um, OK, I see what the author of the article is getting at, but in this particular case, I am not so sure that the opinion of someone who is really unchurched would be helpful; they don’t have any stake in this person as a leader, someone who breaks the bread and pours the cup. And what of the people who will wonder, “if she will say that about herself to someone who will put it in a magazine, what might she say about me?”
Any way you slice it, it’s still TMI. And in a way, I think it undermines the role of women, particularly younger women (I am not one of those) in the ministry.
Just sayin’.
Read the article and still think you are right, PB. The author really did “miss the point” of your critique.
Your comment was an excellent distillation of your thoughts and the thoughts and comments written here (noted in the Christian Century article as “quick and loud and negative”). Thank you for RE-directing the conversation away from the titillation and towards taking responsibility for our actions.
The first time I just read the article, and thought “Well, that doesn’t contribute much to the conversation people had here. It sort of missed the point.” But this morning, I continued on and read your comment at the bottom, and now I “get” why you posted it. Silly me.
Anyway, this week our Presbytery debated and voted on removing the “fidelity and chastity” part of the ordination requirements. And it was interesting. There are some folks for whom “chastity” is the highest form of Christian life. It’s worth any amount of denial and distortion of body, mind and spirit. Thus, the CC author who thought the Marie Claire article woman was a great example of defeating temptation. I don’t get it. That kind of willful ignorance and self hatred is just crippling. And, Jesus was in the business of healing cripples, not creating them. (I know he SAID “cut off your hand if it causes you to sin.” But I think most Christians would agree THAT’s a part of the Bible we weren’t meant to take literally.)
Cindy,
I am not seeing where the author of the CC article says the young clergy woman interviewed for the Marie Claire article is a “great example of defeating temptation”.
Knowing the CC author, I can assure you that she is in no way willfully ignorant or filled with crippling self hatred. I am sad at the continued ugly rhetoric around this topic.
Let me suggest this: I think the passionate language and feeling around this topic is nothing to grieve about. This is an incredibly important topic that has behind it many centuries of true evil, and enormous quantities of women’s blood and suffering. We are angry about it for good reason. All of us are bearers of women’s ancestral memory. To rage against any suggestion — however nicely put — that repressed sexuality, fear of one’s own desire and a fantasy life co-opted by Hollywood virgin porn is worthy of support and respect — is a healthy response.
Rage on, women. For God’s sake, rage on. Too many of our sisters have been tortured and died in body and in spirit for us to insist on polite manners in our continued fight. Those who do not understand that it is a fight are, I’m afraid, not paying attention. In other words, this is much bigger than Wren Miller. I think for many of us there is tremendous frustration that, hey, finally women pastors are going to take some risks and make a statement as sexual beings and THIS is what we get for a spokeswoman? Then again, any woman who thinks she’s going to get a fair shake by a women’s fashion magazine is not very savvy, to put it mildly.
um, OK, I see what the author of the article is getting at, but in this particular case, I am not so sure that the opinion of someone who is really unchurched would be helpful; they don’t have any stake in this person as a leader, someone who breaks the bread and pours the cup. And what of the people who will wonder, “if she will say that about herself to someone who will put it in a magazine, what might she say about me?”
Any way you slice it, it’s still TMI. And in a way, I think it undermines the role of women, particularly younger women (I am not one of those) in the ministry.
Just sayin’.
Read the article and still think you are right, PB. The author really did “miss the point” of your critique.
Your comment was an excellent distillation of your thoughts and the thoughts and comments written here (noted in the Christian Century article as “quick and loud and negative”). Thank you for RE-directing the conversation away from the titillation and towards taking responsibility for our actions.
The first time I just read the article, and thought “Well, that doesn’t contribute much to the conversation people had here. It sort of missed the point.” But this morning, I continued on and read your comment at the bottom, and now I “get” why you posted it. Silly me.
Anyway, this week our Presbytery debated and voted on removing the “fidelity and chastity” part of the ordination requirements. And it was interesting. There are some folks for whom “chastity” is the highest form of Christian life. It’s worth any amount of denial and distortion of body, mind and spirit. Thus, the CC author who thought the Marie Claire article woman was a great example of defeating temptation. I don’t get it. That kind of willful ignorance and self hatred is just crippling. And, Jesus was in the business of healing cripples, not creating them. (I know he SAID “cut off your hand if it causes you to sin.” But I think most Christians would agree THAT’s a part of the Bible we weren’t meant to take literally.)
Cindy,
I am not seeing where the author of the CC article says the young clergy woman interviewed for the Marie Claire article is a “great example of defeating temptation”.
Knowing the CC author, I can assure you that she is in no way willfully ignorant or filled with crippling self hatred. I am sad at the continued ugly rhetoric around this topic.
Let me suggest this: I think the passionate language and feeling around this topic is nothing to grieve about. This is an incredibly important topic that has behind it many centuries of true evil, and enormous quantities of women’s blood and suffering. We are angry about it for good reason. All of us are bearers of women’s ancestral memory. To rage against any suggestion — however nicely put — that repressed sexuality, fear of one’s own desire and a fantasy life co-opted by Hollywood virgin porn is worthy of support and respect — is a healthy response.
Rage on, women. For God’s sake, rage on. Too many of our sisters have been tortured and died in body and in spirit for us to insist on polite manners in our continued fight. Those who do not understand that it is a fight are, I’m afraid, not paying attention. In other words, this is much bigger than Wren Miller. I think for many of us there is tremendous frustration that, hey, finally women pastors are going to take some risks and make a statement as sexual beings and THIS is what we get for a spokeswoman? Then again, any woman who thinks she’s going to get a fair shake by a women’s fashion magazine is not very savvy, to put it mildly.
theglobeandmail.com/life/valentines-day/praise-the-lord-lets-fornicate/article1904691/