I’ve been noticing that I don’t worry any more if I’m dressed in sweats and beat up clogs and need to run an errand. I just go out. I certainly don’t love it if someone from my congregation sees me out looking slobby, but I don’t stress too much about it. I’ve been in this parish for nine years and people see me out walking my dog in yoga pants and a hoodie all the time. I do think that being known in the community makes a difference in how much we need to prepare to be seen in it. At this point I have friends and neighbors and relationships with the local folk. They’ve seen me dressed up and they’ve seen me dash out for a quart of milk with greasy hair and no make-up. That’s life. When I arrived here I was younger and less experienced and had a reputation to establish. For better or for worse, it’s established!
But there is another aspect to this sense of relaxed sartorial vigilance: I live in a town with lots of Perfect People (my congregation is drawn from at least five towns, so this isn’t a commentary on them) who spend a lot of time, effort and money on appearances. I say “appearances” rather than “appearance” because, as is the case with much of middle class and upper middle class America, the pursuit of perfect appearances extends from the person to the home to the car to the children to the dog, and etc. I am becoming more and more aware of the damage this expensive and soul-destroying effort has on individuals, families and the planet — or perhaps I should say I am becoming more disturbed by it — with every passing year, and I most emphatically want to find ways to avoid being caught up in it, or identified with it.
I know that many of you are nodding and say, “We TOLD you so — we TOLD you that ministers should wear jeans and get down with the people.” But that’s not what I mean. I’m not suggesting that you throw the polar fleece back over your head, don the barn clogs and the frumpy jeans and let your beard grow all scraggly to communicate authenticity and a protest against American consumerism. I still believe that that attire is disrespectful, sloppy and unacceptable in most ministerial settings. I’ve made my case about that hundreds of times, so I won’t repeat myself here.
But the other day I was on my way to our town’s food pantry and I went home real fast and changed so I wouldn’t be way more dressed up than the clients. No one who volunteers there dresses up — they’re working hard and lifting and stocking things, it would be ridiculous to do so — and I didn’t want to stand out. I was stopping by to drop off a flier on the way to another meeting and I had to make a decision: do I dress for the meeting or do I dress for the food pantry? I decided on the latter. I don’t EVER feel self-conscious or wrong for being over-dressed in a situation except for when my attire might make someone else feel self-conscious.
So this got me thinking about things like why I don’t rake the leaves in my front yard (I live in the parsonage and a yard crew gets to it eventually) or fix the dent and white paint scratch on my car or keep the garage door closed at all times to hide my garbage cans and recycling: because I have zero time for yardwork (just keeping myself fed and the house decent takes enough time and energy), and because I don’t want to fall prey to the unconscious notion that we will all be saved by cosmetic perfection in our communities. Yes, I am a person with garbage cans in my garage. My car works fine with a dent and a white paint scratch where I backed it out of my friend’s garage and scraped the side. It would cost $400 to have those things fixed and I intend to drive this car until it dies, so why bother? I do think it’s important to keep my vehicle relatively neat and clean (a losing battle, as I seem to constantly be loading it with piles of clothes and groceries to deliver somewhere), but I want to represent for the imperfect, for the Realistic, for the fair expectations.
Like, did you know that in thousands of communities in the U.S. it is actually ILLEGAL to hang out your laundry to dry? This is the kind of thing I mean, taken to an insane extreme: dryers use tons of energy and the sun is free and green. The Earth is rapidly warming and we’re worried about our property values?
Again, this doesn’t mean that I advocate you wearing Crocs or putting less effort into being a polished representative of the vibrant Church of today, it just means that there are occasions upon which you may choose to intentionally dress very casually as a way of standing for God’s alternative values. The key is that your choice be intentional.
This is just random musings, but for me they all seem to connect.
And now I’m off to dissertate. The end is near, my friends… I’m on the last chapter!
Blessings on your week.

Good luck with the dissertating!
Many years ago, my mom went to Bible study at our (small-town) church, and was happy to see a neighbor woman there. Later on, the neighbor confided that the only reason she kept coming back to the Bible study was that my mom was the only other woman there not wearing heels, a dress, full makeup and manicure, and nice jewelry. My parents were financially comfortable; the neighbor lived quite modestly. But my mom’s willingness to be casual and to dress below her means opened the door for another person to come and participate in an important religious practice. My mother’s ability to remember her own childhood poverty and to disregard wealth and social status in her everyday living has been a tremendous blessing and model to me (and for the record, she always looks tidy and well-groomed and appropriate, and she has a great eye for color and style. But she doesn’t confuse that with being fancy or expensively dressed.)
[That is a GREAT story. Thanks for sharing. – PB]
I needed to read this today. Thank you.
This sort of thoughtful prose, our beloved PeaceBang, is what brings me back to your site over and over, and what instills complete confidence that your dissertating is brilliant.
I live in a small, isolated (no roads in or out!) town and I missed the sign that apparently reads, “Move here, and you may no longer wear clothing made for a woman.” I love fashion–shoes, most of all–and also love who I am on greasy-hair, hiking-gear days.
And my struggle to be an “ambassador for LoveIncarnate” falls neatly into the category of “simple enough to teach our children; difficult enough to be worthy of our lives.” So…I pass along a near-quote from Reinhold Niebuhr’s Leaves from the Notebook of a Tamed Cynic:
Oh, my HTML skills failed me in the post above.
Here is the quote I intended:
When I run my once a month young family ministry I try to wear jeans or a jeans skirt for this reason plus it’s easier to carry stuff around like this.
I agree with this, but I know way too many people who may dress casually but have a really holier than thou (ie more progressive than thou) attitude about it, like, “screw your convention, i will wear jeans and a jimmy buffett t shirt from 1980 to your meeting” I think the attitude is more significant than what a person is wearing (extremes aside).
Madge, BIG TIME. I can’t stand that, I can smell it a mile away, and I’ve put some real effort into calling it the bull**** it is on this blog. But it’s been a long time… maybe it’s time to call it out again!! ? – PB
Oh, Madge, absolutely. It can be really nasty in more progressive churches (in my experience); the liberal, holier-than-thou, appearances-are-superficial attitude, I-work-with-the-people attitude that makes me want to punch something.
PeaceBang, I come from a similarly wealthy suburban town (let’s just say it’s in the Lincoln-Sudbury-Concord-Carlisle set) that has this same problem. The longer I live away from home, the more I see how it influences the people living there, including (and most notably, to me) my own family. My parents got lucky during a decent housing market and stuck around to raise their kids. We were of the make-do type, but I can feel my mom’s insecurity about our status. We don’t have the matching BMWs or take vacations to the Caribbean; they didn’t buy me a new car when I turned 16 or Tiffany jewelry when I was 12. They are good, wonderful people who raised their children well, and the Suburban Materialistic Complex has eroded her feelings of self-worth. Cruel, and horrible.
Oh, Peacebang. The sun is not green. The sun is YELLOW.
*shakes head sadly*
[STILL HIGH ON CANDY CORNS!! WHEEE!!]
I’ll admit these sorts of decisions about the precise attire drive me to the collar! Black slacks, black shirt, white collar—so utterly simple. Suit coat for meeting, off with the coat and roll up the sleeves for the food pantry. God bless those in ministry who have been given the spiritual gifts of fashion and discernment, like the beloved Peacebang, but I thank God for being in a denomination where making no fashion choice at all is accepted!