Erin, Part II: Erin At Church, Youth Group And Pastoral Visits

erin-sunday

Erin?
I feel like there’s something you’re trying to express with this blazer. Of all your pieces, this is the one where I’m most like, “Okay, I don’t think this exactly works but I feel like she’s making a statement of some sort, and that’s good.”

The pants are nice and the line you create with the trousers and the cute round-toed shoes is very classic. Good, good, good. You’re a long-limbed woman and that stature (I don’t know how tall you are but you read as tall) can be part of the power of your presence.

This blazer, though. The color is really hard to work with, as it tends to make any light-skinned person look sallow. The cut feels skimpy, and I’m actually wondering if this is maybe a grad school or college-era thrift store find that was awesome at the time but isn’t going to make the cut in your sophisticated future. I’m afraid it’s a very dated cut and style (pockets dead giveaway) and that although it may have been a fun signature piece at one time, I think it’s probably time to save it for St. Patty’s Day.

OR…. another idea would be to play up the kind of fun, wack vintage feel of this jacket with more creative pants. Like if you had really wide-legged cuffed trousers and paired them with a great chunky boot, wore your hair up in a sloppy knot and added a big, fun cocktail ring or a stack of big bangles on your arm, I’d know you were being whimsical with the jacket, and not wearing it as a serious professional piece. You know what I mean? If you’re being fun, make sure we know you’re being fun. And of course you wouldn’t wear that all to church on Sunday, but you could wear it to a collegial meeting or something.

Speaking of fun, here’s Pastor Erin going off to meet with the Youth Group:

erin-with-youth

Miss Erin, are those PLAID FLATS I see peeping out of the bottom of your pants? How totally cute! We love your hair up! So I’m thinking, why not add a hoodie to this outfit? Like a nice knit hoodie (not sweatshirt material) in black or some fun color? That would be wicked cute and who cares if you look young with the youth? It’s a major benefit to look young in that setting!

Here’s my favorite look of Erin’s. It’s her Pastoral Visits Look:

erin-visits

Love the hair style, Erin. It looks mature and it’s very becoming. You could use a bit of volume at the top, but I love the ‘do on you.
Love the earrings. For some reason they seem much more “you” than the other earrings you’ve had on.
The V-neck sweater vest over the clericals works for me: I think it’s a neat idea, and it’s a nice, clean but feminine sillhouette. I’d add a skinny belt over it to add more definition to the outfit because I do think you could use one key accessory here.
You have such a great collection of really pretty flats! Where do you find them?
The bag is great (I’m biased: I happen to have the exact same one). It’s a great color, very professional, and you just look fully confident and individual here. Yes, you look young but not unsure-of-yourself young. Just young, and fresh, and energetic. Which is a wonderful thing.

So, readers, please do comment. The whole point of doing this online was to engage the BTFM community. Have you gotten any new ideas from this? Does it help to have a real model to refer to in talking about those intangibles like image and (my favorite) “polish?”

Some day a reader is going to write to me, “Why do you think all ministers should be Polish? What have you got against, for instance, Czechs?” I swear.

A huge kiss of peace and thanks to Erin for sending in the photos and offering to do an online consult. I asked her if she wanted to do it interview style but that will have to be the next volunteer.

14 Replies to “Erin, Part II: Erin At Church, Youth Group And Pastoral Visits”

  1. Erin is adorable–but honey, she looks like she’s trying to look matronly rather than like a cool, young minister. All the neutrals, and the insistence on nothing but black clergy shirts, is not good. Plus, I don’t think the trousers fit very well, they look like there’s too much fabric on some of them.

    The plaid shoes are cute–but it looks like a timid little nod to ‘fun’.

    Funky jackets, interesting print skirts, coloured clergy shirts and more interesting accessories are needed here.

  2. ^^ I think the length/width of the sleeves on the clergy shirts is contributing to a bit of that matronly look – they look oversized men’s t-shirt sleeves to me, wide and long for a woman’s shirt.

    Now obviously you’re not going to sew them up into a cap sleeve length-wise, but getting a tailor to remove some of the width in the sleeve will remove the “oversized” feel a bit and make it more proportionate

  3. I wear black clergy shirts only. It’s a way I can be immediately recognized as “clergy” in any situation. I have been criticized for this – folks saying that I should claim my authority by virtue of who I am and the message I preach, saying that I just wear the shirt to look the part, one even going so far to say that if I “need” the shirt, I shouldn’t be a pastor.

    I understand that there are regional and cultural differences one needs to take into consideration. But for me, it’s a symbol of the office, it’s my uniform, and at times it has concretely reminded me that I am not there to be someone’s friend, or buddy, or shoulder to cry on (though my role may encompass all those things…) I am there as their pastor, and I do not speak for myself, but only add my voice to a long line of pastors and priests who have done their best to fulfill the office as well.

    Yes, they are at times ill-fitting. I’m trying. And I still have yet to find a tailor in this town…

    Thanks for your comments and insight! :o)

  4. I like the idea of the black clergy shirt. It’s a sort of shorthand for ‘priest’, and reminds you and others of who you are.

    That said:

    1. I heartily second the comment about sleeves. They’re so big that it looks like you’re wearing the shirt of someone who came before you.

    The rather large sleeves are wearing you.

    2. Some of the trousers are too long, or possibly too big, I’m not sure. A little difficult to tell in the photos.

    Oh, and I love your shoes. You have cool shoes. 🙂

    [Her trousers actually fit quite well. I think they look a bit large because Erin’s not moving. I am SO TIRED of seeing clergy in hideous, too-snug or truly ill-cut pants with no flow at the ankle! AUGH! I was thrilled that Erin avoided that look completely! – PB]

  5. Maybe this is just cos I’m another young clergyperson-to-be, but I love the green blazer! I would swap out the gray pants for black, and add a funky accessory somewhere, and I think the outfit would look much more put together.

  6. Erin, thanks for volunteering for this!

    I have to agree with the others that the style/fit issues related to the clergy shirt are the most significant problem that I see. Colored clergy shirts always look cheesy to me, so I support sticking with the black one, but the fit of them seems off, and I think they’re dragging the rest of your ensembles down.

    I also am struck by the mostly neutral palette in these photos. It’s not just the clothes–it’s the nondescript haircut either pulled back or lying pretty flat, the generic accessories (I think PB nailed that), and the extremely minimal makeup. I think a neutral outfit can be really sophisticated, but not with this hair/makeup/accessories combo. The red bag, for example, is GREAT, and I think most of the rest of the outfits shown here need a similar pop of bold color. How about some new, structured blazers in great colors? Some vibrant skirts, maybe even some fun prints for spring? A wide red belt? Some large, chunky necklaces? What about some scarves to bring some color up near your face? What about a bold thick headband? Etc.

    I also agree that the pants seems a little large on you or maybe just slightly ill-fitting in general. How about some trousers in newer more modern cuts? Some dark denim trousers for youth group outings, maybe?

    And I also adore all your flats! Very cute.

    Finally, I want to say to you that I think your makeup needs to be somewhat more defined. I’m totally losing your face in every single one of this pics. I see the clothes, then you. Your face is just receding into the background. Maybe that’s less of an issue in person, but the nondescript glasses and the nondescript hair and the nondescript makeup is just washing you out. I’m not suggesting you cake on the makeup like a Texas beauty queen, but some more definition could really help your truly lovely features stand out. I’m thinking of more substantial eyeshadow, eyeliner, a darker lipliner or lip crayon.

    I hope this is helpful, and that all these comments you’re getting from PB’s readers inspire some beautiful updates to your spring wardrobe!

  7. Hey Erin –

    As someone who only occasionally wears a collar, I loved seeing how you modify it for different settings. I’m also a young (27) minister in western PA. Wonder if you are near me.

    Emily

  8. Erin,

    Better watch out for me, since I’m about to knock you down and steal that red bag and that green blazer! Where’s the red bag from? As for the blazer- I’d probably pair it with a pair of awesome, very dark jeans, and wear it to clergy conference where I (admittedly and immaturely) do my best to prove to my colleagues that I’m not one of the Old Guard yet.

    I feel your pain on the clergy shirt: check out http://www.collarthis.blogspot.com (a few friends from Seminary write this), where they describe how to convert a standard shirt. That’s helped me a lot with fit and with price points. As a young clergy myself, I didn’t have the money to buy the good-fittin’ shirts, or to tailor the over 75$ shirts I DID find.

    Good luck!

  9. I’m fashion-impaired, so I try to catch on here. I haven’t much advice on the clothes (except, what about wearing pants with creases — are they out?) However, I love the color of your wall!

    [Pants with creases? Yea, they’re out. You mean pleats? – PB]

  10. Oy, I am so out-of-touch. Pants with pleats are “out”? Why? The arbitrary nature of fashion would be one reason why I’ve ignored clothing for so long.

    Erin, you are brave to have volunteered to do this, publicly. Thank you.

    I, too (as a layperson, btw) like your black-only clergy shirt rule. It sends a very clear message about who you are and what you do.

    I like your green jacket, and agree with Katy that switching out your gray pants for black ones could go a long way with that outfit. I also like seeing that you wear flats a lot: I am not a heel-wearing person much, myself, as they aren’t good for your back. I’m glad that I have some company 🙂 .

  11. Just a thought- while Erin’s purpose for black only works great in a parish, for those of us who do chaplaincy, the black can be a cautious choice. Sometimes I do wear the traditional black to the hospital (usually after a morning service at the parish), and since I’m the ED chaplain, it can be a be disturbing. I try to remember to bring an extra shirt, from the number of families I’ve freaked out. “OH MY GOD, IT”S THE CHAPLAIN! HE’S DEAD!” and the amount of explaining and calming I have to do after that. Sometimes, though, the black inspires people to call out for blessings as I walk the hall… so I mix it up with black and colors and patterns. (And lots of really, really frumpy shoes that scream COMFORT. I buy nurse shoes. But I’m on my feet for literally hours at a time!)

    So think about what the color of your shirt says in your individual ministry settings. Black in a parish- awesome and reasonable. Black in a hospital- sometimes difficult.

  12. I’m with you on the black clericals, Erin. I wear lots of solid colored button down shirts, unbuttoned like a jacket (I’m too short and round to wear jackets well) to soften that solid black, because as Rev. Bee says it can be too severe.

    My favorite clerical shirts are the sleeveless variety available from Almy or Womenspirit. The tuck in well and can great under anything – sweaters, shirts, jackets, whatever. (Never alone, as PB has pointed out in previous posts!)

    Thanks for your courageous sharing!

  13. Rev. Bee – I’m with you on that. I did CPE at a Level 1 trauma center, in the ER most of the time. I didn’t even wear a collar there – it wasn’t worth the drama and tears for families waiting…

Comments are closed.