Just a quick yoo-hoo to seminarians out there!
As a professional courtesy, when you approach a senior colleague for mentoring of any kind, be very specific about what kind of help or training you want, how much time you think it may take, and for what duration you would like to work with them.
If you do that discernment beforehand, it will greatly improve your chances of receiving a positive response from your colleague. If you do not, what you are unintentionally requesting is that they figure out for you how they are supposed to help you.
The same advice goes for working with lay leaders or anyone else whose time and talent you would like to avail yourself of. A respectful request is always appreciated but it’s especially considerate to specify what you need, when you need, and for how long.
Just a word to the wise.

I have come to believe that part of the challenge (for seminarians, clergy, and lay persons alike), is that we can all be very inept at articulating precisely what we are requesting. This is simply a broad flaw in human nature. We may have a general sense that we need “help with X”, but what we have not articulated (perhaps even to ourselves) is that what we may truly need is specific help with “completing X in a manner that is timely, professional, but not held hostage to ideals of perfection”. My advice to anybody who is on the recieving end of a request is not to be shy about asking clarifying questions. And for those making the request, do not be shy about talking with your peers to explore what you precisely need before you approach the person you are asking assistance from.
Ditto, when you are asking for a reference letter. Give some idea why you asked me–what it is that you think I know about you–that will be useful in your application.
Yes, very important to mention that “we” (clergy, -church-staff) make clear what we request from other people. Especially lay people who do their church work in their spare time.
I absolutely agree; it is however a little like asking someone to ride their bike to the bike repair shop, or log on to the computer to get computer repairs. Most of us–particularly in our early formation, need a lot of help in figuring out what we want and need, and seminaries aren’t good at helping people discern.
I also agree about the comment Chavale made. So much is behind the desire to find “self starters” for church leadership (like, no clergy is actually doing the leading). Disciples are made,not born.
I will take this opportunity to say again why this website is so great! In terms of my job as a grad student, I’ve been asked to write letters for undergrads I barely know, and in one case I have no idea why the student asked me. The other comment is about church, as a lay person, I know I have skills, and in my home church it was easy to get involved, having gone there forever. I’m not a ‘self-starter’ or extroverted… so it’s tough to find the happy balance between wanting to become involved and using my skills while at the same time wanting to develop as a disciple, and stretch myself in new ways.