How About a Simple “Hello?”

I received this the other day and ignored it because something about it really irritated me:

5’2, eyes of blue, slim 50 y.o. (but look younger). Very important early morning interview coming up in [New England] at end of September … so could be coolish weather. I’m equally comfortable in professional slacks or skirt when I’m in the pulpit, but for this interview, I’m not sure which way to go. Does it matter? What are the considerations?

I get letters from readers just about every day, and I answer as many as I can immediately. You’re real colleagues and you have real questions, and you write me hilarious, thoughtful and respectful notes asking for my advice. We have a relationship. You say hello. You write, “Dear PeaceBang.”

After a second and then a third reading, I realized what was upsetting me about this last note: it was written without any greeting, any acknowledgement of my humanity, any “please” or “thank you” or even a To Whom It May Concern. It made me feel as though Beauty Tips For Ministers is some anonymous service provided by — I don’t know what, your tax dollars at work? — and that it’s okay to drop a query in my lap in the cold expectation that I’m supposed to answer your question.

And that’s not how it works. That’s not how it works here or anywhere else in the world. If you want a relationship with people — even someone you’ve never met — and you want their help, you say hello to them. You explain who you are. You make a connection. You do not assume that the world is sitting around thinking about you and your big, important job interview. You exchange a simple greeting, for God’s sake. You say, “I appreciate your time” or “I welcome any help you can give.”

Don’t ever be too busy or self-important for basic courtesy, cookies. Breezing into any room or into someone’s e-mail inbox and failing to even greet them before you launch into your demands is going to make much more of an impression (and a bad one) than whether you wear pants or skirts. If you’re rude, frankly, no one cares what you’re wearing.

[THIS JUST IN: The letter-writer wrote me a lovely note of apology in response to my note to her of this morning, making a personal connection, and recognizing that she just didn’t really know the etiquette of writing in, who would receive her query, etc. I’m so glad to hear from her, and even more grateful that her letter gave me an opportunity to remind my readers that HELLO, IT’S JUST ME OVER HERE. There’s no staff, there’s no office, there’s no one but Victoria Weinstein, busy full-time minister, single woman with a dog and a cat, trying to care for all of you by my lonesome and writing this blog on sheer love fumes. – PB]

26 Replies to “How About a Simple “Hello?””

  1. Dear Generous Lady Peace Bang,

    Thank you for reminding people of this. Basic courtesies. Even if someone IS providing a general service, ‘please’, ‘thank you’, ‘hello’, are basic courtesies.

    I almost automatically say ‘thank you’ to my bus drivers every day. They say ‘that’s all right!’. It may be all right, but getting me to my destination safely and on time is something that deserves my thanks. So, genuine interaction with people you’re asking to go ‘above and beyond’ their duties (and this is not one of your regular ministerial duties!) deserves some human touch.

    With warmest good wishes,
    Wendy

  2. Amen! I love this post, Peacebang. I too had to read it a second or third time – “What’s that nagging feeling?” – and when you explained the context I understood immediately! No “Hi, Peacebang…thanks for your time,” no human connection. I’m really glad you’re calling us readers on this type of thoughtlessness, and I LOVE your last line: “If you’re rude, frankly, no one cares what you’re wearing.” BOOM. There’s nothing like powerfully stated truth.

  3. Good morning PB — I also found this note disconcerting. Aside from the abruptness of it, the first sentence is very offensive. It sounds like an add in a singles column. One can only imagine how she’ll greet the interview committee.

  4. Good morning, dear elegance!
    I agree that this note is off-putting. It starts out like a singles ad and ends like a less ditsy Bertie talking to Jeeves. Hopefully this is a momentary blip in manners for the note-writer.

  5. Dear Peacebang:

    You certainly got your knickers in a twist here. You write that you ignored the message yet you posted it in its entirety. In general there is a three step process for proessing grievances, outlined in Matthew 18:15-17. What you have done is taken step three first, alienating a professional colleague and casting doubt as to your own professionalism.

    Don’t we all have the tendency to fail to see the beam in our eye while attempting to remove the slivers from other folks eyes?
    respectfully, Mick

    [Hi Mick. This blog is not a church. It is not a community of people doing the work together. It is ME doing the work totally alone, without a dime of pay, and as a volunteer ministry. I wrote to the offender (which is none of your business and which you assumed I did not do — so aren’t you busted, friend?) and told her how I felt about her rude approach. That’s all I’m accountable for. Once again, children, and sing it with me if you know it, RELIGIOUS LEADERSHIP DOES NOT REQUIRE GETTING WALKED ALL OVER. Speak up. Stand up, and thereby avoid becoming a simmering mass of resentment and repression. Mick, really… were you trolling this blog just looking for an opportunity to dispense clichés or were you in search of a conversation about image and ministry? I invite you to Bible-thump elsewhere. – PB]

  6. I, too, was more put-off by the opening sentence than the lack of manners (although that is disturbing, as well). Who cares about her eye-color or youthful skin? Is she wearing her pants/skirt on her head?

  7. You stated that you ignored her post. Now you state you wrote to her and it is none of my business. I suppose it is not the business of those who read your blog either. I comment quite frequently on UU blogs as I consider the UU faith to be my own. I have been UU since 1992. There are plenty of Bible thumpers who consider the UU faith as their own, and most of us try to be somewhat judicious in how much Bible thumping we do as many have been turned off by more conservative views of scripture. [Mick. Read more carefully. I said that I “at first” ignored her post because I was irritated by it. I’m glad you’re a UU, but the point is that dispensing beginner gospel advice to a legitimately ticked off blogger is not a really constructive way to participate in the conversation. At least it wasn’t in my eyes. I do want to make another point about your sense of what constitutes professionalism within the blogosphere: please consider that when I hold up a clergy person as an example without identifying anything about their location, their affiliation, or their faith tradition, I am not violating their privacy in any way, or subjecting them to personal ridicule. As with any other advice columnist, we use letters as fodder for reflections, and every letter that comes to us is publishable (although I always ask if I’m going to use a name or identifying details). Some letter writers get thumped, just as they do in advice columns, all anonymously. Much as a pastor might use an example of misbehavior from another congregation in his or her sermon to illustrate a point, so do I use certain letters or other items in the same way — again, without identifying the individual. This is an on-line community and we treasure it, but it’s not a church. Matthean formulas of church conduct do apply, but not strictly. This is a hybrid ministry/advice column/online salon/blog-o-munity. – PB]

  8. Thanks Peacebang:

    Perhaps five foot two eyes of blue will offer an apology for slighting you. I suppose if she reads your blog that would be the only reasonable thing to do. I am sure many of your readers are curious how this ultimately plays out. I certainly am although I will have to admit that I was somewhat partial to her side on this. Some think top posting on e-mails is poor etiquette but others think it isjust fine. This whole exchange brings to mind A WORLD WAITING TO BE BORN
    respectfully, Mickbic

  9. Hi Mick, The writer of the letter and I have been e-mailing back and forth and are consulting on her clothes for her big day. In the end, I am there for hundreds of readers. Don’t be so quick on the draw, for you could end up being the straw that breaks the solo volunteer’s back and ruin it for a lot of other people.

  10. Today after work, I stopped at the convenience store. As I was waiting in line, I recognized the man behind me. He was the police officer that was first on the scene of an accident I had almost 4 years ago. I introduced myself and told him ‘thank you’ for all he did for me that day. (He held my head still for nearly 45 minutes and kept me calm while we waited for EMTs, firemen and the jaws of life. I was pinned, upside down, covered in glass and blood, and it was a COLD December day.) His reply? A blush and a”Just doing my job” I told him he did his job well, and I was grateful.Then he winked and said “Just don’t do it again”

  11. @ PB, I think your responses to Mick are incredibly mature, professional, and compassionate… in a word, you’re being magnanimous. This comes just after your after posting on not making oneself a martyr for everyone’s cause. Similarly, you’re not not obliged to feed the trolls. This troll is being incredibly disrespectful of you as a minister in his/her/zer faith tradition. You have a position of spiritual authority and are being rebuked as if you were a neophyte. I just wanted to remind you that you have no obligation to tolerate this kind of thing on your blog.

    This is your chunk of cyber space, and you’re in charge. The internet is full of all kinds of swill and you don’t have to humor anyone who’s violating common decency… they can find other places to take out their negative feelings.

    I know your choices are your own, and I have great respect for how you handled Mick. I just want you to know that you don’t have to deal with people like that, especially in the very public blogosphere. This is your blog and your choice.

  12. Peacebang, I hope you will forgive this brief aside. I wrote to you asking for wedding beauty advice about three and a half years ago. I was so excited when you wrote me a thoughtful, funny post in reply. (I took all of your advice!) I know how much time and energy you pour into this as a solo volunteer, and I want say thank you, both for your response to me and for everything you do.

  13. Unfortunately with emailing, texting, IMing, chatting we are going to see more and more of this. There is a lost art of good old fashion letter writing.

  14. My dear PeaceBang,

    Know that you are appreciated beyond mere words by this new clergyperson and all the others who have been faithful readers of this wonderful blog!

    I’m a old-fashioned person of words, a letter-writer, a writer in general. However, given the popularity of short text bursts today (say Twitter or text messaging) I can see how the things of courtesy are dropped. Younger people may not even be aware that they are doing so, and I can understand it from that viewpoint.

    I’m not excusing this though, not by any means. I think knowing the common courtesies can take a person a long, long way from the get-go. One of my planned ministries is to talk with kids formerly living on the street but now clean, and teach them what to do when they finally go for job interviews. “Please”, “thank you”, how to write a thank-you note, how to write a letter (even if in email) — one thing I point out is that the person hiring them will most likely be older and expect certain courtesies.

    That being said, I believe everyone deserves the courtesies. Including you, dear PeaceBang. You (and the courtesies) make the world a better place!

  15. Dear Peacebang:

    Thank you for your wit, wisdom and strength.

    You are a model as a ministering colleague – albeit from “the country next door”. Whenever I read your site, you remind me of what is really important, both in life and in ministery.

    Beauty Tips for Ministers is about every so much more than which mascara to use. It is about remembering what is important in life.

    Marni from Canada

  16. I am SO glad to see this post. Not glad that you got a somewhat grace-less request for help, but glad that you’ve gotten the opportunity to remind all of us that 1) our ordination services didn’t include a solemn vow to accept unacceptable treatment, and 2) we don’t have to pretend like our ministry, our work, our efforts are running purely on Holy Spirit juice and cost us nothing in terms of our own time and energy. I’m so sick of hearing clergy (myself and others) reflexively behave as if our work “was nothing”, as if it took no time, etc etc.

  17. I’ve been seeking a new call for over two years, not the first time I’ve been through that wilderness. I cannot count on my fingers and toes how many times I have e-mailed sent requested information–resume, answers to questionnaires, etc., and received NO confirmation whatsoever. How long does it take to type “Thanks!” and hit the reply button? If I send a follow-up e-mail, the response is usually defensive. I won’t even go into search processes I never hear from again, ever. Such rudeness hardly makes one more inclined to seek a particular call. [Very true, Miss Sarah, and it can get bloody discouraging to send our materials out into what seems to be an uncaring wilderness. However, if it helps to remember, do remember that many search committees are comprised of volunteer laypeople who meet sporadically, feel overwhelmed and just don’t have an organizational system set up to reply to e-mails and such in a steady fashion. Good luck and chin up! – PB]

  18. PB, I am curious what type of interview would require a different attire from the one normally worn in the pulpit on Sunday morning. Would your consultee be willing to share?

  19. In response to Sarah G and PB, I absolutely get that search committees are made up of volunteers. However, this could be a great place for transition officers to give committees a bit of extra training. I.e., ‘As you search, designate a secretary or decide upon a system for responding to each and every message from candidates. A “no thank you” is as important as a “yes, please”.’

    In recent searches I’ve been in, I had two searches in which a “shepherd” was assigned to me as my point of contact (each committee member was shepherding two or three candidates). This spread out the load and made me feel so good about those churches. A church that wants to hire a superlative candidate does well to offer superlative care in the hiring process.

    Ah, ministry. LIke all relationships, it’s a two way street.

  20. Peacebang:

    Sorry our exchanges here were a little rough. Sometimes there is heat as well as light. A poster named Carolyn wrote yesterday that I was disrespectful of you and seemed to imply that I was a troll. I don’t even know why anyone would want to be a troll and cannot identify with that motif. I was able to calm down a bit after you described the perspectives of the woman who prompted your original post.

    If you accept financial donations for this labor of love (your blog) I will be more than happy to give you occasional financial support. I will delve further into that.
    Peace, Mick (Mickbic)

    [Hi Mick – A troll is an internet term for someone who “trolls” sites looking for trouble or taking conversations off-topic, or just hammering away at one point obsessively and stirring up negativity. If you ever want to drop a tip in the jar, go to the Support this Blog button and you can contribute by PayPal. Lord knows I appreciate the few contributions I get! But I know this is a clergy readership, I ain’t doing it for the money! – PB]

  21. Peacebang:

    I looked up the word troll just prior to my most recent posting. I wrote the definition down in my notebook at the same time: “someone who writes inflammatory articles on an Internet board.” Obviously there may be something I have posted that could possibly be deemed inflammatory. I do regret that and wish I had posted to you privately instead. That seems to be part of the beauty of the three step process outlined in Matthew’s Gospel for processing grievances.

    I was complimented this year in a letter for a sermon I did in 1982 or 1983. While no longer in formal ministry, I do feel strongly still about the if-you-love-me-feed my-sheep ethos from the gospel of John that spoke to me deeply in 1981.

    As you may note from my most recent blog entry, it was about the juxtaposition of “the good” and “the right perfume” which perhaps would appeal to women in the ministry.

Comments are closed.