Further Reflections on Fat Haters, The Ministry of BTFM and “Women Of Size”

Hi darlings!

My precious little hound tore his ACL on Saturday afternoon, which means that Big Mommy Beagle has been helping him around, carrying him upstairs and generally worrying about him.

I want to thank you for your thoughtful, loving and supportive responses to the Fat Hater e-mail I got from that nasty soul in Louisville. Here is the link to the post and the comments.
I was trying to pick out an outfit for church this past Sunday morning and thought to myself: Now, see, if I didn’t make an effort to look put-together, that same guy would deride me for being a big, fat slob and a disgrace to the church because of THAT. Ya can’t win.

Maybe someday irrational hatred of certain body types, colors, or sizes will be considered a form of mental illness.

I wanted to follow up on a few things in regard to that conversation. First, I appreciate hearing many of you talk about your experience with my tough love. When I first started blogging on the subject of clergy image, I knew I would get a lot of push-back. Therefore, I launched the blog with a fairly outrageous voice and persona, making PeaceBang a larger-than-life (ha!) online character whom I wanted to SWEEP into the room, so to speak, and captivate everyone with her trenchant observations, wit and strength. I always imagined myself in a feather boa when writing my earliest posts. This wasn’t a deliberate strategy but an intuitive one, as I knew from my years in ministry that the emotional culture of clergy gatherings was, in a word, prissy. I knew that many would be insulted by my insistence that we address the fact that we looked like frumpy slobs, and that they would tell me I wasn’t allowed to talk about that. I knew they would accuse me of being a big meanie and tell me that I was shallow, unChristian, and an embarrassment to the ministry.

And I was right!

When one of my early detractors accused me of secretly being a gay man writing as a woman, I was absolutely thrilled. Having been raised in the theatre by gay men with tremendous talent, commitment, a fierce passion for the art, and a fantastic eye for what looks good on stage, I felt I could have received no higher compliment. For better or worse, I would not be the woman I am today without gay men. My parents raised me to be a strong woman, and my gay male friends helped me to live that out with snap and sass.

I fielded a lot of whining in those early years as we built a community together where we could talk about these issues, admit our insecurities, navigate the complicated shifts in the contemporary church and what it means for clergy image, and openly discuss previously taboo subjects like bra size and pantyhose. The whiners slowly faded away, only occasionally making an appearance to scold me for daring to convene the conversation at all or for sticking to my opinion when they disagreed with me. I was accused of not tolerating any dissent (a false claim, as any reading of the archives will easily inform anyone), which was really a way of saying, “I don’t like the fact that you’re claiming authority here!”

When people asked me, “Who are YOU to write about this?” I responded, “I am Victoria Weinstein and I am writing about it because I wanted to. You can do the same thing about a subject you love and care about. My authority comes from my readers, who have learned to trust my advice and who understand that my scrutiny comes from my love for them and for the Church.”

It has been quite a (*cue overused religious word theme song*) JOURNEY, and one that shows no sign of ending.

The second thing I want to say is in response to the commenter who said, “Thank you for reminding us that we matter.”

Darling, I love you and it isn’t just that you MATTER, it is that you are a LEADER. Part of my commitment in being a Rotund Religious Leader writing about personal aesthetic and image is about getting us beyond the basics of self-esteem and acceptance and into Fierceness. My argument all along for all of us has been hey, not only do we need to show up prepared and sent forth to do ministry in our congregations, we need to show up as impressive, put-together public leaders in a society that no longer gives any meaningful cred to the Church. It’s all lip service, kids! Don’t be fooled! We’re a relic of a bygone era to most people, which is why in so many parts of the world we’re regarded as more of a curiosity than as a valuable community resource.

Let me say a bit more about that: I know I sound like a terrible cynic, but I spend a lot of time with progressive, socially involved, highly educated unchurched folks and from their perspective, our efforts amount to very little. Our clergy meetings, endless organizational conflicts, power struggles over tiny amounts of money and turf wars over petty fiefdoms look positively quaint to them. It’s a lot of sound and fury signifying, if not nothing, then certainly not much. What they do respect about the ministry and the Church is our care for the vulnerable, our commitment to grappling with questions of ultimate meaning, and the spiritual care of the parish. At best, they see us as community social workers with a spiritual bent. At worst, they see us as insular, frumpy, self-involved, self-absorbed curators of a fusty institution that would do the world good to up and die already.

Every time you make an appearance in a role of public leadership, every time you chat up someone on the bar stool next to you and happen to mention that you’re clergy, every time you befriend your local barista at Starbucks and invite them to the church event, every time you sweat it out at the Y and strike up a conversation with the person on the elliptical cross-trainer next to you and mention your ministry — EVERY TIME, you have an opportunity to push back against that image of fusty, insular irrelevancy.

So again, you more than matter. You are a leader, you are an emissary with an urgent message, you are a disciple. For those clergy persons who spend all of their time in church meetings, church work and denominational service and think it a virtue, PeaceBang has one question: what does “sent forth” mean to you?

My third and final point: When fat females call themselves “women of size” or “large women” or “BBWs,” it is not for non-fat men or women to approve or disapprove of them. The power to name ourselves — whatever our affinity groups — is basic to human dignity. When a reviled group that is regularly referred to by nasty, denigrating names and oppressed by irrational prejudice chooses to name itself, it is not political correctness but an expression of positive identity formation and pride. Every clergy person should know this basic premise of anti-oppression work. “Woman of size” (a designation I don’t use for myself, preferring the simplicity of “fat”) is not a euphemism. It is a correction. It is a re-claiming. It is a way for overweight women to inform others that they will choose the term by which their bodies are described by others, and that that term will not carry negative connotations. Again, a basic premise of anti-oppression work: those who are not part of the oppressed group do not get to approve of, disapprove of, or dismiss as euphemism the names that victims of hatred and prejudice choose to identify themselves. Our responsibility as ministers is to listen carefully and with respect to the ways that people choose to name themselves, and then then use that name for them.

6 Replies to “Further Reflections on Fat Haters, The Ministry of BTFM and “Women Of Size””

  1. Perhaps I am choosing the wrong place for these comments… and with that cheery introduction, I will dive in.

    First of all, I understand (and largely agree with) what PB is saying here. Yes, yes, yes, and AMEN to the harsh truth that we are too often “quaint” (“such a pretty background for our pictures!”), “historical”, etc, rather than being relevant, challenging, powerful. And yes to the fact that image matters.

    I will add that I have browsed some significant blogs around Fat Acceptance, Health at Every Size, etc. I think there is a lot of interesting, challenging, smart stuff being written.

    Nevertheless – as I was reminded of on a recent trip to the US – there is something new and strange going on in our western world, most obviously (and perhaps most shockingly, as an outsider looking around with “tourist” eyes) in the USA. Obesity (etc) is a problem and one that we in the church need to be addressing – relevantly. Spirituality and theologically. Without resorting to prejudice and shaming, but nevertheless head-on.

    Obesity can occur for any number of reasons – yes. It is not indicative of a moral failing. It does not reflect one’s worth as a human being – any more than any other physical reality. But too many unhealthy calories and not enough movement are all too often key factors. Poverty is also very strongly correlated, absolutely. How is this not a key issue for our churches? Justice, health, well-being: these used to be our strength!

    And I appreciated the person (Brooke, I think) who in the last post pointed out that we clergy need to start with ourselves. I am not skinny but I am also not a woman of size, and I cannot buy a clergy shirt without needing to tailor it significantly in order for it not to look sloppy. No matter what size I buy (neck size being the limiting factor)! Not only does this make already expensive shirts even more expensive, it says nothing promising about our overall health as clergy.

    This is true of both men’s and women’s shirts – I bought a man’s clergy shirt in a fashion emergency (on the aforementioned US trip) and I could fit, twice-over, in a shirt that was selected because it fit both my neck size and arm length. What is going on?!

    And this does not even begin to mention the alcoholism, depression, etc, that are endemic among clergy. Or the subtle pressure I have noticed to work more, harder, longer; the lack of support in the midst of toxic parish environments; the retired clergy who work 35hrs/wk in a “part time” charge (hey, if 70hrs is a normal full-time position, 35hrs/wk IS part time!); etc. But that’s another rant for another time…

  2. Absolutely, Parodie. The issues of self-care, health and the fattening of America are big, fat subjects (wink) that we’ll have to get into in another post. Check the “Self Care” and “Feeding the Pastor” archives for some of my past writings on these topics.

  3. Amen to it all, PeaceBang. I hope you will continue to raise your voice and ignore the haters. I will never understand why they are so threatened by the existence of women who are smart, self-confident, and articulate. If they don’t like what you have to say, no one is holding a gun to their heads to make them read it….

    I am grateful for your voice and your witness. (and I hope Max is better very soon!)

    Pax,
    Doxy

  4. PB,

    Wow! All I can say is, You Go Girl! “Snap and sass” – you have that and more! I’m a loyal, male reader of BTFM and appreciate greatly the message and ministry of this blog. You are the only one (I know of) who is discussing the issues of clergy image – and God knows someone needs to do it. A big thank you for taking this on and for doing so with such style and panache. You rightly point out that a lot is at stake in how we dress and carry ourselves. You are right on in noting that there are many who see us “as insular, frumpy, self-involved, self-absorbed curators of a fusty institution that would do the world good to up and die already.” Thank you for the encouragement to present ourselves with style and class so as to “push back against that image of fusty, insular irrelevancy.” Snap!

Comments are closed.