In light of this post about minimal steps to take to look acceptable when we feel crummy, concerned laywoman Eleanorjane writes,
Hmm… is it really not okay for ministers to look like schlubby death warmed over after they’ve been sick? (or even while they’re still getting over being sick?).
I’m not a minister, but I’ve never minded our female minister dressing a varying levels of formality and put-together-ness depending on what she’s doing and how well she is. I would be more inclined to encourage said minister to go back to bed rather than go to the effort of trying to look well when they’re not.
The exception would be leading a worship service or some other formalish event – if they absoltuely have to drag themselves out to do it then they should try to look the best they can so as not to distract folks from worship.
That’s my two cents… but I do think it’s important to leave room for ministers to be human. What message does it send if the minister can’t relax a bit sometimes around her congregation? “I’m perfect all the time – so you can’t be imperfect with me!†It could be a bit intimidating, having a perfectly put-together minister. Also, I do think it’s important for ministers to model self-care.
Feel free to ignore if I’m mis-interpreting…
I don’t think you’re misinterpreting at all, EJ, and thanks for commenting. I think I wasn’t clear.
Martyrdom went out of fashion among fashionable people centuries ago, darlings, but you’d think some of us were Perpetua and Laurence wanna-be’s by the way we behave sometimes. PeaceBang herself is certainly guilty of this.
So let me be clearer than I was.
Please stay home and take care of yourself for as long as you possibly can when you’re sick. Cancel appointments, remember that God is actually still moving the heavens and the earth even when you’re sound asleep snorfling through your poor congested nose, and that your church needs you to be well for Sunday more than it needs you to give your Undoubtedly Sage Advice at the week’s meetings. Give it a rest, chums.
Like, if it really feels like an effort to put on lip gloss, you’re in no condition to even BE at the office. Remember that by being there when you are truly unwell you are modeling an unhealthy work ethic even as you spread your unhealthy germs around to innocent bystanders.
And remember that great quote, spoken with such sass by Miss Dolly Parton in “Steel Magnolias”: “Get off the cross, we need the wood!”
So to answer Eleanorjane’s query, I would say, “Ministers who are getting over being sick should consider being able to groom themselves a condition for returning to public life.” I also agree wholeheartedly with her point that our appearance at worship and rites of passage absolutely must be up to snuff even when we’re not feeling so. The show must go on, doves, and trust Auntie PB: you may feel like ka-ka poo-poo at home getting ready, but once you get the adrenaline pumping and the energy from the Holy Spirit flowing through you, you will feel much better. We show biz types can assure you that if if is possible to get through a matinee and a night show of a musical while running a 101 temp and throwing up at intermission, it is certainly humanly possible to lead worship well and energetically when at less than optimum health.


I’ve seen our priest tap someone else to preach on a few days notice, while she rested enough to handle the sacramental side. What a good example of self-care, and not driving oneself off a cliff! No drama whatsoever, just knowledge of priorities and limits.
Hmmm…actually, I think that hauling yourself into work when you’re obnoxiously sick and probably infectious, is evidence of the sin of Pride. Among Catholics, this is one of the notorious Seven Deadlies.
That said, I think a lot of church members, regardless of denomination, view their pastors as being on permanent beck & call. Too often, pastors fall in with this and don’t set appropriate boundaries.
Ooh, how exciting, my very own reply! Thanks PB 🙂
Further comment on the self-care thing… I resisted being a teacher for years ‘cos I saw my Ma exhausting herself and even making herself sick working very long hours and thought ‘I don’t want to do that’.
Something that puts me off ministry is the model of our minister who seems to be busy for very long hours six days a week. (And she gets up at the crack of dawn and prays for two hours! I love God, but not in the morning!). I think our minister is one of the better ones in that she does have an reasonably iron-clad Monday off every week.
I presume if God did get around to calling me to ministry, He’d inspire me in spite of what seems to be the workload, but still…
If the minister is contagious i think it would be better (and understood by the congregagion) if she/he got someone to do supply (which is what temping is called in the Episcopal church, not sure what this is called in other denominations) so she doesn’t expose the congregation there seems overall to be a trend towards staying home when you are sick instead of going to work & toughing it out to lessen the possibility of making others sick which I think is spreading to the church world too
Timely topic. I returned from vacation and church camp with an eye infection that got better then roared back to life on a Friday. I was able to see a specialist who prescribed a new med. I was better by Sunday — no longer in horrible pain, but still startlingly red-eyed and puffy-eyed with slight bruising on one cheek. I thought long and hard about whether to preach Sunday and decided to because I was on the mend. There was a limit to how much makeup I could use without causing a whole slew of new problems. At church I explained what was going on and kept a very wide berth from everyone — no touching, hugging or handshaking. In retrospect, I wish I had called and gotten someone else to fill in that day. Much too much attention was paid to me that morning. The good thing was that I got the tiniest, tiniest glimpse of how it must have felt for the lepers to have to shout “Unclean, unclean!”
I didn’t think twice about staying home from the office the week before, but in 20 years I’ve only stayed home sick once on a Sunday. I have preached through pneumonia, the flu, sinus infections and migraines. Is it pride or expectation or supposed expectation? I don’t know. Early on I think I was trying to be tough so as not to be compared with all their previous male ministers and found weak and wanting. I thought I had developed more sense in recent years, but old habits die hard.