A friend invited me to a virtual event on Facebook. Here’s the invite:
Women have been among the most dynamic and successful ministers; but in divinity school, Sarah Sentilles discovered that some of the best and brightest of them were having trouble and even leaving the church altogether.
What was happening? To find out, she entered the lives of female ministers—women of various ages and races in a range of churches—and emerged with the first real portrait of what it’s like to lead as a woman of faith today. What Sentilles found was that despite many churches’ resistance—conscious or not—to re-imagining ministry for anyone but a man, many of these women are achieving remarkable transformations in their congregations.
To learn more about Sarah Sentilles, please visit: www.sarahsentilles.com
Books will be on sale at the event. Can’t make it? Buy the book here to support CNW and women’s bookstores
So, this sounds cool, right? But not so fast. First of all, the book is called A Church of Her Own: What Happens When a Woman Takes The Pulpit. Subtle but important misstep right out of the gate. Yes, I get the literary reference to Virginia Woolf — I have a degree in English literature, too. But a church is never “her” or “his” own, of course, and let’s just say that I hope that title was foisted on Sentilles by an clueless publisher.
Now let’s look at the image that goes with the promo:

My instant read is, I’m afraid, unfavorable toward Ms. Sentilles. Her bare shoulders within the context of her impressive educational credentials communicate, “I know that bare shoulders are considered disrespectful in most cultures and I don’t care!”
The cut of the shirt is also way too low — this is precisely the shirt one would wear to a nice bar for drinks with friends. It is not the shirt one should wear to promote oneself as a serious thinker. Basic BTFM rule: No one should ever, ever be able to see your armpits when you’re appearing in a professional capacity. TMI!
Her necklace is so fashionable that it reads to me as what my elementary school friends and I used to refer to as “try-hard.” It’s not just an attractive accessory, it’s an aggressive statement of super hipness. Too much, SS!
Her hair is so youthful, so gotta-be-sexy that it makes enough of a statement all on its own. She didn’t need to underscore and then double underscore how much she wants to project hip sexuality — the image comes on so strong that I find I have minimal curiosity about what the scholar might have to say. This is a perfect example of what I consider insulting one’s intended audience by image overkill. Above all, the look is incredibly contrived. Is Sarah being given bad advice by managers or handlers? Again, a shame, since her books seem to be very well-received and respected. I’m reading a first impression here, which, we should always remember, is all most of us ever get.
During my recent visit to Union Theological Seminary I talked at great length with young, beautiful female seminarians who were tired of getting the explicit or implicit message that hiding their attractiveness and sexuality under the proverbial bushel would be a good idea if they wanted to be “taken seriously.” I assured them that any professional woman who wants to be taken seriously needs to be aware of certain boundaries one doesn’t cross in one’s choice of attire, but that they should go ahead and have fun with their clothes, hair and make-up (several already have pierced noses or eyebrows) and let their obvious intelligence, hard work and pastoral devotion be the evidence of their fitness for the ministry. In short, yes it’s a sexist world out there, but it’s not 1860. Work with it, work it, and move on out and up.
Yes, you can be very pretty, exude vibrancy and actual connection to your body (tr: you can be a sexual, incarnate being) and be a respected clergyperson, male or female. Having said that, I want to suggest that the promotional image of Sarah Sentilles above is a perfect example of how obvious, cliched sexualized fashion (I’m not making this up — look in the fashion magazines and you will see versions of this exact outfit recommended for bar-hopping) can unconsciously project “I need you to think I’m sexy” when you would rather be projecting “I am a young, hip, relevant author whose presentation you should attend.”

This, while obviously very cautious and even slightly school-girlish (note the re-creation of the schoolgirl “middy blouse” look), is at least not distracting and negatively manipulative. Sarah, call me! I can help you look so much better! And you can introduce me to your publisher!

While I haven’t read Sarah’s book, she was a friend of mine in divinity school, and I feel the need to come to her defense. I agree she looks very casual in the promo picture, perhaps not appropriate for a serious book about women clergy. But then you dislike the picture at the bottom too! It seems that even as we women clergy try to rebel against the idea that the only clothes we can wear are shapeless clothes that give us the “flat male front” (another woman div. school friend of mine articulated this as the ideal), the boundaries for our styles remain impossibly narrow. Be stylish, but not too stylish. Be healthy, but don’t be too fat or focus on being too thin. Be professional, but not boring. Look ministerial, but don’t look male. I love your blog, PB, and I enjoy putting together outfits for my work as a UU parish minister with your virtual guidance, but aren’t you being a little hard on Sarah here?
[I am, and here’s why: she’s putting herself out there as an authority on a subject that has everything to do with sex and sexism, gender and gender stereotypes, and public image. Because she is claiming authority in this area, it befalls her to know how her own image reads. The second photo, as I said, is better, but in its own way is also a cliche. My work is all about encouraging us to project an image consciously and intentionally rather than to project one unconsciously; one that may undermine the message we are communicating. I feel very strongly that SS has yet to find an image that works, that is not a cliche of either careful dowdiness/unthreatening schoolgirl or sexualized babe. I affirm yet again that we must prepare ourselves as visual symbols as carefully as we prepare our words or publications. It is a major responsibility, but it’s one we must take on more mindfully. – PB]
I just finished this book and was really hoping you’d comment on it on this blog (which I read more than faithfully and love). There is a chapter on the minister’s appearance that I think you would find interesting–and I would be interested in knowing what you think. [I’ll look for it at the library — I read an unfavorable review by Christian Century and don’t intend to purchase it. – PB]
I love Sarah–she was a huge inspiration to me at HDS and pretty much is the one who taught me how to write a sermon (in two hours at her kitchen table–more useful than any preaching class I took). Her first book is great, haven’t read this newest one yet. She’s a dynamic, brilliant person. And the best preacher I have ever seen.
Now that you mention it, I wouldn’t purchase it again.
I would agree that her publicist needs to reduce the cheesecake factor and find a nice professional look. But – the work that she has done, and her book, are pretty sobering. As a woman in seminary, on my 3rd career (4th if you count parenting) it is pretty discouraging. I get hit up with “the old boys club” crap all the time. I am working hard to rise above it and not have that hard “edge” of nastiness. But no worries. I won’t show my armpits.
And PB, my dear, I have to tell you that thanks to your advice I have a SMASHING new set of outfits for Sundays… so MWAH.
I love hearing you advocate “fun” but not overly revealing clothes for young female seminarians. This is a subject my roommate and I talk about all the time, as I am one year into my six-year program, while she is facing ordination this coming spring. I have been working on melding my former flashy wardrobe with a more professional look, and she is struggling to find clothes that will flatter her figure and be colorful and bright but still allow her to present a “rabbinic” appearance (whatever that is). I have two piercings in each earlobe and usually wear smallish earrings, but I love offbeat accessories like neckties, chokers, and bangles and I worry about how far I can go. Neither of us would show any shoulder in public and are in general modest dressers, but we go back and forth on how to go about still looking young and fun.
I cannot believe women are still having to deal with this stuff. You prove the points she makes. We’ve come along way but have so far to go. I can’t believe your site is for real! I thought it was a spoof at first but you are serious! I led a women in ministry group and one minister stated one of her congregants mentioned her red nail polish was “innappropriate.” I’m assuming you cover “appropriate” nail polish on your site somewhere. Another stated her congregation said she should not wear pants, another said hers indicated she should not wear a skirt. I think the message is, simply, we will not accept you not matter what you wear. You cannot win. Leaving is sometimes the best alternative. [What a bummer attitude — I would NEVER advise a woman to give up her calling to ministry no matter what — although she may have to find a tradition or place that better respects women in clergy leadership. Yes, there are obstacles and sexism for women in ministry, but many of us are happy and successful and NOT critiqued on a regular basis — in fact, are celebrated AS women. There’s no such thing as “appropriate” or “inappropriate” nail polish — I’m wearing deep blue polish on my toes right now, for instance. There is only knowing who you are, knowing where you serve, and being a smart cookie in making those work together in a way that’s joyful and uniquely beautiful. – PB]