So D. wrote me this Letter of Agony,
I understand you’re a busy lady, dear one, but I so need some advice. I’m in my final year of seminary, and yes, starting to get the clothes thing a whole lot better. However, I do have one basic problem–my hair refuses to cooperate with almost any attempt to change it! It’s baby fine, but there is a whole lot of it, won’t keep a curl for more than five minutes (maybe five days with a perm, but I finally gave up wasting my money), and hairpins leap out of it like they are attempting to commit suicide. On normal, average days in class, I wear it down and it looks nice (about 2 to 3 inches below the shoulder, and enough silver to look classy). But when I’m preaching, I pull it back to keep from any nervous hair touching. I somehow get the impression that ponytails, long-term, aren’t going to get it once I get to my first placement. I would love to make it stay up in some classy style, but my hair will fight to the death against anything more restraining than an elastic band. Any suggestions, other than cutting it short? (I have two enormous cowlicks that stand straight up once it’s cut short, and I’m desperate to not look goofy….) Are there things out there that work better than basic bobby pins and hairspray?
Sincerely, Desperate at D.
Yes, Desperate at D., yes I AM a busy lady, and I am so exhausted after a full day of parish ministry that I VOW to be in bed by 11:30. But as you know, I am obsessive about zipping off a super-quickie response to Desperate Pigeons, and I did send you this response this morning:
PHOTOS, darling! Send me a current photo!
And I know you like the color, but getting it colored will give your hair more volume.
I feel your pain, too — I have super fine hair but lots of it. It STINKS to try to do a “hair-did.”I think I need to blog on this. For one thing, and no girl likes to hear this, but dry shampoo is your friend for preaching days. It’s the only thing that works for me in terms of keeping hair accessories in.
Have you tried a roll and a clip in back?
Another idea is to pull it back, do a claw clip, and neaten everything up with a cute headband.
You’re going to have to learn to tease it up a bit.Does any of this help? xoxo Kiss of peace, PB
Boys and girls, I really do mean it: dry shampoo IS your friend. I used it all summer for the theatre and was able to go 4-5 days without washing my hair. I had to make it big and poufy for the Edwardian time period we were representing,and I used Suave Dry Shampoo and some simple hair teasing techniques to achieve that. It’s simple.
1. Fling your hair upside down and spray it quickly at the roots all over your head. Run fingers through hair at the scalp to distribute the product.
2. Brush, but not overly, to get rid of any powdery residue (but I find that brushing just redistributes oil so I skip that step).
3. Starting at the back of your head, grab small sections of hair and hold in the air vertically. Using a bristle brush, hold onto the section of hair and tease it from the back with a fast motion until it gets roughed up. This takes a mere minute or two to do the whole back of the head.
4. Spray the living Jesus out of it.
5. Don’t gripe to me that you’re ruining your hair; don’t you think I KNOW that? But you have a choice. You can either have pretty, shiny, limp, bleh hair that lies on your head like a dead mink or you can have a hair style. I’m just giving you a CHOICE, pigeons. The bigger the hair, the closer to God. That’s all I’m saying.
Suave Dry Shampoo is a great product but has a very strong fragrance, so I have been testing other dry shampoos and I can give a big thumbs up to this one, which I purchased at Wal-Mart for $5.99. It’s from the Not Your Mother’s line, which is a funny name. Why wouldn’t I want to use my mother’s dry shampoo? Her dry shampoo (I believe she used Pssssssst back in the day) worked just fine. But I digress.
Once you’ve teased up your big ole’ hair, you can do any number of lovely things with it. You can put it in a nice chignon. You can roll it and clip it in the back and secure it with a nice claw or clip (see the BTFM archives for Accessories. Just keyword “hair accessories” and you’ll find a treasure trove of suggestions!)
Teased hair with double headband:
Teased hair clipped under with claw with ethnic headband:

Just some hairspray and a teasing comb = major Edwardian beehive, baby (just to prove it can be done with fine hair):

Side braid to keep your hair down and off your face for preaching. I wore this last week and hated it, but people liked it and you gotta try new things!

Gentlemen with fine hair, if I can spend 20 minutes teasing and spraying and torturing mine to get it to look presentable for Sunday morning, could you at least shampoo yours and perhaps also make sure that it’s not sticking out in a huge, distracting cowlick? Thank you?





pixie cut? [Are you being sassy, young lady? Hmmm? Hmmmm? – PB]
I have fine hair too, and this reminds me of a question I have. I start to look dowdy when my hair reaches past my cheekbones–what short hairstyles would you recommend? You once made a comment about not showing ears, which I don’t think I could manage, but I am curious nonetheless. Thanks for answering questions when you are so busy!
Another member of the fine hair club. On the plus side, I actually found a haircut that my hair will do – a roughly chin length bob, and I curl it under and it stays pretty well. If – and this is an big if – it gets cut right, it will actually curl under by itself. (Unfortunately the only place that I have reliably had it cut that way is 1300 miles from my call). If I take a quick nap, I have bed head and have to start over. Oh, and one of the joys of getting older is that I no longer have fine THICK hair.
My biggest problem is that I live in South Dakota, the great WIND state. All the other women around either have longer hair (at which point I no longer have curl) and put it up on windy days (and our inquiring sister has summed up why putting it up doesn’t work – besides mine is at that point where it’s just to short to put up) or short hair that doen’t blow in your face in the wind (I’m afraid to go shorter because my hair will just lie there looking chopped).
Please, Peacebang, a series on solutions for those of us with fine hair would be wonderful! It’s hard to look professional when your hair is blowing across your face! [So, do you mean like doing weddings and funerals outdoors? Because that is a BEE-yotch, I agree. – PB]
I have fine hair also – and it grows INCREDIBLY slow! Definitely second the tips on dry shampoo and teasing! Yes yes!!! I have had great results with Tres Semme brand dry shampoo. I’ve also found that Redken extreme shampoo and conditioner helps strengthen my hair, and the Moroccanoil (sp?) hair masque is great once a week.
As far as styling – you can look into sock buns, or try a big bun by twisting a binder around once, then halfway through, and then the third time looping it around your whole hair (tease up the sides first) – if that’s not too confusing! – it will really make you look like you have more hair.
I used to swear by hot rollers and they are really great for fine hair, but this year I finally figured out how to use a curling iron more successfully, and that can work too. I always curl on the day after a shampoo – dry shampoo and heat protectant spray are your friends! When curling make sure to separate into sections – split the sides, and then clip up portions on one side to curl.
As a last resort – I used to play around with clip-in extensions sometimes (before switching to a career in the ministry). The real-hair ones from Sally Beauty Supply are great and can be curled, washed, etc. If you want to experience long, thick hair if only for a day 😉
Finally – don’t be embarrassed to peruse YouTube tutorials. I got great curl tips from teenagers like Elle and Blair Fowler (not their real names). lol!
I hope some of this helps!! I spent much of my life hating my hair, and it’s great to finally feel like I have some options. A bit of color – highlights, whatever – really will help thicken it, too.
I LOVE Suave dry shampoo! I also have fine hair, but a lot of it, and if I use Suave, I can actually put it up and have it stay that way. It’s not really the best idea to wash your hair everyday anyway.
Okay I finally went with really short hair but there is a shampoo and conditioner from Samy called, yes, “Fat Hair”. It’s the best I found in the wet category.
For holding long hair in up-dos, wimpy little bobby pins do NOT do the job. You need
implements that the Victorians had that are not sold in drugstores of today. Look on etsy.com for “bodkin” or “Amish hairpin”. These are narrow u-shaped hair pins made of stiff wire about 3.5 inches long. Hair sticks (wooden) or hair forks can be used for similar purposes. Chopsticks are also used sometimes. If you have fine relaxed hair, the Japanese chopstick (or any stick) with highly polished, smooth finish, will slide out of your hair. (Those are for persons with tightly curled or Afro hair.) What you are doing with the stick, fork or pin is using it to “sew” the bun or up-do to your head. I also have a lot of fine, absolutely straight hair. One thing that works well for me is this:
(1) make one long braid starting at the back of my neck
(2) braid most of the way to the end of my hair and hold the end of the braid
(3) wrap the braid around itself with the end tucked under the wrap
(4) use 2 hair sticks or 2 real hairpins or a hair fork to sew the bun to my head.
There is also a barrette-style hair clip, available in many sizes called the Flexi-8.
See also many videos on You-Tube for how-to using all of the above hair implements.
I buy Kenra hairspray #25 (award-winning–it says so on the label) two cans at a time for my fine, thick hair that won’t hold a curl, and it’s worth the expense. Fortunately, my wonderful hairdresser who doesn’t even yell at me for coloring my own hair, knowing that I am a flat broke seminarian, buys it for me in bulk and passes along the savings, thank goodness, along with a free travel size every once in a while. One hairdresser once told me that I had to STOP teasing and spraying–she clearly has never had to live with hair like ours–so I found a new hairdresser (she actually SCOLDED me–the whippersnapper). Five minutes after I walk out of most salons, my hair is flat. Five hours after I leave my own can of hairspray, I still look pretty good. I also have found the $2.99 giant yellow bottle of LA Looks mega mega hold hair gel is a pretty good base before I blow dry, which is good because it balances out the $16 hairspray. I blowdry upside down, tease, spray upside down, arrange, and spray again. Then I can clip, pin, headband, or not, and it stays much better than it used to.
Another one with fine hair arrow-straight hair here…fine hair but lots of it. Fine and fly-away…
Mine is cut into a bob just below chin-length, and I have had to learn how to blow-dry it slightly curved-under. If I take a nap during the day I have to redo it when I wake up.
I’m a big fan of Redken products, and so I use 3 lots of Redken post washing (which I have to do every morning, or it looks lank at the roots in addition to being fine and fly away at the ends…dry shampoo makes it more prone to static.) I use Redken’s leave in conditioner for coloured hair, and then Thickening Lotion and another styling lotion I can’t remember the name of. If its a windy or humid day I finish off with hairspray.
I think that you have to find a style which works for you, and then resign yourself to managing it was well as you can and living with it for your lifetime. I have had this style or a variation on it since I was a kid (with a brief disastrous foray into the world of short hair and perms, which turned my hair frizzy and dry before it broke off near the scalp.
I do have it coloured with lowlights and I’m obsessive about the condition and the cut.
I’m another member of the fine but abundant straight as anything hair club. Like others, only 2 styles seem to work for me:
chin length bob
SHORT pixie cut (think Audrey Hepburn)
If you go short, find someone who does a GREAT cut.
If you go short (which I did) styling wax is your best friend.
“The bigger the hair, the closer to God.” –PB
Thanks for that. This bushy, curly-headed gal who’s always trying to tame the spirals needed that boost today. I do love my hair, but a good windy, humid day can definitely increase its unpredictable volume and make me feel an unprofessional mess. Now I’ll just think of my hair as growing closer to God. 🙂
My love and good wishes to my fine haired friends. I wouldn’t even know where to start in that situation.
Talk to your hair care professional. If he/she won’t listen to you, find someone else who will. Look at friends, colleagues, church members whose hair is great and ask them who they see. Drop the name. I see the person I see because she took 20 years off of one of my members, and I thought if she could do that for her, she could do that for me. So I went, and then proceeded to tell her what to do (fine hair, needed to be permed). . .until one day, she told me she wouldn’t do it anymore. I told her it gave my hair body and covered the grey (curly and you didn’t notice it). She said some highlights would do the trick, give it some body, and oh, we were going to be growing out the bangs, and getting a new cut. I gulped, and said I trusted her. . .and we laugh about it all to this day. The right cut, keeping it trimmed and highlighted. . .and trusting her as the professional (something we keep telling people to do with us) has made all the difference. Oh, and she tamed the eyebrows, too! [This is a great story and I feel that we need photos! – PB]