Hey, PeaceBang!
I am so hoping that you can help with my somewhat bizarre question/plea for help.
I’ve just read all of your maternity things, and I found the comments about what to wear during the week incredibly helpful.
However, one question still remains–what about Sundays? Specifically, if I am assisting (as I do quite regularly), should I tie ABOVE, BELOW, or THROUGH the belly? This past Sunday I went BELOW the belly and wasn’t quite smitten with it. I felt more like a dude with a beer gut, to be honest. But ABOVE might just look like extra support for my chest.
Please help!
Thanks so much, I really appreciate it.
Hi Mommy-to-be!
Well, I’m thinking about Friar Tuck, our big bellied friend from medieval lore. He always tied his cincture around his belly. I would recommend that you do so for as long as you can into the pregnancy and then tie it below and let that baby be seen! To tie it above the tummy would create a kind of bizarre empire waist that features the bazooms, and to tie to tie the belt ON the round tum at that late point just won’t work (I don’t think — Reverend Mamas, am I right or wrong on that?).
I’m afraid you will, soon enough in your body’s history, have more in common with a dude with a beer gut than you’d prefer to have. But think of the wonderful outcome!


Can you just skip the cincture altogether? In my tradition, most of us wear albs, and many people omit the cinctures just because they feel like it. You would have much more reason!
I, too, vote for skipping the cincture if you can. One of my favorite things about my alb (even now that I’m not pregnant) is that it’s designed to be worn without the cincture. But my internship supervisor wore a more traditional alb and never used a cincture.
I don’t use a cincture as it makes me look like a sausage – I vote for skipping it.
Pregnant lady, here:)
We’re required to wear a cincture in my tradition (boo hiss), so unfortunately I can’t just skip it:(
Thanks for your help, Vicki! I might just have to send pictures of both options to help others in my…joyful predicament.
I have an a-line alb (Almy makes a nice one with a more traditional high neck now) and it got me through nicely.
We were taught to tie it straight across, but I think that pregnant people were not really taken into consideration with that rule. The cincture is not kind to the postpartum figure, but if you can’t skip it (and I personally think no cincture on a traditional cassock alb looks a littld disheveled), avoiding the double lasso rope trick and simply doubling it and doing a simple knot is much more flattering wherever it hits. Only tall thin guys and with women with tiny waists look good with the funky double loop cincture.
If you don’t use the funky double loop, how do you keep your stole under control?
I vote for no cincture. It can’t possibly be required–it’s not in Scripture or tradition, and certainly not reason.
do the doubled cincture with a simple sliding knot, then just tuck the stole underneath. I think it works better than the other one.
In both my pregnancies, the cincture went into storage for the duration at about 4 months. Both the congregation and I were more comfortable that way! Yes, my stole slid off to the sides, but if anyone even thought about it, it probably was not beyond the obvious “she’s pregnant”! On the bright side of things, a chasuble is perfectly designed for a pregnant woman, for those of us in traditions that wear them 🙂
The minister in my church was pregnant several years ago and all I remember is how glad I was to see her expanding body in clerical garb each week — it was a wonderful reminder that women have finally been allowed to be ordained and to preach. Wear it as it’s most comfortable and don’t worry so much about how it looks. I guarantee you that someone in your parish will think you’re beautiful no matter what.
Noooooooo!!!!! Please do not tell me that tucking in the stole to a cincture is now fashionable. I find it ridiculous. I’m definitely not a fashionista (though PB has helped me step up my game, thanks!), but I just can’t do it even if it comes from the Goddess’ own mouth. Please tell me, at least, the reason behind this.
[Well, I’ve seen it done as a stole flap management technique, like during baptisms and other sacraments. I don’t think it’s about anything but keeping the stole from flying around or falling off. Anyone? Anyone? I do it at outdoor weddings, too, when I wear an alb. – PB]
I skipped the cincture thru 2 pregnancies as a full time pastor (Lutheran). I also skipped the collar by month 4 or 5, and still didn’t fit into those shirts while breastfeeding, so I went collarless until the kids were weaned. Truly, the only person who even noticed was me.
I’m not a minister, but during my pregnancy, I found it much more comfortable to tie the belt of my bathrobe above my belly. 😉
The well-regarded RC and Lutheran and Episcopal liturgical guides we studied in seminary recommended going cincture-less, and more and more Episcopal/Anglican clergy are doing just that. Is it really “required” in your tradition?
I wouldn’t say “required,” but instead would say “strongly suggested.” Keeping in mind that I’m not ordained yet (and have yet to begin the process), I’m probably being a little too strict with myself:)
I’ll definitely try cincture-free this Sunday and see what, if anything, is said. Then again, I also like the idea of mixing it up throughout–although I think if only I could rock a chasuble my problems would be solved! Someday, just not today:)
Thanks for all of your help, y’all! I so appreciate it!
Liturgy geek, where did you go to seminary? At Sewanee, where we learned the Sewanee way, vs. the wrong way, we always did the double loop. And learned that a surplice over cassock must be 4 inches from the floor. Not that Jesus cares a whit.
Yeah – the stole flap management is tricky.
I’ve done the double loops to stick the stole in, I’ve done the cincture over top of the stole too.
In the Lutheran church i see it done every which way, and everyone has “the way” that they do it…
Last year, I forgot a stole while doing a service someplace else, and just went without. THought it would be weird but I love it. Yes, my stole flaps a bit, but I think it looks more polished IMHO than the weird poofy-ness I was getting with the stole around my waist, which made my hips and my boobs look huge….
Where else in the blogosphere can you find such a spirited discussion of where to tie your cincture to minimize both your belly discomfort and boobage enhancement?
Only with Auntie PeaceBang, kittens. Only here.
I’m not a minister but have been through three pregnancies. I think the best place to put the cincture would be above the belly; if she puts it in the middle it will just emphasize things and probably slide off into the floor.
The usual pregnancy look is to belt above the baby. Empire location. Once a woman is showing, it won’t emphasize the bazooms. Not sure why, maybe just because that’s a natural look for pregnant women. Belting below would create a lot of bunched fabric, and a weird hem uplift.
We were taught (and an Episcopal seminary) that all knot tricks are totally local custom, and any mythology around what is “right” is, well, just that. Of course it may make sense to follow the local custom and I wouldn’t go telling your boss or colleagues that they are somehow wrong for doing it all one way 😉
Having a stole flapping about while celebrating is just distracting, unless you have one of the a line albs that doesn’t employ a cincture (mine has a collar that sort of holds the stole in place).
I think above the baby looks cuter, but it doesn’t help with the stole. Maternity clothes are gathered in that spot.
Sarah G., I did not go to Sewanee, but to one of those liberal seminaries on the West Coast (Pacific School of Religion). I know a few Sewanee grads, though….My only beef is the stole under the cincture thing. I’m not even sure if I do a funky double loop or what.
Oh, and needless to say, we did not learn the “correct” way to tie a cincture at PSR. “Correct way” – hahahahaha!
Since the neckline on an alb is incredibly conservative, unless you are a DD (which I realize, you very well might be) I wouldn’t worry about tying above the belly making your boobs distracting for parishioners. If it does, well, your motherhood is going to cause them problems anyway. I was incredibly fortunate, and a clergy mom I knew gave me a maternity robe she’d had made 15 years ago. It had a belt that was sewn into the sides and tied to back, and had a lovely little dart/pleat thing in the front (at about empire waist height) that allowed the robe to expand with my big (and I mean BIG) belly. I am unordained, so I wore it without a stole, but felt really great in it. I searched far and wide to find them commercially, but, never did. I’d love to see a women’s clerical company come out with a line of maternity/nursing wear for us.
I was pregnant with twins and was carrying high to boot, so there was no comfortable way to tie the cincture either above or on my belly. So I tied it below for awhile and then eventually did without. And I have to say, my alb was amazingly expansive! I wore it right to the very end, when I was measuring at 52 weeks, and it just kept accommodating me. Much better than most maternity clothes, which don’t tend to be designed for women carrying multiples.
I am loving the fact that we are having this conversation! When my belly outgrew the Women Spirit darted alb sans cincture a month and a half ago, I sadly moved to the more traditional cassock alb. After trying the cincture in many possible permutations came to agree with many of those above; lose the cincture. It’s not worth it. It’s not flattering and not comfortable and you’ll have to adjust it frequently.
If people hold the loss of the cincture against you, that’s their problem. Most people give pregnant clergy whatever leeway they need.
So far I’ve received much grace to wear what I need to wear. The collar has been gone for months and I suspect wont reappear for a while. No one seems to care. The pregnancy itself has over shadowed all sartorial decisions.
I’m 35 weeks pregnant and have been cincture-less for the past few months. The cincture is far more distracting than necessary when it comes to pregnancy, in my opinion.
I was not yet ordained when I was pregnant, but I worked at an Episcopal church as a youth minister and did assist at worship fairly frequently, in a cincture and an alb. I carried fairly small and I seem to recall that I could tie the cincture just fine until the end (8.5 months), maybe a little higher than its usual location, but not much. I would definitely migrate up rather than down – I don’t know how guys with bellies keep their cinctures up when they tie them under the belly, to be honest.
I will say, my Almy cassock-alb has always hung kinda funny and it never fit better than when I was hugely pregnant!