This made me LOL. Gidget writes,
Speak to us of eyebrows, if you will. Or perhaps just let me rant here. You’ve spoken before about middle aged women having half-brows. I discovered this 8 years ago when I got contact lenses for a brief time. My glass frames had always disguised my lack of browage – at least from me! I learned how to use an eyebrow pencil from a high-pressure, clown make-up peddling Clinique lady, for which I’m forever grateful. But I still see women going about half-browed, or they just add “tails†to their eyebrows in a poorly matched color. These are stylish women who apply the rest of their make-up well. What’s up with these tails? Do they just not see how strange they look?
Dear Gidget,
Well, I suppose they just don’t. My favorite is the woman who has dyed red hair and who crayons on a thick auburn brown to MATCH, extending the garish eyebrow pencil far beyond her actual brow. It always makes me want to sit her down and ask her about her days with the Rockettes, because that look always puts me in mind of an eccentric old show biz type.
Brows are tricky. They really are. THEY DO NOT NEED TO MATCH YOUR HAIR COLOR, so stop trying! There are a billion sites you can easily find by doing a Google search that will tell you how to appropriately shape your brows, but for my money I think it’s worth letting a pro do it (I have very sparse brows that need filling, not plucking, so I don’t do this but I think others could really benefit from a shaping). It’s a $10 investment (maybe $20 if you go to some fancy joint) and you can keep up with the clean-ups yourself, so I think it’s worth looking into. A scraggly brow can really change your expression, while an over-plucked brow can give you a look of permanent surprise. And as Gidget notes, a weird “tail” drawn at at the end of your brow is just alarming.
I am not a fan of eyebrow pencils except for one by Lancome, I think, a powdery formula. They last for so darned long (keep them sharp if you use them!) that I can hardly remember where I got it or what I paid for it, but it was probably close to $20. Not bad for something that lasts for three to four years.
Another product I recommend is Anastasia brow powders, which come with two colors in the compact:
Wicked pricey but it comes with it’s own angled brush and spoolie and I’ve used it for about five years now and it’s going strong.
What you want to do if you have a dark brow is get a powder that’s a shade or two lighter than your own color, as the lighter powder will create shadow illusions that your brow is fuller than it is. If you’re blonde, go a shade darker, but not much more. The angled brush let’s you apply the product lightly and (this is genius) extend it beyond your natural brow without looking like Crazy Former Rockette Lady. If you make a mistake (you won’t after a few tries) you just whisk it off with a Q-tip.
I find that my face is way less expressive from a distance without brow powder, so I use it religiously (heh heh) when preaching or doing any public speaking. I fill in my brow and then I step back and look at myself from a distance. If I’ve become too Joan Crawford, I just roll a Q-tip around to remove excess. I use the Le Poudre Crayon brow pencil by Lancome (see, I remembered!) on ordinary days when I’m in a hurry and it takes two seconds to whisp, whisp, whisp on a few strokes to make my face look less wan.
I hope you know by now that WAN is one of PeaceBang’s favorite words. There’s just no other word like it to describe that washed out, barely-there face that bums me out whenever I see professional women walking around with it. ESPECIALLY if they’ve put effort into their outfit and hair! It’s like, “OH MY GOD, you got this really nice picture frame and you done forgot to put a picture in it!!”
Hey fellas? You could do with some brow groomage yourselves. There is NO shame in waxing a unibrow (also known as mono-brow, or Caveman Face). And a tiny bit of surreptitious plucking will be our little secret. If you have Crazy Stickin’ Out Eyebrows (see Milo O’Shea), PLEASE take care in trimming them or you may wind up with bizarrely chopped off eyebrows that will make people wonder if you got into a fight with your electric razor.
In March of 2007, I answered another query on the subject:
“I just discovered your blog, and I have a question about eyebrows.
I know I should pluck my eyebrows, but they’re a) light; b)sparse; c) the hairs are long.
So if I eliminated the hairs that shouldn’t be there, there’d only be a few left and they wouldn’t necessarily look tidy. And what do you do with eyebrow pencils?
I’ve never figured out how they work. The color certainly doesn’t rub off on the hairs, and I don’t think you’re supposed to just draw your own on your skin even though lots of elderly ladies do. Thanks.
Your colleague in the Midwestâ€My dear Midwestern lamb,
There is no rule that says Thou Shalt Pluck. Are the brows messy and scraggly? Do they distract from your eyes and travel over onto the bridge of your nose?
If so, they should be shaped.
Are your brows well-nigh invisible, failing to provide a beautiful, expressive frame for your face? If so, you should find a nice eyebrow pencil that is as close to your natural brow color as you can get it (Lancome Le Crayon Poudre is by far my favorite), keep it nice and sharp, and fill in your brow with light, feathery strokes. You’re not drawing on the brows, you’re filling them in.
The thing you want to avoid is using a harsh, hard pencil that requires you to use a heavy hand that will result in that permanently-startled Eccentric Retired Drama Teacher look.
Remember, as with all make-up, you want to look like yourself –only better.
Visit a cosmetics counter for a free lesson; it’s a perfectlyl legit investment of your time and energy. You will be seen far more effectively from the back pew with good, defined brows.
Good luck! PB
Thanks, Gidget, and congratulations on winning the $250 JC Penney card giveaway!



How timely. I was noticing this weekend my eyebrows appear to be shrinking. Thanks for the tips. I will have to practice – I don’t want to end up looking like witchy-poo 😉
Half of one’s eyebrow disappearing can be a sign of a sluggish thyroid.
For those of us with light eyebrows (mine have blonde tails), I cannot recommend brow tinting highly enough. I have it done once every two months or so, and once the hair is darkened, they can shape it into something that looks like a real eyebrow and defines my face perfectly. It’s more pricey than an eyebrow pencil would be, but it looks totally natural and I’d rather deal with it once every couple months than every day.
I call them beagle eyebrows. Young southern women are especially susceptible. And girl gymnasts. Now that I’m at the age where I have to have my hair color refreshed, I get my hairdresser to throw a little color on my brows too. Otherwise I get to plucking the gray hairs in a fit of pique, which is not a good thin.
I have very fair fine eyebrows – which I was forever pencilling in and fretting about (the no-brow look is awful…)
This summer I finally had them applied via micropigmentation. (OK then, tattooing…). Money extremely well spent and a great time saver in te morning. And no-one (not even people like my usual beauty therapist who tints my elelashes, or my hairdresser), noticed until I said what I had done.
It wasn’t painless, but boy it was worth it!
My spouse has the Crazy Stickin’ Out Eyebrows, but he won’t trim them. So when I trim mine, I give his a little trim too. He gets annoyed and makes a fuss, but lets me do it… once he’s had a nice trim he looks neat and tidy for months. Thankfully he does his nose hair himself, HA!
My husband is also a minister and about every 6 weeks I lay him down on the bed, get on top of him and go to town…. with a tweezer. hehe. I can’t have my man with only 1 eyebrow! 🙂
Gidget, my second email to you bounced, but your gift card is in the mail! Look for my tasteful pale green Crane envelope.
I’ve been blessed with good eyebrows, but my husband has, how to put it delicately? Old man brows. Beetling. Wild. Woolly. So hard not to pin him down and pluck them mercilessly.
When my husband died we had so many memorials that I opened an account in his name as a memorial account. My children had so much fun picking charities to give the money to that I kept the account and contribute to it each month and would use it from time to time but mostly at Christmas for the kids to each choose a cause they wanted to give to that year.
Oops – i did not mean for the above comment to go under eyebrows!
I received the JCP gift certificate today, and am so excited!!
Since my husband’s fall coat is 17 years old and looks dreadful, some of it will go for a new one. But the rest, my friends, is for additions to the fall wardrobe I long for. I will examine what I have, what I need, and make use of the other great prize offered here – a consult with Rev. Auntie Mame.
Thanks so much, Lynn, and PB, for your generosity.
@Rev. Gidget: Hooray! So glad you received the card. Can’t wait to hear about some of your new wardrobe!
@Pastor Joelle: I kept waiting for you to mention the name of this special charity that helped poor unfortunates with out-of-control eyebrows…