Don’t Wear the Seasons Literally

The fastest train to Frumpsville, my dears, is to dress too literally for the seasons:

Don’t you dare.

If you’re a cozy country parson and you want to wear this sort of thing to the office, I suppose I can’t stop you (although I’d like to if you’re under 75). I know a lot of lovely women wear this sort of garment but you really, really should not if you have any aspirations at all to elegance or sophistication. You may say, “But it’s CUTE for low-key days!” Yes, okay, but listen up: when you see yourself in the mirror in this kind of look, it acclimates you to that look. It makes you feel super dressed-up when you wear, for instance, a classic, structured jacket, and makes it harder to get dressed professionally and feel like yourself.

Anything that someone could spot on you a block away and say, “IT MUST BE (fill in the blank with season/holiday of your choice)” is not polished. It’s frumpy. Sorry; had to be said!

15 Replies to “Don’t Wear the Seasons Literally”

  1. I agree! IMO, there is nothing wrong with wearing, say, a PLAIN brown wool sweater with a pumpkin-colored scarf in the fall…but just say no to applique, people.

  2. No, I wouldn’t wear those. But I did have a very lovely camel corduroy blazer that was embroidered with the most gorgeously subtle leaves in a green, gold and peach (you had to be standing almost next to me to see it). I wore it out.

    I can also see a sort of ‘water-coloury’ leaf print in a silk blouse or skirt as something appropriate and attractive.

  3. I once found myself considering a sweater like the second one… Then I remembered the promise I made to my dear friends when I was ordained – “to never lose my sense of style”. I slowly stepped away from the sweater, gave my head a good shake, and kept on walking.

  4. I used to teach in a conservative parochial school in the midwest and accumulated a number of themed sweater-embroidered mock turtleneck-matching skirt ensembles. Throw that on with a pair of Clarks clogs in a complimentary color and I was good to go. This was consistent with what the other female teachers wore. The sick part was that I was in my early twenties.

    A good friend met me for breakfast before work one day and, thank heavens, had the good sense to tell me I looked ridiculous. Fortunately I’ve long since given up on the “3-D sweater” phase of my fashion life.

    I appreciate you waving others off of this terrible but enduring trend. It starts with just one or two such outfits, and like the gateway bad fashion that it is, it soon consumes your whole closet.

  5. Can we just say the same goes for animals/teddy bears/inserted lace/”grandma” sweatshirts? A decorated sweatshirt is still a sweatshirt and has no place in the office.

    Gads, PB, what would we do without you?

  6. Warning against these sweaters is a public service!

    About the time I turned 40, I seemed to start noticing a whole lot of clothing with cartoon characters embossed or embroidered on it in various cheap and ugly ways.

    It depressed me profoundly. I realized this was the designated “grandma” wear. But if someone is old enough to actually BE a grandma, that person is likely to have had deep, interesting life experiences.

    How dismal that the apparent fate of such people is to be buried alive in the Disney World version of prison uniforms.

    Just step away from the puppies, daisies, cartoon characters, bumblebees, pumpkins, snowmen, Christmas trees, et al. Really. None of us could have possibly lived a life stupid enough to deserve them. [What a great quote! – PB]

  7. I was wearing that cardigan when I met my husband. It wasn’t cool in 1998 on a 28 yo and it isn’t cool on me now that I’m forty. I do have a halloween sweater that I wear ON THE DAY OF HALLOWEEN, and I have a Noah’s ark vest that I thought would be cool for a priest to have but I’ve never worn it.

    I just got a green sweater set because all the moms at at school wear holiday sweaters when the come for the school events and I sort of feel ba-humbug-y if I don’t do something to mark the day from a clothing perspective. [Get a festive rhinestone pin! Not a tacky big colored one but a pretty snowflake one! Wear a red headband and put the pin on it! Wear a silver-sequined tank top under a black blazer! There are so many ways to be festive without being frumpy! – PB]

  8. I don’t understand why people would spend money on this stuff – 11 months of the year it will just sit in the closet. Why spend $20, $30, or $50 on a sweater you can only wear once or twice a year? Why waste closet space?

  9. Festive without frumpy–of course! What on earth do you think God invented velvet for? 🙂

    Last year, I found a simple white wool beret with a bit of diamante sprinkled across about a third of the top. Perfect for a bit of ‘holiday cheer’ without dressing up like Mrs. Santa.

  10. I attended an ordination last weekend, and the woman who preached the sermon wore one of these seasonal “festive” sweaters, except instead of autumn, it looked like a summery theme. Very distracting, especially since I kept giggling inside my head, thinking about your blog post.

  11. Oh dear, I just had to respond with a story.

    My mother and sister live in holiday-themed clothing. Mom is mid-60s, sister is 30, and they both teach elementary school. For years, Mom has been buying me clothing like this, which I return when she’s not around. I ardently refuse applique, in any way, shape or form.

    Then I got a sweater that is almost identical to the second one two years ago–as a Christmas gift from a 86 y/o church member who is one of our most active volunteers! First off, it make me incredibly uncomfortable to receive such a personal gift of clothing from a parishioner, (to think of her guessing my size, with my busty self!) Then I was horrified at the thought of having to wear it! But wear it I have–it is my go-to on office-only days, and also for some nursing home visits.

    I live in applique heaven, and I get huge compliments from the 75+ crowd every time I wear it. *shudder*

    Thank you for reminding me not to get comfortable in it. EVER. [You’re a good sport, and you know it was given in love. Wear it in good health! – PB]

  12. I totally agree, but one of my favorite holiday traditions is an “ugly sweater” party. Last year, a friend had one with lights and a small battery pack sewn in. Its great fun to get a bunch of people wearing awful sweaters together. I wouldn’t spend $20 on one though. This is why we have thrift stores and yard sales. And, a number of people took the sweaters off before they left, so as not to be seen in the general public wearing one.

Comments are closed.