Leggings Police: You Have Been Deputized

If you can’t wear the top without the leggings then the leggings are acting as pants. – Alison McQuade, via Twitter

I can’t help it. There is work to be done here. Consider this a PeaceBang Crusade.

Leggings are back AGAIN, those fashion varmints, and we need to eradicate the problem from the clergy population, at least. It’s very simple: leggings are not pants and should not function as pants. This is not a feminist issue, it is not a body-shaming issue, it is a “You’re not dressed, please go home and put on some pants” issue. Leggings should never be worn in lieu of pants by adult women. Period. I am laying down the law on this.

“But my shirt is long! It covers my butt!” you say.
I don’t care. You’re not dressed if you’re not wearing pants or a skirt. Go put on your pants.

“But I’m on my way to the gym! And I’m slim and fit!” you may protest.
Nope. I’m still issuing a Leggings Citation. You’re a minister, and you’re not fully dressed. Don’t leave the house unless you’re fully dressed. No one in town needs to see your buns that clearly. If you’re out jogging in leggings, fine. You’re in the actual process of exercising and that’s different. But I don’t go to the gym in my bathing suit, do I? My bathing suits are modest and have pretty good coverage!

That’s not the point. There’s dressed, and there’s not dressed. The fabric on the vast majority of leggings is not substantial enough to function as a garment – they’re made cheaply, and they become the equivalent of wearing thin cotton socks on the lower half of your body. Let’s say it one more time: YOU JUST LOOK UNDRESSED!

I haven’t seen any adult woman or model wear leggings of any kind on their own and manage to look professional or mature. They do not belong on professional adult women, period. Not until the day when men start walking around like this:

There’s a reason men don’t wear leggings. It’s called power, and understanding that displaying one’s buttocks immediately lowers one’s professional standing, unless one is a matador or actor in an Elizabethan play (or perhaps a sex worker, but let’s not go there). Wear leggings under skirts, if you must, or under dresses with boots, great. But not as a pair of pants. This is the gospel according to PeaceBang. Let the people say AMEN.

You are now deputized to issue leggings citations to your sister clergy. Be gentle, but be firm.

16 Replies to “Leggings Police: You Have Been Deputized”

  1. I whole-heartedly agree, but I have some clarifying questions. I recently thought about wearing leggings a few days ago with an appropriately long dress & cardigan to the office. But then I remembered reading something on BTFM about leggings & the evils thereof…so I went back in the PB archives and found a post where you suggested that leggings are not appropriate ever except perhaps with boots in winter, if one is over the age of 20.

    I am over the age of 20 (barely) and definitely want to look and act professionally in the church. I don’t wear leggings as pants (though I’m brave enough to admit I have before, recognized my sin and am a changed woman), but am a little confused: are they ever appropriate in the office (ex. with a nice pair of flats & an appropriate length skirt/dress) or like skinny jeans are they just too youthful and teeny-bopper?

    Trying my best,
    EMD

  2. I can’t wait ’till the leggings trend disappears…

    As for the comment above, I think leggings under dresses kind of died a death about five or so years ago. Just wear a long enough dress or skirt. And wear opaque tights if it’s cold. Boots even! Lots of nice things to wear that don’t involve the dreaded leggings!

  3. I think my own judgment on this is that, as Eleanorjane suggests, this trend is hanging on with the younger set and that’s fine, but it’s already looking dated with anyone out of college. Elaine, my darling, just stay with the McQuade Ruling: if you can’t wear your top alone without the leggings without risking total over-exposure, don’t use leggings to make it “appropriate.” Also be aware that “cuts-off-at-the-ankle” immediately and instantly communicates Audrey Hepburn gamine, which I think is just plain wrong and unprofessional for a clergy woman.

  4. I don’t think most legging wearers (never in my life) realize just how much is exposed through that flimsy fabric. It’s the kind of thing where I get embarrassed for them, want to rush up and throw a coat over their bottom. “I can see your underwear!…in public…walking down the street…please stop.” [A thousand times YES to this. – PB]

  5. This raises a question for me which is not about leggings, but about being a deputy in the Quest For Appropriate Garmenture, (I just made up that word.)

    What to say? I might see someone totally inappropriately dressed, even someone who is or hopes to be clergy. Being Old and (maybe) Esteemed, I could say something that might make a difference to them. But what to say? They didn’t ask me for my opinion. I have no right to comment on what they are wearing. Or do I? If so, what should I say?

    Your thoughts on this would be appreciated, PB. After all, it was you who deputized us.

  6. Re: Yoga pants. Especially if they are knit. To and from the gym, and that is ALL. With a top that covers you-know-what–and I’m not talking about your derriere. Not acceptable for plane travel.

  7. I generally agree. However – the quality of the leggings DOES make a difference (for weekend wear (non Sundays obviously) or days off or whatever)) – HUE leggings are extremely thick and very different than the cheap version. With a sweater dress and boots (a long-enough sweater dress) I don’t think it’s a complete “don’t.”

  8. All this talk of leggings and boots has me curious if people also wear socks? Is there some slight comfort advantage to leggings and socks and boots over tights? I could get behind that. I have recently adopted a lifestyle that includes a LOT more walking and I am needing to reevaluate all my footwear decisions!

  9. I heartily agree that leggings are not pants.

    If memory serves, leggings first appeared in the 1980s as the original footless tights. The intention was to wear them with socks (remember the movies “Flash Dance” and “Footloose?”).

    In terms of practicality, they last far longer than tights since they don’t receive any wear on their nonexistent heels and toes. I think they are essential in cooler weather because they are usually thicker than tights. For women who wear skirts with boots, leggings can be matched to the color of the skirt (I frequently see leggings in a much wider variety of solid colors than the tights that are available) and you can still wear a nice thick pair of socks inside your boots that don’t show on the outside.

    I, too, recommend the HUE brand of leggings. And they are quite nice for lounging around the house – but only with close family or if you’re alone. [Sage advice, Rabbi. Thanks. -PB]

  10. I have read the leggings posts with interest and nostalgia (I rocked them majorly back in the early 90s). Now, for a leggings story…I am not ordained, but I do work in a church-related profession that is in a corporate setting. I just interviewed a candidate who was wearing a mid-thigh tunic, black leggings, and jeweled flip-flops. What is going on here?

    (PeaceBang: forgive me for not including my full name. I don’t want to be traceable and I know you have Lutheran readers who know me! But how could I not report this unthinkable wardrobe choice?)
    [I can’t even… – PB]

  11. Though I’m not a leggings fellow, I have taken up the environmentally responsible activity of riding my bicycle to and from church. I have even ridden on a preaching Sunday.

    I ride to work in loose fitting business casual clothing and though I may glisten upon arrival, living in a dry region means that I don’t much perspire.

    Recently, I was pre-warned by a congregant, who may well be a BTFM aficionado, that she has become aware that I am cycling to church. She indicated that while she supports the activity for reasons of sustainability and general physical fitness she does not wish to see me in bike shorts.

    I hasten to add, she has not and will not. [I’m holding my hand in the air in a silent but emphatic PRAISE THE LORD pose. – PB]

    Perhaps you have been deputizing in the Pacific NorthWest? [My flying monkeys are everywhere, darling. – PB]

    Signed,
    Sweatless in Seattle

  12. I’m in agreement on several points here–especially that no one needs to see anyone’s booties anytime. Why can’t we all go back to baggy sweats to go to pilates and such? When did it become required to wear form fitting clothes to exercise? And I say this as someone who wears leggings to pilates, because that seems to be the required uniform. And in my opinion, yoga pants are just as awful as leggings. I don’t care if they are pants–they are still way too revealing, in front and back. I know people are proud of their “yoga butts” but I really don’t want to stand in line behind you at the grocery store. Thank you and hallelujah, PB, for taking this on.

    But here’s where I am having trouble: 1) tights are okay in front of your family. I used to agree until my college aged son said to me, just last week as I was making dinner in my post-pilates outfit, “Mom, do you feel like you are fully dressed, or is that like going around in your underwear?” I said, actually, it is like being in my underwear. Thanks for the reminder, now I’ll go get dressed. 2) I’m really struggling with the not wearing leggings under dresses, and particularly for the “gamine” reason cited. Audrey Hepburn is still my style icon, and I love slim pants that end at the anklebones for that very reason. I am not sure why an age appropriate dress that comes to the knees cannot be worn with (entirely opaque) black leggings and a pair of pretty, feminine flats. Not for preaching, not for office days, but surely for a date with my partner or for dinner with friends. Is mid-40s really too old for that, PB? Please advise…

  13. Where do very sturdy black ponte pants fit into the scheme of proper leg coverings in public? No one seems to question their appropriateness in style blogs, but they are an awful lot like leggings insofar as they are form fitting. I have a nice pair from J. Crew that fit well, but I’m not sure about wearing them in public without a fairly long top (like, down to the knees—I’m size 00 but in my 50s) and knee-high boots. They feel sort of skimpy even though the fabric is quite thick. [Let me be your Jiminy Cricket and say, “Always let your conscience be your guide!” Unless your conscience has no idea if your ponte pants are too bootylicious, in which case ask a friend. It sounds like you’ve got the right idea. If I was a small size I might wear the pants with a long tunic AND another layer, with boots. So maybe a jacket or cardigan. – PB]

Comments are closed.