This question came to me via Twitter, and it’s a good one: “What do I wear to a ‘casual dinner’ at a parishioner’s house during an interview weekend?”
So tricky, so tricky! Here are a few thoughts for you, my dear and talented newbie:
1. Get comfortable with the fact that you’re probably going to be the most formally dressed person in the room, because you are interviewing and they can say “casual” all they want, but you should never be casual in an interviewing situation. They’re welcome to eat in jeans, or in work-out clothes. Practice your confident smile in the hotel room: these are weird gatherings that can tempt you into feeling like you’re off duty, but you and I know better than that. You’re not their pastor yet, so you can’t dress for dinner with them as though you are. Your beautiful, polished presence honors the invitation. I am certain that the hosts will have gone to great effort to put a lovely meal together, so your outfit should reflect back that effort. God knows you don’t want to be under-dressed. That would be horrible!
2. Your outfit should be comfortable but very put together. Styling is your friend here. Think soft fabrics (anything too structured, like a blazer, will seem too stiff and corporate for the intimate setting), think tailored, think accessories that make an impression but that don’t get in the way of your eating or gesticulating at a table filled with delicate items that could get knocked over. You really don’t need an “Oh, I’m so sorry I just knocked over a glass of Pinot Noir while enthusiastically detailing for you my vision of Christian Education at your church!” – moment.
So skip the charm bracelet and stick with the beautiful dramatic necklace, or use a gorgeous clip to hold your hair back. Avoid scarves, as they might wind up dragging in your salad. Gents, you should wear a nice, casual sports jacket but not a tie.
Some ideas: cute neutral trousers (something fitted nicely in a structured fabric), a navy cardigan, a beautifully patterned blouse, hair up in a chignon, pumps. A knee length pencil skirt, comfortable sweater with 3/4 length sleeves, pretty flats. A pair of wide-legged trousers with a perfectly ironed classic blouse tucked in, a great belt, and statement earrings. Dudes: khakis, shined up shoes, button-down, nice V-neck sweater. Throw a sports jacket on over all that for extra awesomeness.
No: jeans, big clompy boots, dangly anything, hair that will distract you or tempt you to play with it, crop pants, overdone glittery or sequiny details, shiny fabrics, or super fitted garments. Check for cleavage from a seated position. You will be leaning forward, reaching and using utensils (I mean, I hope you will, unless you want to go au naturel and eat everything with your fingers: that will certainly make an impression!).
3. Eat before you get there. Seriously. At least eat enough so that you aren’t actually hungry when you get to the house, as your job there is to be able to graciously converse and respond to pleasant inquiries (that are actually just as loaded with potential gaffes as any formal interview questions). You can’t really pay attention to what’s being said and to social cues when you’re wolfing down bread and butter or obsessing about the appropriateness of accepting a second helping of meatloaf, so make sure you arrive with a good blood glucose level and something in your tum.
4. One glass of wine seems fine to me, unless you know the former minister was a lush, in which case pretend to think it over and then say, “Oh, thank you. Maybe later, but I’d love a (club soda, tonic, Diet Coke).” And then don’t have a glass of wine at all. If the hosts are serving a wine they seem to be very proud of and have obviously chosen just for this occasion, it’s a good idea to accept ONE glass and make an appreciative comment about how lovely it is. If you’re abstinent from alcohol and you’d rather downplay that fact for the time being, you can say, “Thank you, but I don’t think I’ll drink tonight” if cocktails are offered. Always follow a rejection with an affirmation, e.g, “No thank you, but I would love some seltzer if you have some.” It’s the same thing with meat or sugar, or any other dietary restrictions. “I’m going to pass on the pork, thank you, but I would love some more potatoes if there are any left,” or “I don’t think I could possibly manage a chocolate mousse right now but if you’re making tea I would love a cup.”
5. No matter how much fun you’re having, never forget that this is still a job interview. Wrap up your stories in a timely manner and keep an eye on the clock. I am a total night owl and dining room gabber who can happily sit around a table for hours and hours talking late into the night, but in most gatherings people really want to get their guests out no later than 9pm so they can clean up and get to bed at a decent hour. As the guest of honor, it is up to you to look at your watch, exclaim, “Oh my gosh, it’s after nine already!” Let the others take it from there. They will, and they’ll appreciate you for helping conclude the evening, which has been work for everyone.
6. Be ready to offer grace, because you will be asked. Keep it simple. This is not the time to impress with your mad extemporaneous prayer skillz. It’s time to offer up a humble and short prayer, because the food is hot and your host or hostess is going to harbor deep resentments against you if you blather on too long and let the asparagus soup get cold.
7. Get up out of your seat and help clear. Don’t ask, just help. If someone says, “Please, relax,” you can still help by stacking plates. As a frequent dinner party hostess, I am amazed how many guests come, eat the food, and peel out the door without asking if they can help clear. I consider that to be a sign of poor character and bad breeding and I sniff with disapproval at such people, which causes Jesus to look sadly at me over his cup of coffee. When he does, I say, “Oh, stop it with your big puppy eyes. That is SO ill-mannered and you know it.”
8. Send a thank you card. A CARD that comes in the MAIL with a STAMP on it.
9. Good luck!!! xoxo Kiss of peace, PB
