An upsetting letter came today:
I’ve gotten ordained, so that I can officiate at my sister’s wedding, next October. (Thank goodness I have plenty of time to help her out with stuff!) I’m hoping to get my wardrobe squared away ahead of time… I’ve gotten a black, short sleeved minister shirt… the kind with collar and tab… and I was wondering what in the heck I should wear it with? I am intrigued with the possibility of a suit… is that even do-able? Would it look ok, or ridiculous? Help!
My response:
Hi ___________,
If you’ve only gotten ordained so that you can officiate at your sister’s wedding next October, you have no business wearing a clergy shirt at all. A clergy shirt is not a costume, it is an outward symbol of the responsibilities of the ordained ministry — not just for one day, but forever.
I’m glad you asked!
***
Now, pigeons, I certainly hope that it was just a matter of wording but I don’t think so. Anyone who refers to clericals as “a minister shirt” is most likely not a minister and not in the process of becoming one. I commend this gal for writing to someone she thought could give her responsible advice about what to wear to her sister’s wedding. I’m sorry that she — or anyone else — is under the impression that a clerical collar should be worn by anyone other than ordained clergy or chaplains who are doing the ongoing work of ministry.
Wow. That’s a new one. *shakes head*
I guess the analogy would be if I went to take care of an ailing friend for the day and donned a white coat and stethescope.

I wonder if the person who wrote in has talked to her (?) sister about the intention of wearing a clergy collar, or if there’s just an assumption that this is what the sister wants? Clergy do a lot more than officiate at weddings.
[It’s just part of the confusion and degradation that comes to the office of clergy with these instant “ordinations.” I don’t know if that’s what the writer has done, but I think they’re a problem — not to mention an insult to religious traditions who have learned clergy. I am trying to think of another profession that tolerates imposters for the purpose of conferring authority for a special occasion — I mean, if I want to wear a policeman’s badge for a day for a specific purpose, should I be allowed to? I have no problem with people getting licensed to do a wedding. Pay a fee, get your license. There should be no faux ordination about it. – PB]
Wonder what denomination this person is.
I´d say it´s not the clothes that make a minister.
😉
I had an inquiry from a Unitarian Universalist congregation recently about ordaining their Director of Religious Education. The old familiar comment was made, “because under our polity we can ordain anyone we want.”
Even in the tradition of a learned ministry, with the harder-than-ever fellowship credentialing process, the idea of ordination as reward or recognition still pops up. We have educating to do.
I completely agree with your assessment of the situation and the apalling thought of someone wearing a “ministers shirt” who is not ordained. That being said, I wonder if there is advice you would give someone who is conducting the ceremony of marriage who is NOT ordained? For example, simple black slacks and coat? OR do you get funky with some nice accessories? Coordinate with the bride? [I would just keep it simple and classic, perhaps a suit. There’s no need to coordinate with the bride but you would definitely want to avoid clashing with the bride… neutrals are good! – PB]
As a non-ordained person who has officiated at a number of weddings (almost always with a one-day designation, a few times with another authorized person signing the license), I’ve never felt that my suit was somehow an inadequate uniform.
Thank you so much Peacebang! This is also one of my pet peeves. I had many people ask me on my internship last year where I got my clerics… and I was not afraid to tell them that only people who are on their way to being ordained (like those in seminary or internship) or who are ordained should be wearing them. Honestly! I love your response!
I’m going to be officiating at a wedding too this summer, and I might not be ordained yet. But even though I’ll have graduated from seminary I won’t be wearing a collar. My friend wants me to wear a dress which is like the bridesmaids dresses. Then I’ll probably wear an alb for the ceremony. Maybe this girl could do the same.
It ticks me off about these online ordinations too. Honestly, it’s so fake. Pastors spend 3-4 years in seminary and get intense training and education. It’s totally not the same as click and ordain.
Good job Peacebang!
As a third-year seminary student, I find this letter extremely insulting. Even though I have been serving a church as student pastor for almost a year now, I will not wear a collar until I have been ordained. I have worked very hard and will continue to do so to meet the requirements for ordination, and I am offended that anyone would think it is ok to play dress up in this way.
Our letter writer wrote a very sweet note to me saying, essentially, “whoops, I hadn’t thought of it that way and I’m sorry for any offense, but do you have any thoughts on what I *should* wear?” To which I responded thusly,
“When I did my sister’s wedding before I was ordained I wore a sage green suit (skirt and jacket) that was pretty and dressy but neutral enough to let her be the focus. I added blingier jewelry and accessories for the reception.
What you could do to sort of suggest a clergy/officiant role is to wear something fairly neutral but dressy and then find a beautiful scarf and drape it down front like a minister’s stole. You can ditch the scarf for the reception and add a big necklace or something more festive.”
Cheers to our officiant-to-be!
It’s nice that she cares to get the look right. Maybe this experience will encourage her to look into doing it the right way.
Oh, ugh. As a pre-seminarian (heh, that’d be someone who hopes to attend divinity school after she gets married next fall), I was very careful not to impersonate a minister when I married my college roommate this fall; I didn’t even want to mimic the stole, because that is such an important part of ministry. The plain suit I wore fit the bill perfectly, and I felt I gave the situation the authority and honor it deserves.
I’m also so, so conscious of how this online “ordination” could look if/when I seek fellowship. I don’t intend to marry anyone else between now and when I am (I hope) officially ordained, and if it had been in Massachusetts, I would have absolutely availed myself of the handy-dandy one-day marriage designation. I don’t consider myself a minister, by any stretch of the imagination, and hope that it can be seen as a single favor for a close friend, and not as a way of circumventing the system.
My longtime minister (who will be marrying myself and my fiance next fall) compared it to doctors– getting an online M.D. and performing heart surgery. I felt pretty similar, actually– I wasn’t trained for what I did, and though it felt amazing and my friends were happy with the ceremony, it wasn’t the work of a professional. But they wanted someone they cared for to perform it, and I was honored to do it, but I definitely don’t consider myself a minister.
Seriously, ‘judge not, lest ye be judged’.
I can see that you got to it eventually, but could you not answer the question before piling in wth the ‘holier than thou’ stuff.
Ministry isn’t a vocation to everyone – answer the question asked.
[I wouldn’t call that holier-than-thou. I would call it good and pissed off at someone impersonating a credentialed, ordained minister who isn’t even on the doorstep to beginning a PROCESS of becoming one, let alone already one. Also, try reading carefully. A careful reading of the exchange (rather than a defensive one) would have informed you that the “question asked” wasn’t “should I wear a clerical collar” but “WHAT should I wear with the clerical collar I have already purchased?” Hence ticked off clergy readers, and rightly so. By the way, ministry is by definition a vocation. What could you possibly be thinking? – PB]
Sarah K – I don’t think officiating a wedding is anything like performing heart surgery. A judge officiated my wedding, and a surgeon performed my daughter’s heart surgery. Both were major events in my life, but while any number of other non professionals could have officiated my wedding just as well as the Honorable Judge did (if not better), I wouldn’t have trusted even my dearest, wisest friends to slice into my daughter’s chest.
The minister who married me IS a minister and still wore a dressy suit, no clerical collar necessary.
CC
Interesting responses all, but it would be less of an issue if we completed the disestablishment of church and removed from all ministers the right to act as officers of the state when it comes to weddings.
Civil and religious marriage are two separate beasts, neither depends on the presence or validity of the other. But if we insist on treating ministers as state officials, then ministers should be held to the same standards in every respect. (E.g., regarding discriminating in decisions about whom they will perform this official function for…)
In other words, if people who aren’t actually ministers shouldn’t dress as ministers, (where such distinct trade uniform exists, with the exception, perhaps, of costume parties, where everything is free game because no impersonation is implied and a whole lot of irony frequently is), then we should equally hold that people who aren’t state officials shouldn’t “dress up” like state officials in order to perform legal functions.
[Thank you for addressing that whole issue, which I wanted to but was just too lazy to compose. – PB]
She did say the wedding was in October. Maybe it’s a costume deal. In which case, go all the way and dress up as the Pope!
To many who have replied:
Wow. Don’t you think you’re being a tad bit unkind to the writer? No need to get huffy and indignant over a question or idea. If so many of you are that knowledgeable about the subject, are you not knowledgeable regarding the act of kindness and teaching in a manner that is not so humiliating?
I am officiating a wedding this afternoon. I am an ordained priest. I will be wearing a clerical collar and skirt beneath my alb and stole. For weddings outside the Church (of which there are more and more invitations) I generally wear the same as I would in a Church, but not always.
The writer is asking advice, but to me, she’s making a rather large assumption and seems to want to play “dress up” which is NOT okay. Clergy have a difficult enough time as it is in today’s society, without folks wearing the “uniform” when it hasn’t been earned.
I am a ULC Minister. NO ONE is ordained “online”. You apply for ordination online and the actual ordiantion takes place by church officials at ULC Modesto several times a week. Should someone who becomes ordained just to marry their sister wear clericals? Probably not… You ULC ministry is what you make of it. It is a REAL ordination – and you can use it to do good things. Here is a ULC minister that has chosen to do good and raises money for cancer treatment selling crosses. He has earned the right to wear his clericals as he is performing the role he was ordained to do – ministering and actually doing good : http://www.aulc.us/
There is nothing wrong with an online church if it is spreading the word and doing good for others!
[I don’t think so. No training, no community of accountability. I don’t doubt that ULC church “ministers” think that their ordination is legit, real clergy do not agree. – PB]
Several denominations have tracks to ordination that do not involve seminary. They do, of course, require a specific course of study (often overseen by the licensing district).
There are also ministerial fellowships that provide credentialing. While there are several that are ordination mills, there are a few that take it seriously, require a certain level of education (and ongoing learning) and hold credentialed ministers accountable.
Bottom line, non-profit religious organizations can require any criteria they choose for ordination. MANY independent churches ordain without seminary requirements (including almost every independent baptist church I have ever stepped foot in)…MOST holiness denominations are very similar. No denomination has a patent on the clerical garb, and neither do they have the corner on ordination.
Okay I am curious NO I was not ordained by the seminary how I was ordained as a minister by Global Christian outreach ministries I agree the collar is not a costume its a holly thing, however, I feel I have made a commitment to the Father the son and the holy spirit yes the ordination was online but I believe everything my Lutheran minister father believes he wears the collar to me it is a sign of loyalty to the father in heaven is it wrong for me to dress holly I am a minister to me the collar is like a badge that a police officers carry I want to honor thy father in heaven, in fact, I like being called reverend I old fashioned I did not just get ordained to do weddings but to be able to baptize bless homes and preform all duties commanded by the triune God I did not go to seminary becasue of chronic health issues but I want to help other people who may be sick or dying and if somone asks for me to do a wedding I will do so as long as it is Christian if I do wear holy clothing while serving is that a sin please forgive me spelling and grammer I have a learning disibility