My days involve needing to be able to move pretty quickly, walk and minister in one of the rougher SF neighborhoods, and then be in the ER / hospital bedsides for urgent and end of life care. On-call days can last up to 36 hours and could land me in any of these settings. The in-hospital dress sense seems to be business casual to professional (depending on the role), and my fellow chaplains follow that line. However, my supervisor suggested I “blend” while I work with the homelessness groups, which are very, very casual. There’s not a locker room available to us, which adds an element of challenge.
So how does one dress for times such as these? And, in particular, shoe related advice would be massively appreciated as I’ve got massive blisters in spite of heal cushions and band-aids. Thanks for your time and advice!
Dear L!
What an exciting ministry, but a sartorial challenge, indeed.
My first thought is that you MUST be able to wear comfortable shoes and not concern yourself with the fashionablity or frumpiness factor thereof. I am thinking all black sneaker-type shoes like this Saucony style below.

You can’t minister with blisters. If you’re walking as much as you are, this kind of shoe may be your only option.
Of course, you can always test-drive the comfort brands of clogs such as Ariat, Dansko, Jambu, Alegria. You’re slim and in good shape without any knee or ankle problems, so a clog may work for you. They do not work for me and many others, but you might find some luck here.
So the task then becomes how to build a professional-enough uniform around the sneakers. When we do sneakers or comfy footwear, the rest of us MUST be polished and classic, and the lines simple and tailored. Slim trousers with a bit of stretch in them worn hemmed so they hit the top of the laces on the shoes, no shorter. I think black, brown or plum. Navy seems too Salvation Army to me.
It wouldn’t be a bad idea to stock up on fantastic black trousers with a hint of stretch in them and make all-black your bottom half uniform.
Now – could you collect a small supply of nice cotton T’s with a bit of stretch to them to wear with the trousers and top the Ts with a denim jacket or hoodie while working with the street community, then swap out that jacket for a blazer at the hospital? Can you have a locker there where you can stash a blazer and scarf? A pair of nice earrings and a lipstick? You said no, but I am hoping that a conversation with a supervisor might yield some kind of help as you’re on public transportation and can’t be expected to keep a change of togs in your car.
When you’re sitting at bedside doing hospital chaplaincy, it is very important that your top half be professional, so you might find some miracle fabric jackets that you can fold in a knapsack for your hospital switcheroo. I get a catalog called TravelSmith that has a ton of packable options, and I see that there are some swell pieces on sale right now for $69.
Ottoman knit jacket, interesting cut.

Ponte blazer, not going to make you feel super glam or anything, but it will do the job:

It’s a pain to have to carry around multiple changes of clothes but I agree with your Faithful Fools mentor who advises wearing clothing that won’t immediately identify you as “not of” the people with whom you are ministering in the Tenderloin.
Make sure you take a damp paper towel to your shoes before you start your chaplaincy rounds. Powder your nose, brush your hair, swipe on a bit of brown mascara (you’re too fair for black mascara), and don your wristwatch, which you will probably need.
What an exciting time for you.
With much love and a faithfully foolish kiss of peace,
PB




Docs are back in this season (the shoes), which could be an option if the danskos aren’t. I swear by my clogs, and in fact wore mine today because my day also involved hospitals, car share, and transit.
If she has a locker, changing to hospital shoes might be an option. I keep church shoes in my office for quick changes.
I hate skinny pants, though. Can we get your blessing for straight legs or boot cuts for those of us who are slim of waist but muscular of leg?
I am in hospice chaplaincy and I have to go into some sketchy nursing homes and some very swanky homes. I don’t walk a ton, but I am on my feet a lot all day and have to travel miles by car. My previous work was with homeless families, which is a much more mainstream crowd than adults living rough. I can’t say that I really attempted to dress down in that ministry, but of course you should try to honor the wisdom of your supervisor.
The nurses I work with wear a lot of clogs, but I don’t feel myself in them. I have found that I like a really solid pair of flats, something like these, which have the innards of sneaker.
http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41LKISU0%2B%2BL.jpg
These seem to work well for me with a trim trouser or skirts.
I tend to wear a lot of layers because the temperate variables from place to place can be extreme. Some people don’t use any air conditioning and other places freeze everyone to popsicles.
Have a look at Rohan. It is outdoor/activity type gear, but they have a fab trouser which is fairly slim legged, with stretch, washes very well, doesn’t needs ironing and looks smart. (I think they are called Trekkers…they advertise that they look as good in the pub as on the hillside!) They also have technical fleece cardigans which look like a knit fabric on the outside and look smart, not like polar fleece stuff.
My experience with clogs (Danskos) is that they are great for standing but walking long distances can be hard. The wide toebox and loose heel is comfy if I’m on my feet all day but not supportive enough for long walks. [Yea, me too! I thought it was just me. – PB]
I like those flats! I can’t tell what kind they are from the link. I’d get a pair in all-black. To my great horreur, I find my feet hurting before I’m up for my second sermon. Even with a very modest heel or flat without arch support. This week I slipped ’em off in the pulpit.
Melissa, what is the brand of those flats?
They are NikeAir by Cole Haan. I got mine at a thrift store, so I have no idea what the distribution or pricepoint.
Sketchers has some “dress” shoes with memory foam insoles. They are very comfortable to walk in and may be able to work for both settings. One example: https://www.skechers.com/en-us/style/22672/ez-flex-2-quipster/bbk