Hola, kids!! This is Erin. She’s a newbie in ministry, all of 26 years old and in a pastorate in Western PA. She has written to PeaceBang for a consultation and had said, “Yes! Let’s do this publicly!” She has obligingly and awesomely provided photos of herself in various outfits that she would wear doing regular pastoral things, so without further ado: HERE’S ERIN!!
Erin’s biggest irritation regarding her ministerial image is about … surprise… her youth. “Aren’t ya awful YOUNG to be a pastor laydee?” is something she hears all the time (although admittedly, she probably doesn’t hear it in that ridiculous caricature of a hillbilly accent. We’re just having some fun here). So we’re going to focus on some tips that might help Erin gain a bit more confidence and gain a bit more mature polish. Now, if you’re one of those softies who likes to come on this site and say, “I can’t believe that you OFFER YOUR OPINION TO YOUR READERS, PB! YOU’RE SOOOO MEAN! I THINK SHE’S ABSOLUTELY PERFECT IN EVERY WAY!! KUDOS FOR BEING SO BEAUTIFUL!” I just want to warn you in advance: I will be offering honest feedback to Erin. Because that’s what I do for people. I assume that they know I think they’re gorgeous, glowing stars in the religious leadership firmament (not my line, got it from a movie) and that it is BECAUSE I am a huge fan of their existence that I take the time to pay extra special individual attention to them. Okay? So here we go.
My overall impression of Erin is that she’s doing a fine job picking out some basics that work well for her, but that she would benefit from a more polished hair style, a bit more care in the fit of her garments, andf finally, finding a few signature pieces that help her have more of an individual presence. Right now what I see if serious, nice-looking young gal who looks a bit generic, and there’s no need for that. If Erin and I were together I’d ask her, “Erin, what kind of clothes do you LOVE? What colors make you psyched to get up in the morning? What kind of impression — beyond “appropriate” — do you want to make? What would you like your clothes to communicate about you?” And then we’d go to the store and try on whatever fascinating combos she felt like trying on — without worrying about the collar for a moment — and let her gravitate with natural enthusiasm for things way outside her comfort zone, just to see what was fun for her.
We might also sit down with a pile of magazines and let her go wild with scissors, clipping images of all kinds that she resonates with and would like to incorporate into her wardrobe. Images from nature, snips of color, architecture, art, movement. You and your ministry are a work of art. How can we fit a touch of that into your daily appearance?
That said, here is Erin dressed for a day at the office:

First, the good: Her outfit has excellent proportions, she’s dressed entirely appropriately, and she looks comfortable and neat.
Now, the suggestions: In order to look more sophisticated and professional, I would recommend a cut and color for our Miss Rev. Her hair would look lovely in a smoother style, and her ends need a trim and conditioning. A nice wash of color would even everything out, as there seems to be a grown-out color on her ends (or perhaps sun fading).
I’m not loving that sweater, as it’s just somewhat drab for a vibrant young pastor. Also note the weird lumpiness we get with the collared shirt under the fitted crewneck. The skirt is a terrific cut (perfect length and fit!) but the denim with gold stitching does look very youthful and super casual. My recommendation:
A v-necked cardigan in a royal blue or other vibrant color, worn with the collar shirt and a skinny belt around it (Erin has such a lovely waist! Why not feature it?).
This isn’t a V-neck, which would look better with the clericals, and the belt isn’t the classic I had in mind, but you get the idea. Cardigan by Express.
If you can find a skirt just like that in black or brown or blue jersey or wool or gabardine, Erin, you’ve got a winner.
Pantyhose: Glad you’re wearing them, think you could have more fun with them. Swap the ordinary nude for a pair of opaque black hose now and then for a much more sophisticated look.
Shoes – cute!
Erin looks like she’s wearing a cute pair of dangly earrings and very delicate bracelet and ring. Here’s where I recommend you really bust out as an individual, Erin: I don’t feel like you’re wearing those accessories because you LOVE them or because they represent anything to you but “I should put on some earrings.” If you want to up the maturity ante, look for signature pieces that you JUST LOVE — interesting and bold accessories that you can add to the more delicate pieces to make a stronger visual statement.
I look terrible in bracelets (tiny, child-size hands and short arms but wow, what a stunning piece!)
Here’s Erin in her Graveside Presiding Outfit:

Very serviceable. Just needs a bit of detail attention: I would brush the hair back in a low chignon, put on a brighter lipstick (when we’re presiding, we don’t want our faces to get lost, and Erin’s face can get a bit lost behind her glasses). Erin, the coat is terrific but it looks like it’s a size or so too big for you in the bottom. Is it? Since that’s such an excellent and classic piece, I think it would be worth it to take it to a tailor if there’s as much excess material there as it looks like there might be. A pair of nice black leather gloves and button-type earrings and you’re all set here. May they rest in peace.

I will only reluctantly second the hairstyle- I recently cut my always-long hair. After a GRUELING round of family illness, residency, grad school part two, and more illness, I lost some hair to stress. As things evened out, my hair was growing back in freakish spurts of broken frizz. I finally cut it off into a bob while it all regrew into one length, but I discovered such a side effect. People complimented me for about four months on the hair cut, and stopped asking if I was tired, needed makeup, or was afraid of them. So I’ll keep it like this for a while.
But if you love that hair long and it’s healthy, don’t cut it if it’s YOU!
I really love the fashion advices although I don´t wear a collar.
BUT- I can´t support the green skirt and jumper.
It makes the young, energetic looking Erin look 20 years older.
It´s not only the cut of the jumper (Yes, a cardigan and a belt would make a huge difference) but also the colour and the shape of the skirt.
To me it is the outfit that carries the message “hi- I´m a young pastor but don´t know my role yet”
I love the other outfits but not this one.
Are dark jeans an absolute no-go in the US? If not I´d go for an office day for some dark jeans, a bright coloured cardigan and maybe some matching shoes. [I wear dark denim slightly flared jeans almost every day to the office. Most clergygals don’t get it. They need to either be DARK or have a discernible style –not just Levis or generic GAP — to be really work-appropriate. – PB]
My hair has very good days and bad days. It was straight and thick when I was growing up, and about puberty it turned very curly. Now, some pieces are curly and some are straight… I’m a long hair kinda gal – my mom is in her 60’s and still has longish hair, baby sisters in their 20’s and have beautiful long curly hair. Guess I’m just not ready to give up on it!
*To me it is the outfit that carries the message “hi- I´m a young pastor but don´t know my role yetâ€*
Wow, thanks – it’s a dark denim skirt and a bright green cotton sweater. Pretty sure I know my role, and if my clothes make people think that I am 20 years older than I actually am, well then, I’m flattered I’m suppose :o) At least for the next couple years.
On the Jeans (and since I’m procrastinating on those Holy Week sermons!), I finally discovered it was worth it to try on the “expensive store” jeans, like Black House/White Market and Ann Taylor. Yes, the jeans are around $80, but they are awesome. I call mine voodoo pants. It’s worth it to wait for a good sale- I snagged my two pairs for 20 and 40$ each.
What I can’t find anywhere are JACKETS! Anyone able to help? Those ARE expensive. I’m super short-waisted, so most of them hang long. Is a tailor my only option?
This is such a strange combo – being a “cleric with fashion sense.” the former, with it’s focus on the eternal, just seems not to go with the latter. fashion is about earthly beauty, gender, sexuality, and earthly desires, no? Isn’t that the reason for the black and the collar, to get away from concerns of beauty and fashion?
I totally sympathize with the dilemma here, since male clerics have an assumption of authority that women don’t benefit from. Plus, younger women who play up their gender/sexuality in a religious contexts usually do it within a tradition “helpmate” family structure.
The advice i’d give is to look to older women in corporate contexts as models for appropriate dress – the women who’ve had success have had to create an acceptable balance between communicating authority and gender through dress. think hillary clinton, meg whitman, nancy brinker.
shorter hair, jackets, pants. cover your curves, don’t accentuate them (unless you’re seeking the attention of men. think: less cute, more polished.