Wa-ow, wa–ow, wa-ow! *sound of sirens*
PeaceBang is having a Preacher’s Insecurity Attack! You’ve had one, haven’t you, pigeons? I’m not the only one who does this, right?
Listen, if you’re going to get all Self-Esteemy on me now you can just GO SIT IN THE OTHER ROOM where the unreasonably secure preachers sit. I’m not ready for your positivity just now. Let me stew in my Calvinist angst for awhile.
Here’s what, darlings. First of all, I believe in constantly honing our craft, never resting on laurels or experience, and regularly listening to audio recordings of our preaching. That’s numero uno: don’t ever get satisfied. Preaching hasn’t lasted for thousands of years as an art form because practitioners got confident that they were doing it super well. In the immortal words of Devo, “Crack that whip.” Keep learning, keep critiquing, keep listening with the ears of the worshiper as best you can. And if that means you’re a bit harsh on yourself, better that than too cozy with your own awesomeness.
Second of all, it is occasionally a good idea to give a sermon from the pastoral perspective, ie, something almost wholly from your theological storehouse and no one else’s. These are the sermons where you don’t try to quote several sources to support your points — you just share from your heart your experiences of religious truth and make faith claims that are informed by tradition but validated and confirmed by direct experience. In my own Unitarian Univeralist tradition, we claim six sources for our living tradition, the first of which is,
Direct experience of that transcending mystery and wonder, affirmed in all cultures, which moves us to a renewal of the spirit and an openness to the forces that create and uphold life.
These are the scary sermons. It’s just you in that pulpit, trying to articulate some fact of your religious life that sustains and/or challenges you. You’re speaking to them as a pastor, responding to a question that has been coming to you on from various folks in the congregation often enough that now you feel compelled to respond in sermonic form. You’re not going to set out an intellectual argument but to reveal something of yourself — to give them, in Ralph Waldo Emerson’s words, “your life passed through the fire of thought.” And because this sermon is going to be more personal, you are taking a much greater risk than usual.
I find that the aftermath of such a sermon is rough. In editing what I have given that morning, I find myself second-guessing myself far more than usual, regretting that I said this or didn’t say that, and feeling that I tried to bite off more than I could chew and wound up condensing something I would have rather had an hour to discuss into 18 or so minutes. I agonize over the use of humor, or conversely, having been too serious and self-important. Sometimes both.
In this particular case, I am able to live with the anxiety mostly because I led an after church conversation with fifteen people on the sermon, so I know that at least a portion of the congregation got to delve more deeply into the topic. But still, here it is Wednesday night and I’m preparing the sermon for publication and podcasting and trying not to bite my freshly-manicured nails.
Sunday comes, and then Sunday comes again, and the next Sunday will come in the same measure of time whether we’re feeling adequate to the task of leading worship or not. It does not do for any of us to become too neurotic about our offerings, but to offer them in the spirit of sincere effort and sincere desire to minister to those who pay us the privilege of listening. I have never known most church-goers to be anything but generous and forbearing in the receiving of a sermon — most would rather stick pins in their eyes than get up and try the same stunt week after week — but that’s not the point here. The point is that even when we get safely down from the tall branches, sometimes we just climb too high into that tree and scare the guts out of ourselves.
Tonight I’m going to think of myself as a mewling kitty stuck in the tree and God as the nice firefighter who patiently sets the ladder against the trunk, climbs up, and gets me down safely to the ground.

Thank you! As a senior seminarian who has a push-pull relationship with preaching I appreciate your candor and your idea to occasionally preach 100% from my heart and my experience. I find I get all caught up in the intellectual/thinking part and forget about my heart. That’s what people want, a little piece of us that assures them we are just like them. Keep up the good work to those traveling with you! Peace.
I used to be an attorney. I was very, very good at legal research. When I became a priest, I brought that talent to bear on sermon prep. I would spend a solid 6-8 hours every week reading, culling, and collecting and collating before writing. About 4 or 5 years ago, my clergy coach asked me why I did all that work. I thought about that, and realized it was because I still wanted to “win,” even though one of the reasons I stopped practicing law was because it was so hyper-competitive.
So, I stopped. I still do reading and collecting, but more like an hour, certainly no more than two. The rest comes from my life experiences, my faith experiences, stories that touch me, the news, etc. I no longer preach to win, I preach to share the good news that makes me rejoice to wake up every morning and be a disciple of Jesus (not a great one, or even a good one, just a hopeful one) every day. What a difference that has made in my stress level! And, my people seem to like my sermons.
I think vulnerability is one of the hallmarks of an honest preacher.
As a missionary I am expected to share my story with congregations so that they can support me. It is nerve wracking to share with a congregation but it is 1000000 times more nerve wracking to share with my home congregation. Yes, they love me, but they also will see me again. It is like there is more on the line when I speak to them because they’ve seen me before and will see me again.
There is a huge difference between bleeding on the congregation and opening one’s heart. I believe when we trust in the Holy Spirit we can get to the second place.
It’s a scary place, to be vulnerable, when we’re the one’s who are supposed to be ‘in charge’ of the congregation and most definitely of ourselves.
But being an authentic presence means sharing the struggle appropriately, letting the congregation know you are human. *shock gasp awe*.
Thank you for mentoring us through the places of darkness and showing us that the pre-homily stress freak is not necessarily a bad thing.
*kiss of peace*
The descriptive imagery as firefighter really has hit the mark and touched the heart, and for now I rest in this great I AM you have brilliantly helped emerge as one helpful rest along the Way. [I am so glad! Thanks for letting me know. – PB]
I am grateful for the reminder that having it all perfectly together all the time is an aspirational goal and not an entry requirement. (I am currently stuck at the “I’m never going to get into seminary because the application requires letters of recommendation and that means I have to talk to people about this!” stage of angst, and I am keen to get myself over it so I can get on with angsting about more interesting things.) Thank you.
Love the mewly kitty image. I’m finding (I’m a lay preacher in the baptist tradition) that the only sermons I feel legitmate to stand up and give are those rooted in my own experience. That doesn’t necessarily mean that that experience is visible – I don’t necessarily tell my own story every time – but I think that if we’re going to make claims like “God is still there when you feel like he isn’t” then you need to have had that experience, and not just be passing on something you read in a book. Whether you then “show your working”, as my old math teacher would say, is a different issue – and may sometimes be the difference between bleeding on the congregation and opening your heart.