Women Keeping Women Down

OOOH, this kind of thing just burns my grummies! I just last week received this letter from a young, very bright and talented colleague whom I have met and spent time with in person. With that brief introduction, read on and join the conversation. Because this is serious stuff, kids.

W.P. writes,

… all in all, things are positive. A problem I’m running into, however, is that I feel consistently dismissed / (mostly gently) mocked by my colleagues – particularly female colleagues who have a generation or more on me in age. I’ve tried hard to follow wisdom from your writing and other women I admire in ministry, and cultivate a style and wardrobe that is true to my personality but allows me to walk the walk in ministry. I still love me some pretty dresses, but always with appropriate necklines, sleeve length, and knee length or lower hem lines (with opaque tights underneath).

So what the heck is up with every presbytery gathering / clergy / worship event people making remarks about what I am “able to pull off”, how “cute” I am, remarks about “sexiness” (I don’t consider anything I’m wearing to these events to be sexy… eesh.), including a remark from the [female] moderator from the microphone about [my clothing]. I wear robes on Sundays and even then, I consistently have women from my congregation trying to adjust my robe / stole / hair, often without asking permission before touching me.

I’m feeling a little defensive about this (obviously) and tried to just run it off, but I feel frustrated and like my only options are to join the ugly blazer / turtleneck brigade, or to put up with mockery. Any suggestions on how to handle this one?

Thanks for your time, and hoping you are well!
Pigeon

This is how I responded:

Wow.
This was very hard to hear. Wow.
It sounds like sexism and competitiveness, pure and simple. Really in the realm of spiritual warfare, and you know I wouldn’t use that term lightly.
It’s true that you look young and fresh-faced. You have a fun sense of style. But these women are descending on you like a pack of wolves trying to frump you up so that you’re less threatening to them: a successful, bright parish minister with her own church and a record of commitment and achievement in serious social justice work.

Those broads are trying to get you down. I’m furious. Because there is no other explanation and this happens all too often.

Let’s talk soon. You don’t need to do a thing but perhaps come up with a few withering quips when someone dares to put you down like that moderator did.

Now, is there any lingering doubt in your mind about what you are wearing? I mean, you have perfectly good taste: where is this sexy thing coming from? How frumpy are these women anyway, and how conservative is the general environment?

Fierce love from your friend,
Vicki

She responded,

Thank you! I was worried I was just being defensive and it’s really a huge comfort to know that you also read inappropriateness in how these women were behaving.

The frump factor is pretty darn high here in — – particularly amongst female clergy. Lots of unflattering choppy hair, many, many turtlenecks, lots of blazers and ill-fitting pants. I recognize that my style might stand out in that setting, but I really don’t think it’s anything outlandish.

I’m also aware that I am one of very few under 40 clergy people, and I am the only unmarried one (male or female). Not sure if / how that impacts things but I have a suspicion it might.

The whole thing is leaving me with a strong urge to invest in a nuns’ habit and / or a burka and call it a day. Definitely open to suggestions – quips, clothing, or otherwise!

With gratitude,
love,
W.P.

Women can be our own worst enemies. What happened/is happening to Western Pigeon is an ancient low-level harassment and social control by which women have been keeping other women in “their place” for thousands of years. In this case, it’s about objectifying and shaming a young woman leader with a sense of style into playing by the unspoken Rules of Frumpiness by which the other women have tacitly agreed to do the work of ministry. This just in: we don’t have FRUMPINESS PURITY LAWS in the church, people. There is no KOSHER FRUMP CODE. It just looks that way when you see us in a large group.

“Know thyself. … For non-conformity the world whips you with its displeasure.” That was Mr. Emerson speaking in the late 1830’s, and it is obviously true today for Western Pigeon. Yes, I have seen many young clergy starting out whose attire hollers “NOTICE ME! I’m COOL!” and that’s not a mature approach. However, knowing WP as I do, and knowing her setting, it is very obvious to me that she is being schooled by her peers to be Blah for Jesus as they are, and that’s not okay.

The issue of being petted by parishioners is much less sinister, but it’s still annoying and disrespectful. It’s obvious that some of the women unconsciously view W.P. as a little girl if they feel that it’s okay to adjust her hair or clothing in church. Every one of us — whatever our gender identity — gets identified with certain roles in the hearts of our people. Sometimes we’re father or mother, sometimes we’re Teacher, sometimes we’re child. There’s nothing very surprising about a young pastor being seen as a child by church elders, and there’s nothing necessarily destructive about it. Given this, W.P., how you respond to being adjusted depends on your sense of humor and your relationship with folks. One simple response would be to fix the hair or attire of anyone who fixes yours. Just do to them exactly what they do to you. If someone touches or fluffs your hair, fluff theirs for them and say, “There you go, dear.” If someone straightens your stole, turn to them, look them over, smile and straighten something on them and say, “Now we’re both perfect. Thank you.”

I’m such an old broad now that it feels wonderful to have someone straighten my stole for me. I was at an event not long ago when a colleague I’ve never met looked me up and down and said, quite nastily, “Your stole’s crooked.” She didn’t even offer to fix it for me. GEEZ. In a robing room when there’s no full length mirror, we should feel free to straighten each other’s stoles and smooth crazy hairs and such for each other. If you’re finding that lay people are getting handsy with you, you might want to ask an usher to do a “last looks” with you before exiting the robing room to make sure everything is correctly placed before greeting people. That way, if anyone reaches for your hair, robe or stole you can deflect and say something like, “I’m all set, thanks!”

As for the female colleagues who are making the inappropriate remarks about your clothes or look, here are a few responses you could tailor to the occasion:
“How interesting that you think this is sexy — it must be a generational thing.” (cool tone, head tilt, walk away)
“It certainly is interesting that you have such strong feelings about my clothing.” (raise eyebrows, smile, walk away)
“As I look around at this gathering, I suppose it does seem remarkable to see a young woman in a dress. I’m glad you like it.” (brush imaginary crumbs from their shoulder, smile distant smile, walk away)
“Thank you, you’re pretty cute yourself.” (wan smile, walk away)

Christian women NEVER expect to be called out for their cattiness. But go ahead and get out the Purina. Don’t dignify any of this nonsense with a sincere response, and don’t let this sexist bullying be your problem. Give it right back to anyone who gives it to you. MEOW. And blessings.

5 Replies to “Women Keeping Women Down”

  1. I don’t have anything to add to PB’s excellent advice except to add my support and say ‘kia kaha!’ (stand strong). I hope you can find some supportive allies amongst the judgemental masses.

  2. AMEN, PB! Keep dressing and shining beautifully, WP, and don’t you dare think about joining the Frump Brigade! I am in my 60’s and dress in well-cut/fitted and colorful clothing and regularly receive these kinds of comments from colleagues my age — and sometimes, younger. Do not listen to any of it. As for getting all “hand-across-America” with you, PB’s advice is right on.

  3. Reminds me of my early days in ministry when people would say, “Hello, young lady.” I felt five. I wanted desperately to say, “Hi there, OLD MAN.” Always thought better of it. Still wanted to.

  4. Sadly, this really doesn’t surprise me. I think Western culture eats away at women’s confidence as they age and that for those who don’t reflect on this and seek confidence from being a loved child of God, younger women and single women are seen as a genuine threat. Women have learned that our gifts are not always recognised and we wonder if the church would treat us better if we were gorgeous.
    PS I once had an old lady in a nursing home who loved to introduce me (at 32 years of age) as her ‘little minister’.

  5. I’m sorry this is still happening….and it is definitely spiritual warfare. Don’t take it lightly and don’t give in to those threatened by your sprit and style and attractiveness.

Comments are closed.