Okay, these aren’t going to give anyone palpitations of thrils, but they’re solid Sunday morning preaching shoes.
They look wicked frumpy in black and brown, but in this color, I thought they would serve honorably.

Rockport Phaedra pump in Sparrow.
Now, here is the highly mysterious process by which I found them, since I get that question all the time.
1. I looked in my closet and realized that I only have old (like 12 years old!) black high heels and flats, and a couple pair of wedges that are okay but not great.
2. I decided that I needed a low-heel preaching shoe that I could wear with navy and grey.
3. I went to Zappos.com and entered the heel height, color options (pewter, grey, purple) and style (pumps, wedges) that I was interested in. I scrolled through the 469 options that the search engine provided for me.
4. I found nothing I liked, so I went to Google search and entered keywords “low heel pump, purple, leather” and found another bunch of options. These shoes came up in Image Search. I clicked on the Google Shopping option and found out where they were for sale.
5. I chose the least expensive option (Google does the work for you that way), which required one click of my thumb to take me to eBay, where a vendor was selling a new pair in my size for $35.
6. I bought them through PayPal and then I went to bed.
You too can find semi-frumpy good preaching shoes by just this very method! Good luck!