Are you watching?
Did you see tonight’s team challenge?
It was PURE EVIL.
Team Military and Lace did a totally cute collection, but not before Casanova had a huge diva breakdown. I am totally Team Valerie. I love her, love her designs, love her look, her personality, etc.
Peach is funny and can laugh at herself and I’d love to hang out with her because she reminds me of the fun preppy gals I grew up with.
LOVE Mondo. He’s so quirky.
But that CREATURE Gretchen is just too despicable for words. LOATHING her. She and Ivy are horrible women and I want them to go AWAY as soon as possible.
Tim Gunn, who is to ADORE UNRESERVEDLY, became even more of a hero to me tonight for his passionate, spot-on, totally crisply articulated denunciation of the entire team for allowing Gretchen to manipulate and bully them. Well played, Monsieur Gunn. I mean, what a disgusting display of pack mentality: it took the judges about three minutes to turn these people into sewer rats. It was so disturbing.
I shan’t soon get over that or the shockingly ugly outfit Ivy devised.
Such fun!! *jumping up and down and clapping*

Oh, yes! I whooped so loud the whole neighborhood could hear.
I know her type–who “just want to help”–and what’s worst is they do not see themselves; they cannot see that they are manipulative, controlling, or bullying.
Well played Monsieur Gunn!
I have to not read these…I don’t get PR here, and my brother is saving them up on his DVR for me for when I visit at Christmas!
I wish that I knew Tim Gunn in real life. He is one of maybe three celebrities I feel this way about–it is a very strange transference sort of thing. I don’t know what it is, but I wish I could call him before I go shopping or get a haircut. A little embarrassing and childlike, actually ;). His combination of brutal honesty and ultimate decorum is just so appealing.
I loved Cassanova from the moment he made that truly horrible first outfit that he was sure was “not vulgar” Gretchen reminds me of those people who tell everyone how “sensative” they are and then run roughshod over everyone else’s feelings.
Sounds just like WWF – wrestling on TV – bad guys, good guys, funny guys, sinister guys, plots, etc. All for the drama.
I love Project Runway, and this season is very entertaining. I was holding out on hating Gretchen, who was clearly emerging as the season’s villain, because I thought maybe she wasn’t really so bad and it was just editing that was painting her that way. But this episode she was over the top, and it was so good of Tim to call her out on it and in front of everyone. I was stunned that some of the team didn’t turn on her when she was trashing the whole collection and Michael on the runway, and especially that Michael just took it. He has immunity, he’s been trashed by her, he needed to say, “Listen, judges, you need to know that this entire collection was Gretchen’s idea, that she functioned as team leader, that it was her aesthetic and vision the way we did things, and if it didn’t work, it’s her responsibility. Whether they felt like I was the weakest link or not, my pieces were some of the most successful, and Gretchen had her hands in many many pots, and made all of them boring and bland.” Instead, he just took the criticism and internalized it. That, more than anything, convinced me that Gretchen is a huge bully.
And, of course, after they all agreed not to throw anybody under the bus, they all trashed Michael, and Gretchen was the first to do, when she didn’t have to, and Ivy was the second.
At the end she said the judges called her out on things, and she accepts responsibility for those things. Let’s hope so.
I recognized a co-worker of mine in Gretchen last night. She has the best of intentions, but is clueless as to how her bossiness offends people. That cluelessness makes it much more difficult to change that behavior than with someone who is being deliberately mean. After all, she is “just trying to help”.
I am rooting for Valerie all the way. The way she handled and supported her team was awesome.
I did not get all the love for Peach’s dress, though. It was an eyesore.
I’m so happy to see this today. I had paused the show while my family got home and when I hit the button to resume, I thought I had missed a whole section. Then I realized, no, Gretchen did just turn on her team that quickly. And Tim Gunn. Oh, I just love him. Each week I tell my girls “I just want him around me all the time as a life coach.” He tells it like it is and he tells it with compassion and love and I adore him.
We were on media blackout til catching the recorded version on Saturday morning, and indeed this was a classic episode! The Meltdown! The Grampa Sweaters! The ‘retechin! And Tim’s slap down – all priceless! Almost as good as Tim’s recent snort laughing over the wooly balls!
Next wish? More Mondo!
Yes, yes, yes. I agree 100%. I can’t believe they sent home AJ over Ivy’s atrocity or Gretchen’s despicable behavior and horrible team leadership.
But, at least it’s shaping up to be an interesting season.
Hahaha! Oh, that Gretchen! I’ll stop there before my inner voice comes out to play on the message board.
ANYWAY… I do love Tim!