, but not in proportion to the rest of me). I think my stomach looks smaller to other people than it does it me; it’s also hard to find clothes as I can’t wear pants as what fits in one place doesn’t in the other, hence my reliance on shortish skirts & leggings.
    I love the shoes too! They are terrific

  16. Oooh! Oooh! Me! I have that! See, I have a phenomenal mama, who allowed me to grow up without body issues. Now that I’m fluffy, I realize it, but I’m always surprised by the reflection in the store window and by pictures taken of me. [LOL! Oh my god, maybe we have TOO HIGH self-esteem!? Naw, because people were calling me fat when I weighed 110 lbs. in high school. I didn’t have the tall, thin body type that so many of my schoolmates had, and I was a large presence. I think it was the preppy boys trying to keep me down because my theatre and music boyfriends never called me that. Food for thought!- PB]

  17. Yes, I’m body dysmorphic too. After loosing 80 pounds last year, I realized that whether I weight 250 lbs or 180 lbs, when I look in the mirror I see someone who weights about 210.
    I want to help myself see the truth in the mirror. I bought a teeny, tiny bikini on sale for $6. And I’ve taken pictures of myself in it at different weights and different angles. Now I can look at a photo to see my body at 200 or 180 or whatever. It is teaching me to see reality in the mirror, and for that I’m grateful (although the thought of anyone else seeing the photos is horrifying).
    If you don’t use a scale, you can also do a series “Me at size 18” “Me at size 14” etc.

Comments are closed.