I’m sick and angry about what is happening in our country around government’s hyped-up efforts to control sexuality and women’s bodies. I am so upset that I can’t even formulate a coherent argument. I only know that I was happy to be able to donate $100 to the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Health for their new campaign “I Am A Fan Of Birth Control” when they called today, although I almost never respond to phone solicitations (full disclosure, I was on the Clergy Advisory Council of the RCRC in the late 1990’s). I also just went and made a $100 donation to the Religious Institute, a multi-faith organization that is dedicated to having a public conversation around sexuality, religion and social justice. It recently lost all of its funding and I admire and respect its Executive Director, the Rev. Debra Haffner, so much that I am happy to forego some luxuries this month in order to support the survival of her amazing organization.
You know I love fashion. It’s one of my favorite art forms because it is living, evolving, open to personal interpretation, exciting, and accessible to every person who dresses him or herself in the morning. I love style, I love the study of image and what it communicates about individuals and institutions.
That does not mean that I am uncritical of the fashion industry. I appreciate it as a powerful entity and I respect its place in the world of the arts and commerce, but I take high fashion with a grain of salt, referring to it for inspiration and out of curiosity and respect for the real artists working in the field.
Grain of salt or no, fashion is big business and a major cultural force. And given our current political climate, this just makes me angry. Look at these images with me:
First, from Nina Ricci’s Spring Collection, this little white ensemble that reminds me of nothing so much as a fetish nurse costume or a child’s bathing suit. Creepy, especially with the little candy striper cap.
Here’s Jessica Biel modeling the look in the March issue of W magazine (click to enlarge):
Interesting. Boring and bored pretty lady sunbathing and keeping her skirt from blowing up? Or prone, deathly female figure barely covered in a white garment (reminiscent of a hospital johnny) trying to keep her genitals covered? I see both. I see more, but I’ll leave you to read the image for yourself.
Now check this out from the Louis Vuitton Spring Line:
These granny panty looks are all the rage now, and they fill ME with rage. Because, you know, women’s bodies aren’t enough on display as it is. By all means let’s strip off their pants and skirts and invite them to walk around with their bodies almost completely revealed to the public gaze, so we can further objectify them (or ourselves). Then, after we’ve stripped them and made them believe that this is not just revolting objectification, we’ll put them in precarious little shoes to make sure they can barely walk, let alone run from danger (or, you know, just walk to work comfortably).
If you want to know why I rail so hard about leggings, it’s because I see them as part of a contiuum of encouraging women to reveal more and more of their bodies in the name of fashion or comfort. I’m going to say the words “crotch” and “butt” because they need to be said. I can’t think of a time I saw a woman stride by wearing leggings as pants when I didn’t immediately question her good judgment and feel terribly embarrassed that she was putting her crotch and rear on display like that, to be both consumed by the sexual gaze and condemned for her bad judgment (by old fuddy duddies like me, except that I’m not a fuddy-duddy). I always want to whip out a camera and take footage of her walking away and present her with the video with these words, “Did you ever think about what this outfit looks like from the back? When you’re in motion? Don’t you have any sense of dignity or privacy?”
I wonder if there’s any correlation between women looking as though privacy means nothing to them and politician’s insistence on invading our private lives. I’m not blaming the victim (and we’re all victims of this current insanity — welcome to the U.S. Taliban), but we need to understand how image and culture and values interplay. I remember going to the State House to testify on a reproductive rights bill and some young women were there from Planned Parenthood. They were dressed so disrespectfully to themselves and to others (and I was a ripe old 34 years old at the time, not nearly the cranky spinster I am today) that they undermined their own cause before they even opened their mouths. And frankly, when they did open their mouths, their Valley Girl inflections further undercut the seriousness of the justice issues they were there to speak about. Some of that is age, experience and maturity. Some of that, though, is having been persuaded by feminism and the self-esteem movement that issue of propriety and dignity are irritating, oppressive and undeserving our attention. So very naive, that.
The fashion industry needs to be provocative, and it needs to be super sexy. That’s its job. Your job, and mine, is to use fashion to our advantage, not to be victims of its latest whims. And at times, it is our job to cast a particularly critical eye on what fashion is suggesting and push back or outright condemn it. If fashion is currently saying, “Hey gals, no part of your body should remain a private matter between you and your self and soul, put it all on display!” it is our responsibility to say, “You’re being stupid and irresponsible. That’s just you trying to be provocative and sell magazines. I won’t buy it, I won’t wear it, and I frankly find it insulting that you’re dishing this up. Give me strong, powerful, wearable, inspiring and beautiful — don’t give me a vision of women that plays into my enemy’s lowest opinion of me.”
Thanks to my favorite blog, TLo Blog for the photos.
And God bless you, Gary Trudeau, for tackling this outrage in Doonesbury.





I love your righteous rage.
Truly I think Marilyn Monroe was 10 times sexier in that white dress standing on the grate than these models in what looks to the naked eye to be actual underwear.
I just read today’s press release about Governor Perry (my governor) totally working over the 130,000 women who rely on Medicaid for their health care. I am outraged at the war that is being oppressively and religiously waged on women. I can usually express myself pretty well but I am stumped for strong enough words for the raping and pillaging that’s going on around women’s bodies. And, when I stray away from the blogs and media I regularly read, into “real America,” I am saddened and frustrated by the wholesale ignorance and cruelty that is expressed there.
Fashion irritates me. I weep for the images it has fed us of young girls and girl-like women dressed provocatively and for how those images have become part of the background to our lives.
I appreciate and celebrate your rage. As someone told me at seminary (or maybe I read somewhere), if you’re not mad you’re not awake.
I admire your incisive commentary on this issue. I would disagree, however, with the idea that feminism (the feminist movement?) taught young women that personal dignity is oppressive, etc. The feminist movement in my experience upholds the innate dignity of women in general and of individual women in particular. [It would be great to talk about this. I agree with you and then I think there’s also this strand in feminism of “wear whatever you want/present however you want and let THEM deal with it.” It’s just not thoughtful or wise. – PB]
While we’re on the topic, could we please ban the phrase “put on your big girl panties”? Thank you. [I’m happy to, in your honor. – PB]
Amen. You have said everything I’ve wanted to say but, in my righteous anger, have not been articulate enough to say myself. Thank you, PB, you’ve done it again.
I totally agree. My general thoughts on all this are fairly incoherent. Your mentioning of the US “Taliban” has got me thinking about the revealing clothes in the fashion industry in the US in comparison with the utterly opposite end of the spectrum that the burkah represents. I also wonder if men’s high fashion is similarly revealing (I don’t really keep track of runway fashion).
I also fully support the wearing of granny panties as underwear (under clothing!!) because I believe in being wedgie-free and I think that anyone who claims thongs are “comfortable” are either lying or have a lobotomy. 🙂
While we’re on this topic, can I just say WHAT the HECK is with all the sheer fabric on the runway lately??? What is that I don’t even…??
The good news is that Peacebang is not the only one speaking with her pocketbook–one of my congregants is the president of the local Planned parenthood and they are getting an incredible boost in both donations and advocacy–sometimes I think it has to get so bad so that we get appropriately outraged to move to action! Our paper has removed doonesbury from print this week, so thanks for sharing–I can second the distaste of a transvaginal sonogram–ugh!
Preach it! I’m pleased you managed to get some good words out of your outrage ‘cos you’re informing and encouraging us by speaking out.
I recently re-read the chapters on Fashion in Susan Falludi’s Backlash. You say what she said more concisely, but it is fascinating to read her depictions of people in business dress avowing that women “need” to wear revealing and just plain awkward clothing in the workplace. As I’ve mentioned before, I work with very bright college students, and I’m constantly struggling with ways to tell them how to dress for professional talks.
Like Mary Cauliflower, I am (especially now that it is spring in NC) frequently “struggling with ways to tell [the young ladies I work with] how to dress” for school. As in, “I understand that you think that wearing skin-tight short-shorts under your very tiny mini-skirt makes it okay, dearest… But discovering what you are wearing underneath your outer layer is not suitable for school.” If only the skirts were so long as those the models are sporting! Or, “I’m sorry– those are running shorts. We are discussing and studying right now, not running and THEY HIKE ALL THE WAY UP YOUR THIGHS WHEN YOU SIT DOWN. Please go put on pants.” Some of the long-shirts/short shorts combos make the poor girls look like they forgot to get dressed all the way.
I frequently feel like the Wicked Witch of the Lost Cause and have trouble articulating a good explanation for why the girls (ages 10-13) should change besides “the dress code says so” or “it’s distracting”… I think “because it lacks dignity” may be my new reason. Thank you, Peacebang! [Love you lots, Ma’am!! – PB]
Do you object to leggings when worn with dresses?
The job of the fashion industry is to sell clothes. For people living in a capitalist country, we are amazingly naive about marketing. Fashion magazines exist to sell us something and if we don’t know that, and don’t take a look at what we’re being sold, then we’re pawns.
Teenagers love to catch adults trying to pull a fast one on them, so a unit on seeing through advertising should be very popular in high school, if done right and not in the spirit of “let me show you what a sucker you are for buying that product every teenage girl is into.”
(What I always want to know about high-fashion models is: (1) why do they look so miserable? (2) why is their hair so ugly? (3) how many of them can afford the outfits they’re modeling?)