YES, I Said That!

This article absolutely made me howl and howl with appreciation, love and laughter.
In it, my friend and colleague, the Rev. Roger Butts of Colorado Springs, responds to the brouhaha surrounding Florida minister Terry Jones’ decision to burn the Koran.

Roger, who gave a 20-minute interview from which this quote was extrapolated, said, “What endures is interfaith cooperation, mutual respect and attempting to understand one another. So (“f” expletive) him.”

I laughed my head off. We’ve all spoken to the press before. We’ve all cringed at being misquoted, taken out of context, and having our words edited so as to make us sound dumb or deranged. Ministers are careful crafters of language: it’s hard to let go of control and let someone else move our words around to suit their editorial needs. A tip to readers: when a reporter calls you, ALWAYS say you’ll call him or her back in ten minutes (don’t give any quotes over the phone). Write up what you want to say and then return the call and read your statement. That way you have something prepared, you’ve had a chance to think about what you want to say, and you can control the content.

However, I think Roger’s is a wonderful quote, eloquent and made even better by the inclusion of the “f-bomb.” Context is everything. Stick with me and I’ll explain.

As you ought to know by now if you’re a regular reader of this blog, I think it is high time that clergy came out of the closet as real people with real anger, who even use ordinary cuss words when there’s cause to do so — and if burning sacred scripture isn’t an opportunity to use the f-word, then I don’t know what is.

Roger’s “f*** him” is shocking and unexpected, and therefore very funny to me: a throwaway line revealing the deep frustration in this pastor’s heart after all that carefully considered beautiful stuff about tolerance and love abiding. Best of all, I bet you a million bucks many readers of the Gazette will say, “Let’s go hear this guy. He sounds refreshingly real.” I know I would. I would make a special trip to listen to a minister who risks saying something decidedly un-clerical to a reporter because, you know, his feelings are actually stronger than his desire to make a pious impression.

I loathe pious impressions. We’re either authentically faithful and religious people or we’re not. The heavenward-gaze and eggshell-prancing behaviors are a sham, a fraud and an obstruction to the building up of God’s kingdom. The people of God can’t be real if their chosen leaders aren’t allowed to be real, and even impolite at times.

“So *** him” is not a kind thing to say about a fellow clergyman, but it shows the world that guess what — religious leaders sometimes vehemently disagree to the point where they lose their patience. Some will say this is another moment in America’s long slide into total incivility but I think not. I wish more of us would dismiss the insanity committed by our colleagues (pedophile priests come to mind, and the bishops who protect them) with just this kind of honest exasperation. I’m not suggesting we should swear in public intentionally, and never from the pulpit, but to keep such slips of polite, respectful language in perspective: what’s worse, the f-word or the act that provoked one of us to let it fly out of our mouths?

Roger is likely to get an equal number of high-fives and disapproving remarks or looks following the publication of this quote, and I have no doubt that he’ll weather whatever reactions come his way with good grace and humor. Parishioners in the contemporary church should know – especially if they seek to be more than insular community centers – that their ministers have a public role to play in society, too, and that their views are understood as their own and do not represent those of the congregation. Nor does Roger speak for, or represent, all Unitarian Universalists. We should not expect him to try to: he was not acting as a denominational representative but speaking for himself and expressing his own opinion. He takes full responsibility and credit for his remarks as we must all do when quoted in the press.

I think he has given us a great opportunity to think about the costs and the benefits of being fully human in our work. Ministers spend so much of our life-blood thinking of just the right thing to say and delivering those words in painstakingly prepared ways — and are often utterly ignored. Our beautifully crafted words so often flow like Muzak over the ears of our listeners. Let something out from the heart now and then, colleagues. Let it out, unedited and uncrafted, and see what happens. Yes, you may earn some disapproval for the occasional blunder (and if you’re a woman, be extra aware of that risk!), but then again… some people just might start listening.

12 Replies to “YES, I Said That!”

  1. Absolutely, clergy are people too. Great advice to call a reporter back once you have collected your thoughts. But, at some times the words just have to fly and the real feelings be expressed, as a person and not a representative of a denomination. Once again, clergy are people too.

  2. If I read it right, Rev. Butts’ “f*** him” was directed toward the lay atheist PZ Myers, not toward fellow minister Terry Jones.

    FWIW, I think Myers is being dishonest to say that he “wouldn’t walk into a church and interfere with someone’s religious ritual”, after having defended Webster Cook so vigorously for doing exactly that. Given that Catholics believe in transubstantiation of the Host, and Muslims believe in the direct divine utterance of the Qur’an, as perceived direct insults to God the two sacrileges are closely equivalent. However, Cook’s actions are arguably even more offensive than Jones’s, since they occurred within and disrupted the host religion’s own worship service. [Good point. – PB]

  3. One of the things I hate, hate, hate about the Koran burning situation is that that seems to be what is being spread in countries like Afghanistan (no wonder they’re angry) and not the thousands of Christians who are saying ‘fuck him we think it’s an apalling thing to do too, don’t judge us all by him’

  4. I got a new member who defected from a generations-long Church of Christ (Noninstrumental–NOT the UCC)to my Episcopal Church because of an article in the local paper in which I caused the proposed amendment to ban gay marriage as an abomination to the Lord.

    On the other hand, I did not preach a “Grow the f*** up, people” sermon at my last service at my former parish, much to my bishop’s relief, although he certainly felt it was understandable.

  5. Somehow “F expletive” comes across as a stronger statement to me than if they had printed the actual word itself.

  6. Speak to us of eyebrows, if you will. Or perhaps just let me rant here. You’ve spoken before about middle aged women having half-brows. I discovered this 8 years ago when I got contact lenses for a brief time. My glass frames had always disguised my lack of browage – at least from me! I learned how to use an eyebrow pencil from a high-pressure, clown make-up peddling Clinique lady, for which I’m forever grateful. But I still see women going about half-browed, or they just add “tails” to their eyebrows in a poorly matched color. These are stylish women who apply the rest of their make-up well. What’s up with these tails? Do they just not see how strange they look?

Comments are closed.