A Concerned Pastor writes,
I’ve been a XX minster for XX years and am in a weight loss campaign – xx [over 50] pounds so far – yea me! – and still losing – it’s terribly hard but I feel and look SO much better…that’s not why I’m writing…my church has a lovely, young seminarian working with us this year and she’s a wonderful pastor already, but she’s is very overweight (I’m extra sensitive to this, of course) and has no concept of dressing professionally. When she came to preach to my congregation last Sunday, she wore the same sloppy clothes (too long pants badly turned up, smocky top, clunky shoes) that she wears every other time she comes to church. In worship she wore a robe, so it covered her clothes. Our senior pastor is a young, unmarried man. As a woman in her field, old enough to be her mother, can I say anything to her? I think it would be doing her a favor, but I would like your advice. I’m thinking of just pointing her to your Beauty Tips for Ministers, but I’d like to be a little more personal. I am thinking of taking her to lunch when she finishes her year with us at the end of April, and just tell her that next year, when she’s looking for a call, she will need to present herself more professionally. I am not her supervisor, I do not have week-to-week contact with her, but I think she’s terrific, and I care about her. I don’t know how much money she has to equip herself with more professional looking clothes, and if lack of money is holding her back, or if she just is comfortable in student clothing. I’d appreciate your input…and I hope you are recovering from the flu by now. Thanks.
On the surface, it seems simple. As our Concerned Pastor herself suggests, why not just take the seminarian out to lunch and “Tell her that next year when she’s looking for a call she will need to present herself more professionally.” Add the honest, “I think you’re terrific,” and you’ve done your collegial duty.
But because it’s early in the day yet, and because I’m fascinated by the issues or women, weight and “mothering,” I’m going to unpack this a bit more. Because there are hidden dangers here that need to be directly addressed.
Our reader begins her letter with a celebration of her significant weight loss, which she admits makes her “extra sensitive” to the overweight seminarian. RED FLAG #1.
What does “extra sensitive” mean? Is it a euphemism for “judgmental?” It could be, and that would be only human; after all, this pastor has worked hard to lose a huge amount of weight and is still losing. Anyone who has lost a lot of weight (or been/is very overweight) knows how much emotional baggage is packed into our plus-sized jeans. Or is “extra sensitive” a way of saying, “This hurts me to see this sloppy overweight woman preparing for religious leadership, because I relate so strongly to her?” Does CP see herself in this seminarian? Does the seminarian represent compulsive overeating or lack of self-care that the Concerned Pastor is still actively battling? Very likely all of these emotional realities are present. Judgment, concern, over- identification, competitiveness, etc.
And that’s just human. That’s why we ask for advice when we’re dealing with these issues; they’re complicated.
Because of the emotional complexity here, it seems very important that Concerned Pastor set clear boundaries with herself around the conversation with the seminarian before she has it, because this young woman activates a lot of “stuff” for her. The sensitivity to fat isn’t the only issue here. She also says, “I’m old enough to be her mother.” RED FLAG #2. What does that mean for Concerned Pastor? Whatever it means, she will want to be sure to be very clear about her role in this relationship. She is a senior colleague and sister minister, not a mother (whether her mother associations are positive or negative, especially around issues of professional nurturing and appearance, I don’t know, but CP does, and that information is important to her here).
There is also a special mention in this letter that the male senior pastor is “young and unmarried.” I’m not sure why she mentions it, but it could be that Concerned Pastor thinks her senior colleague’s hands are tied in this situation. As a young, single man he might not feel that it’s safe to address the issue of appearance with a female intern at all. But what if CP discussed the matter with him, respecting his supervisory role, and informed him of her desire to do a sensitive intervention? She really ought not do this on her own outside of the supervisory process, which would muddy both her senior colleague’s role and hers. Knowing that a conversation had occurred, he could be assured that the subject was at least on the table and could follow up in an appropriate way with the seminarian.
I think that’s all I will say for now, with many thanks to CP for such a rich and easy-to-relate-to case study. There is always so much going on, isn’t there?

I wonder, if this could be done a little differently. If the city/town where the seminarian is an intern is the same one (or near) the one where the seminary is, might it be possible to have a day on ‘preparing for the interview process’ and ‘preparing for first call’, where the issue of dress and image is a part of the proceedings? That way, it would not be targeted at one individual, and others might benefit.
As well, although I’m not ordained, I did earn my MTS at an Episcopal seminary in the US, and there were yearly assessments. These not only had to do with academic progress, but issues of personal development. Self-care was one of those issues, and certainly, healthy weight is a self-care issue.
I’m thinking of ways to get the issue addressed that take it out of the strictly personal realm and make it part of process and professional development.
Could it also be that the seminarian hasn’t yet found fabulous professional clothes in her size? Or that the seminarian has some issues around body shame and/or dressing the body she has, and compensates with baggy, too-informal clothes?
The former could be resolved with a lunch conversation, a site like fatshionista.com, and a couple of gift cards. The latter could blow up horribly in CP’s face if by “sloppy” she means “person who is fatter than I approve of” (especially because I hear a lot of fatphobia in CP’s letter).
I had to talk to a college-age intern about her unprofessional attire (LOW blouses, too-tight, too-low pants) last year. As her supervisor, and as a female, I kept the comments brief and not about my personal judgments. I did NOT say, “this shirt is too low; I can see 3/4 of your boobs” or “when you bend over I can see your thong.” What I did say in one of our “debriefings” early on, when the topic of ministerial authority came up, was something to the effect of: clothing communicates authority. When I go to the hospital or nursing home or even on a regular office day, I think about whether my clothing is appropriate. It is easy for others not to take young, female ministers seriously…and I try not to give them reason to. I also shared a personal story about realizing my own clothing becoming too revealing as I bent down to distribute communion. Keeping the comments about my own observations and my own ministry, I do not think I embarrassed her. Yet she got the message.
As a current seminarian myself, I think CP would be doing the intern a huge favor to have a direct conversation on this topic. I agree the conversation needs to be well thought out in advance, and sensitively handled, but honestly, we are working so hard to become ministers, we need all the HONEST advice and feedback we can get.
Someone from my denomination’s Ministerial Fellowship Committee just spoke at our school and made a point of telling us to dress sharp and get a haircut before coming to the committee. She equated it to showing respect to the committee, and I was grateful to her for mentioning it. It makes sense that personal grooming shows respects to congregants as well.
As someone who is “very overweight”, and also nearly 6 feet tall, I have only this advice for your CP:
Unless she is willing to fork over cash and time to help this person find clothes that fit and flatter, she has no business voicing anything. For someone who is struggling to just not be naked, this conversation will only feel like an attack. Especially from someone who is dieting. And who is giving the spiel about the single male pastor. This is a variation of “you have such a pretty face, but…” and I would likely say some very unkind things to someone who spoke these things to me without cash in hand 🙂
(((As a young, single man he might not feel that it’s safe to address the issue of appearance with a female intern at all.)))
As the law student in the room, I can assure you that this assumption is far and away the safest one. I get what other people have noted about the concerned pastor, but a woman “old enough to be her mother” is by far the safest person to have this discussion.
Running it by the single male pastor is fine and probably wise, but yeah, the older woman should be the one to have the chat.
Personally, I would handle this in the context of “buying the intern an interview suit as a thank you for all her hard work and giving her the chat about professional dress that I give all our interns.”
CC
Just to *ahem* weigh in… I agree that the issue of weight is probably too personal (and too particular to taste) to bring up. But as you have pointed out to us a few zillion times, you don’t have to have a perfect figure to dress well. I think that the “mom” minister should have the conversation with her, and put it in terms of her own learning.
But do it sooner rather than later.
Would you like to know that people have found your appearance sloppy and unprofessional FOR AN ENTIRE CHURCH YEAR and not have been given a chance to do anything about it?
My first Sunday up “on stage” in my internship church, I had seven (I counted, 7) older women in the church tell me that I shouldn’t cross my legs up there in that short a dress because they could see up to my… I was mortified. But I corrected the situation, pronto.
Yes, it costs money. But I made a pittance as an intern and still managed to buy a few things. Especially longer skirts.
I agree that you are the safest person to have this discussion, and it’s a nice thought to do it in the manner that you’re “buying the intern an interview suit as a thank you for all her hard work and giving her the chat about professional dress that I give all our interns.â€
Well said. I walked by Addition-Elle today (do you have that in the States?) and there was some absolutely beautiful clothing there.
I will add though, since all the comments have been said already about being sensitive and careful, etc… you will be doing her a great disservice NOT to mention anything at this point.
In the worst-case scenario… even if you end up offending, even if she is hurt, even if it’s an awkward conversation… if you come to her with the attitude of wanting to help, it’ll be better that the topic has come up than for it never to have come up at all, whatever the immediate effect is on her.
While in seminary I had a male professor tell me that I should “wear dark clothes because they are more slimming” after I preached for the VERY FIRST TIME! I had on a dark shirt with a lighter colored cardigan. Being a full sized woman, and currently serving a church I know how important it is to dress professionally and to put my best foot forward.
I think that a woman expressing concern and care accompanied by advice will be much more recieved by the young intern. Frankly, she knows that she is overweight. She does not need someone else telling her that…or telling her how to diet…but she probably could use some help finding clothes that fit properly.
I would encourage people in this situation to not point out a persons weight, but direct them to clothing that would fit and flatter them.
I carry with me that inappropriate comment from my past every day. I pray that others do not have to have those same comments made to them.
[Hey GirlPastor, that sucks and I’m angry for you and with you. I don’t know whether or not you were able to say anything to the professor but I hope that you can somehow exorcise the sting of that stupid remark. “Gee Professor, ya don’t SAY! I’ve never heard THAT before! By the way, and just incidentally, how was my PREACHING?” Jackass. God bless you and all the gifts you’ll bring forth to the world through your bodacious and fabulous self. – PB]
I was humilated during my field education by a member of my teaching parish committe who stated that my sermon (which won praise from the other 5 members and a host of congregants) told me the sermon would be better served if I had worn makeup. Well, I’m allergic to make up – after testing many brands and spending many a day at the derm, I’ve opted to wear makeup to specfic family events only (weddings, funerals). The woman spent the year saying I’d be a better minister if I wore makeup. Nobody in the parrish bothered to defend me (including the pastor). While I just smiled and nodded, to this day whenever I hear of somebody wanting to offer advice regarding personal apperance that is unsolicted, I wonder. Unless an indivual is willing to hand over the amex card, I think somethings are better stated in a more neutral way like “do you have your power suit yet for your interviews?”.
[Wow, what a bummer experience! Anyone who harps on such things has ISSUES, for sure! I mean, we all know when a comment or advice is given in love and appreciation for our best selves vs. a snitty improvement pitch. In the latter case, I think that asking for one’s AmEx card would be a hilarious come-back! – PB]