Thanks to Wendy D., I was able to read this fascinating critique of Kate Middleton’s wardrobe and to see some truly hideous suggestions for how to improve it.
The bashing of Kate’s HORRIBLE taste in clothes is spot on, but the suggestions for improvement are almost 100% ugly as sin as well.
I wish I had the time to offer my own suggestions but alas, that would take far too long. Maybe next week. For now, just take a look at the lovely Kate and see what you think. She’s absolutely gorgeous and has an amazing figure so it PAINS PeaceBang to see her stepping out in such terrible ensembles. I’m almost equally as pained to see what clothes were recommended for her. How frumpy can you get!? There’s a way to look like a future royal that doesn’t involve such ugly options.

Blech! Some of the “improved” outfits are more horrible than the originals! I’d like to see what happens with her wardrobe when she has a royal budget at her disposal.
I think Kate Middleton has wonderful fashion sense, by which I mean, to me she looks stunning 90% of the time. She’s been photographed in hundreds, if not thousands, of different outfits, and these were the worst offenders…that’s a pretty good W-L record if you ask me.
This handful of outfits that have been singled out are definitely near the bottom, though, and I couldn’t agree more that the “improved” outfits are just as terrible–with the exception of the suggested floral dress, which I think is lovely.
I think some of the improved outfits are ghastly. In particular with the first set of pictures I love the pattern of the Diane Von Furstenberg dress under the jacket.
I think the lady has great fashion sense. I particularly like the big navy blue hat she is wearing in some of the pictures. I know hats are much more important in the UK than they are here and she has some nifty ones.
Why are we/they trying to turn her into another Diana? Let us think on that. . . .
Srsly? Hey, Daily Mail: if you’re going to complain that one of Kate’s shoes are too “matchy-matchy” for the (goregous!) outfit she’s wearing, don’t give a suggestion in which the shoes are EQUALLY and AWFULLY “match-matchy.” (And hideous, too.)
I dunno, I kind of liked some of her outfits, and has already been mentioned, this is probably the worst of the worst for her. And most of the “suggestions” were pretty terrible, too.
Good grief. She’s a kid. [On what planet is almost 30 years old a kid? – PB] She carries herself very well given her situation, I think. She’s managed all the drama and publicity for years, and this is all they can come up with to thrash her with. She will have a stylist soon enough to dress her like the Queen Mother. I say leave her alone. [I don’t think you understand the point of this sort of editorial, Madge, or the function of women like this in the public eye as symbolic figures of great importance in a particular country. This isn’t about “thrashing her,” it’s about analyzing how fashion, power, status and personality intersection to make history. What Kate wears and what trends she chooses to adopt will have an enormous, staggering effect on the fashion world and the economy. I do wish we would stop with this sentimental naivetee. – PB]
I’m most impressed by the fact that they are trying to SEX her up so much. For the “Summer Wedding”, they poo-pooed the fact that she wore a gorgeous heel that happened to be mid-height– and proceeded to suggest a 4+ inch platformed MONSTROSITY that looks not only uncomfortable, but sleazy and totally inelegant. Ick.
And I love the comment about tights- that she would “never be taken seriously” (?!?!). I simply don’t get it. What do TIGHTS have to do with whether she would be taken seriously? It might have simply been COLD, for heaven’s sake. Tights with a dress are wonderful for winter in the UK. Ridiculous.
I loved some of Kate’s original outfits (or at least parts of them), and thought the “improvements” were mostly hideous, with only a couple exceptions (I liked the cream “cocktail” dress was pretty, and the bold floral dress for the “girl’s dinner”).
Okay, so she doesn’t dress like a princess yet. Possibly because she doesn’t yet have the income to dress like Diana did. She is not the daughter of a wealthy earl, to the manor born. The Winter Wedding outfit is lovely. The style choices the editor proposes are mostly terrible replacements. It is possible that she wore some of those outfits in public to measure how much of herself she could be if she married William.
As for the ring, William gave it to her as a cherished memento of his mother and though he is very wealthy, it is one of his most cherished possessions. After Diana’s death he and Harry were taken into her rooms by her butler at Kensington Palace to sort through some of her things. Harry chose the sapphire ring immediately. Later, as an adult, he gave it to William to propose to Kate. William is trying to make his mother present through her wedding ring on Kate’s finger. It is not probably a reminder of his parent’s marriage.
the black boots are too “wintery”? duh, it’s WINTER @@
and the wedding photo – geesh, the propsed alternative in cream and balck is sooo matronly! 🙁
Why all this about the ring? My sister in law has my late mother’s engagement ring because my parents were divorcing when my brother was about to propose. It (like Kate’s) is not so much a reminder of my parents marriage which was about as successful as Charles & Di’s but more because what else do you do with an old engagement ring? You find a new lady coming into the family & give it to her.
I liked all of the suggested outfits except for “date night” and “winter wedding.” The suggested “Summer Wedding” platform shoes are super tacky, though. They look like the shoes on the rack in front of Charlotte Russe in my local mall. Kate’s too old, too rich, and too classy to wear shoes like that.
Disclaimer: I’m 26 and could see myself wearing most of the suggested outfits. *prepares to get jumped on*
I thought most of the suggested outfits were impractical – it is currently winter in England so going out in short sleeves with no jacket isn’t a good idea. Also, Kate probably has to stand quite a lot so shoes would need to be flattering but moderately comfy. And bare legs are considered a bit declasse for a princess to be…
I think Princess Mary of Denmark nails it most of the time: http://www.hellomagazine.com/royalty/201006043645/princess-mary/denmark/fashionable-washington/1/
Kids, don’t go off the rails, here. God forbid Kate should be another Diana. I wasn’t into Diana and that’s not the point.
The point is that Kate doesn’t know how to dress. Her outfits are terribly proportioned, she’s on-trend but does it wrong, she goes Ultra Frumpsville for every formal occasion (and for those, she really does need a stylist). She’s a gorgeous girl with enough sense of personal style to really do it right, which I hope she will learn to do.
Please don’t forget what this blog is about. It is about public image and style. Kate is a public figure and she needs to find a style. This isn’t about your taste or what you would wear or whether you think people should “leave her alone” (please, that ship has sailed long ago!). Are you learning anything from studying these images? Do you see why her proportions are off, why her choice of fabric is often glaringly wrong for the occasion, how the cut of her formal wear works against her figure and makes her look boxy and thirty years older than she is? Is your eye getting better at seeing the details or what makes an outfit work or not work? Can you translate this to your own choices in attire?
(Yes, I know about hats in England. I do actually study fashion, you know. I didn’t say a thing about her hats. I’m the granddauther of a milliner and I’m ALWAYS going to be hot for hats)
When you see Kate, do you see someone who is projecting self-confidence and self-knowledge? What image *should* Kate be projecting, given her new status? These are the questions I would like you to ask yourselves when you read a post.
As I said to Madge, the point of reading Kate’s image is to engage in a time-honored tradition of analyzing how fashion, power, status and personality intersection to change history. People who don’t understand how Kate Middleton is poised to influence the world of fashion and her national economy are being very naive.
Crankily yours, PB
Were she truly powerful she could wear whatever she wants (just look at what Hilary Clinton did once she was “off the throne. She took her own power back, got a new stylist who got her, and went on with things).
But, her considerable finesse in dealing with media and a future king for the last decade (DECADE) has lately been boiled down to picking her clothes apart, and I have to say that bugs me. Soon she will have no control over what she wears, but what I have seen is for the most part really cute and creative and flattering.
I think the primary article here is typical English snark, and that’s about all.
Clearly, I’m too tired from my day to be trusted with grammar 😉
by her, of course, I mean Ms Middleton.
The “primary article” I refer to is of course the piece from British “journalism”, not our dear Peacebang’s.
I do think in our culture a 30 year old can very much be a “kid” in many ways. She has shown herself to be uniquely self-possessed.
She is not truly powerful she is marrying a powerful man. This is akin to Princess Diana who had the title for marrying a prince as opposed to
Anne the Princess Royal the Queen’s daughter who dresses very well is to the manor born and doesn’t have to worry about this so much.
Kate will set fashions. Diana’s wedding dress set bridal fashion for 10 years as did many of her other clothes. But despite my fondness for fashion and my love for thie blog & the NYT Style Section I am hoping Kate finds a niche for herself that is socially regarded as more heavyweight than dresses. She is making history she will be the first university educated British Princess.
I just can’t get past a 21st century writer’s using the word “nude” as a color (as in, “accessories in nude”). What color would that be, Liz?
[Good point, and I’m sure I’m guilty of it as well. But I’m not sure what term to use as an alternative, except for maybe “white lady nude.” – PB]
I don’t think I’ve ever heard you say it.
Hm, what word? How about beige? Ivory? Off-white? The people who come up with colors like “mushroom,” “clay,” and “sun-washed rock” must be up to the challenge. After all, we still have terms for brown now that “n***** brown” has been tossed in the Hopelessly Racist bin.