Women’s Shoes That Never, Ever Belong In the Pulpit Or Presiding

This goes for you too, fellas! NO MERRELL Jungle Mocs!!

Nothing with big, rubbery wonky soles like these. A very cute shoe but not for church. If it was in black it might pass muster but in general this type of thing is way too sporty:

Nothing with mesh. Too sporty:

Be careful with this sort of basket-weave type thing, too. Too sporty and casual:

Please, don’t get cute and “creative.” These don’t belong anywhere near your ministerial setting:

These would be the PERFECT black flats except for the tire tread on the sole. What a bummer! I’d certainly wear this at church gatherings and to the office and meetings, but not in the pulpit, please:

13 Replies to “Women’s Shoes That Never, Ever Belong In the Pulpit Or Presiding”

  1. Please do share the name of the last pair. I can see those working as during-the-week pastoral shoes this fall.

    I’m still laughing about the Jungle Mocs.

  2. If you preached in Moose, Wyoming in the midst of a snow snow storm and a barely heated building – you would be right at home in the first pair – maybe black tho – not brown suede. See here

  3. Actually, that final pair is a VERY good pulpit/altar/liturgical black shoe here in the UK. Thousand year old church–weird ‘floors’ (sometimes still dirt). Slick or worn stone steps going up to the altar, often damp (which means slick) stones in aisles.

    The others, yes, I agree that they’re not usually appropriate, except as Ann points out, in Moose, WY. But it really does depend on your context.

  4. I’ve worn black jungle mocs in the pulpit, indeed everywhere, for years. They’re very comfortable when I am on my feet for hours, and well within my budget. No one worried about the stylishness of my shoes if the rest of my outfit worked in the context of the congregation. fwiw, there’s a smooth leather version of the jungle moc.

    I like your blog very much, but its very “city-oriented”. My first parish began to accept me the day I did a funeral wearing LLBean rubber boots — they decided I wasn’t a city girl at that point. I think it wise to dress well — for the context within which we minister, I don’t know that it’s all that smart to dress “dressier” than the best dressed person in the congregation, just as it’s not so bright to dress further down that most everyone in the congregation.

  5. You don’t think the skull and crossbones shoes would be perfect for presiding over an All Souls’ service? Aw!

  6. I’d love to see some comfy, appropriate examples, especially ones that would go with a calf-length Geneva gown.

  7. LOVE the skull and crossbones shoes. Where do I
    find ’em? They should be fine to wear if you
    work in data processing.

    [Sure! I got all of these shoes on Zappos.com “New” list for fall. Go ye and search. Those are called Emily by Pleaser USA. – PB]

  8. Looking at the last pair on the list reminds me again of how I’ve been kicking myself for buying the last pair of shoes I bought. You’d advised me on the one perfect pair of shoes for all pants and jeans, and while I was investigating them, my old pair split and I bought the first black pair that felt good on my feet. Still not happy, and now I have a pants suit someone gave me to go with my clericals and nothing much suitable to wear with it.

    Moral of the story: Follow PeaceBang’s advice sooner, rather than later.

    What is your thought, PeaceBang, about plain black leather shoes cut a little like those mocs, but squarer-toed and dressier, with clericals? Someone has given me a used pair, and they’re better than what I bought, anyway.

    BTW, in the pulpit I wear a habit, and habit shoes follow no rules known to ordinary style, so at least that’s one less thing to worry about. [You HEAR THAT, Pigeons? Oh, Sister Sarah, I’m sorry! I know the shoe thing is a big one for you, as you tend to wear that one pair faithfully — ha ha, no pun actually intended! – – and don’t like to have to own multiple pairs. So what happened? What did you wind up with? I think the shoes you describe sound good, and sort of remind me of a pair of super-practical, comfortable and well-made Naots that I got ten years ago after hurting my feet badly in an accident. Those have a rounded toe but cripes, they are terrific, solid shoes and would go really well with a habit. I’ll see if I can find a photo online. The thing about depending on used shoes to really work for you is that if they’re at all worn in, they really do take on the contours of their first owner’s feet. Not a big deal if they’re something you’re not relying on for everyday, but definitely a consideration if you are. – PB]

  9. LOL – Did you see Ty Burrell’s shoes that he wore to the Emmy’s with that weird gray tux? They were some tan leather jobs, bootlike. OMG!

  10. But Ty Burrell of “Modern Family” missed the mark with cognac colored oxfords and his gray tux. Men can never go wrong with polished black dress shoes. What’s worse is that Ty’s shoes looked like he had been wearing them with corduroys this past winter.

  11. I’ve taken Rev Gidget’s challenge (http://revruru.livejournal.com/109471.html) for two reasons:

    1. This advice is more or less what I was told when I was ordained 5 years ago. As I say in this post on my own blog, the challenge was that it was easier to envision the frumpy options that met those requirements than the cute, comfortable, stylish ones that spoke to who I was/am.

    2. I needed the procrastination. For various definitions of need.

Comments are closed.