Danskos Are Dead To Me

This just in: I have decided to officially withdraw the BTFM Seal of Approval from Mary-Jane style Danskos, and the clogs aren’t really any better.

After trying to wear them to several ministerial functions I have come to the conclusion that they are eternally frumpy, that the toe is just too round and the shape too little-girlish to suit any professional woman except a nurse or maybe a professor (MAYBE, but only one who wants to project an image of harmlessness). Chaplains, fine. But a minister in the public eye, NO. Especially not to officiate or preach in, please.

They’re little girl clogs. That’s all there is to it. They are adorable on funky 20-something retail clerks and pizza servers, not on you and me. I have tried them with dresses and skirts. I have tried them with pants. Each time I do I think, “Augh, these shoes are ANTI-sophistication. They are irredeemably frumpy.”

We’ve gone back and forth on this for some time but having tested the Dansko situation with my own wardrobe I irrevocably conclude that they are OUT. Forever and totally OUT for clergy.

It’s sad, I know. Wear them until they wear and look for a replacement, is all I can say. I am beginning to think that Danskos are the single most nefarious bit of attire keeping female clergy from looking like serious leaders. They seem so inocuous but they’re not. They’re little girl shoes.

Now rant and rave in the comments as you like but PeaceBang is not budging on this.

23 Replies to “Danskos Are Dead To Me”

  1. I won’t rant and rave; I’ll just keep wearing them. They are my go-to shoe on office days, with linen pants (ankle-length–absolutely no cropped pants leaving those big shoes just hanging out there); I think they look funky, not frumpy. But eh, we all have our own ideas of what looks little-girlish. I’m with you on things like jumpers (can we have a jumper-burning party? please?), but I put Mary Janes in the same category as jumpers and drop-waist dresses, namely “Items that Look Totally Smashing on People Under 11.”

  2. Nurses, Professors, AND Chaplains. I have worn a pedometer, and an average day can mean about 12-16000 steps for me. I will fight to the death for my Danskos, which make my flipper like feet feel happy. In fact, I’m about to change out of my daytime “nice shoes” into my overnight happy Danskos, the mary janes.

    Not budging on my Dansko love. 🙂

  3. I am tall and willowy (or gangly and cadaverous 🙂 with somewhat larger feet, and the Dansko Professional just works for me, fashionably speaking. It looks kind of European, definitely casual, totally classic, and really nice for most days. There are plenty of shoe styles that petite women with their cute little feet can wear that I can’t, or petite and roundy women wear that I just look like a skinny teenage boy attempting drag – I hope in time you come to see that Danskos (at LEAST the classic Professional clog shoe) do have an appropriate place in our world, if not for you! 🙂

  4. I’m glad that chaplains are allowed to wear Danksos, because they’re pretty much all I wear when working. I only wear my clogs when I wear pants, and they are pretty much hidden because I’m short and my pants almost cover my feet. (:

    However? I have preached in them, when I was pregnant and me feet were so swollen my only choices were my Danskos, Birkenstocks, and sneakers.

  5. Phew! I am relieved I don’t have to fight for my Danksos. I have clogs, open-back clogs with strap, and the PB-detested Mary Janes, and they make my feet survive these crazy shifts. I’ve even worn them once or twice with a dress, but it was around hour 18 of 24 in a row, and only once have I ever paired scrubs with a clergy collar (trauma patient. Nuff said.).

    Whew!

  6. All I’ll say is that I have a pair of Dansko open back clogs. I wear them to work when my feet hurt(a couple times a year). I also wear them when I want to signal that I am absolutely off the clock. Kind of like slippers that you can wear in public. [Oh, sure! I wear my comfy jungle Mocs or even *gasp* CROCS at those times. – PB]

  7. I’ll also say that Danskos are GREAT standing shoes, which is why people who stand up all day like them
    (I’m thinking chefs and surgeons). I don’t find them to be good walking shoes or good driving shoes. [Well then I’m TOTALLY wearing mine tomorrow night to sing my concert in, because my feet are killing me. – PB]

  8. Well, I’m a chaplain, which MEANS that I am “a minister in the public eye.” Not sure why you make those mutually exclusive professional categories. No frumpiness allowed for me either! I agree with you, PB, about the clogs — always terrible and stumpy and ugly. I won’t wear them. [Just thinking about chaplains running around hospitals and also fitting in with the nurses in their Danskos… hospital corridors are really treacherous. I should have said “hospital chaplains.”- PB]

  9. Dansko clogs are also dangerous!
    I wore them to church for a Saturday meeting with moms and kids and tripped while carrying my son! Many other women have also said they are very unsteady shoes. Not only are they not attractive, but hazardous to you health- I say as I type with one hand and prepare a sermon with a broken arm!
    Just say no!

  10. UU music professional here…and I could not agree more, PeaceBang! The frumpiness of Danskos has aggravated me for ages. Preach it!

  11. I agree that Danskos are not good for much professionally, but as I’m three months into a year of hospital chaplaincy, I can’t WAIT until I get some holiday wherewithal so I can make a trip to the Dansko outlet–my feets need a break at least one day a week!

    I would add, though, that though there are places and situations where Dansko clogs can be appropriate, even in these cases, the MOST important thing is to keep them oiled or polished and in good shape. It’s when they get scuffed and dented and the heels all worn down that they look worse than frumpy.

    And besides, if they’re that dented and old, the happy comfy place for your feet is also dented and worn and not helping the feets.

  12. I LOVE my Dansko Savannah Mary Janes in Olive. I agree they are a little girlish, BUT I have a chronic form of arthritis in my left foot and there are days when only keen water shoes fit. And I’m a campus minister, which means I need some funky street cred when hiking the hilly campus I serve. So can I get a health-related dispensation?;)

  13. Sorry Peacebang – this is one peice of frump that you won’t wrest from my happy feet! Between the chronic foot pain that drove me to Birkenstocks in the first place and the sad truth that two pregnancies have forever altered my foot width (especially in the toe box area), all those cute, no-arch-support, toe-pinching, so-narrow-that-I-have-to-wear-one-and-a-half-size-bigger high heels are a banned item in my wardrobe.

    Not that I don’t drool over them. I used to wear high heels all the time, even when on my feet all day, with nary a problem. I miss those cute sexy shoes — my husband misses those cute sexy shoes on me! But when faced between aching sore feet all day and excruciating foot pain so bad I can barely walk in the morning…well comfort is going to win out over frump every time.

    BTW – The moral of this story, my younger friends, is don’t cheap out on shoes because Payless is NOT your friend and you will do damage and be consigned to frumpy-shoe-hell.

    Still searching for a comfortable, dressy shoe with a great arch support…..

  14. Thank you for seeing the light about Mary Janes. But PB! Crocs??????? Never, never, never, unless you are wearing the semi-cute slide-on sandals to the gym.

  15. One word … Clarks … I wear Partridge with slacks and Sugar Plum with dresses. Both are extremely comfy on the footsies when standing for long periods and they have the added benefit of having synthetic/rubber heels so no ‘clickity clacking’ as we walk about on the hardwood floors.

  16. Can we have a picture please of the said frumpy shoes? I don’t think we have these in the UK?

  17. Sorry you don’t like them. They’re the only shoes I can wear for an entire 12 hour shift at the hospital with no foot pain. I wear them with black wool socks and they are totally the bomb.

    If I’m wearing a skirt I wear the black mary jane crocks. They totally rock and don’t look terrible. I’d look like a fool in pointy toed, narrow heeled shoes on a regular day or night at the hospital, IMHO.

  18. Yes, yes, yes, yes yes. I’m only 25, but I don’t understand the appeal of these shoes at all. I have friends younger than me with plantar fasciitis and a host of foot problems. EEven if you absolutely MUST wear orthopedic shoes, there’s no reason to make them Mary Janes instead of the Dansko Professionals.

    I’m moving into a time working part-time in a hospital as a technologist and “part-time” as a pastor (har har).

    Though I wouldn’t normally wear this type of shoe professionally, a lot of technologists wear running-type shoes. So I’ve been wearing the Puma GV Special
    http://www.zappos.com/puma-gv-special

    They blend into my coworkers’ styles without being unsupportive – the sole is thick and they fit insoles well. It’s also a role where the easily wipable/cross-contamination rules arent as strict as people who work in ORs or invasive procedure areas are, so the laces are OK.

    But I wouldn’t wear those anywhere besides an indoor volleyball or basketball tournament in the church setting.

    In the church setting I now wear the clearance-priced versions of shoes like these:
    http://www.zappos.com/la-canadienne-callie-black-leather
    http://www.zappos.com/ecco-casual-bouillon-buckle-retro-red-macau-patent

    Although for the inevitable time when I’ll have to move seamlessly between both roles in a given day and scarcely have time to change shoes, I’m looking at some like these:
    http://www.zappos.com/naturalizer-northall-bronze-metallic-smooth-leather
    http://www.zappos.com/bandolino-holden-medium-red-synthetic (the vamp may be too low on these for the hospital)

    The Dansko Professionals may be a fact of life at some point, but I don’t see any need or reason for the Mary Janes… ever.

  19. I adore my Danskos. They are, indeed, the Professionals, and I do NOT wear them with a skirt.

    I live in the city and I walk to work; I need solid, sensible, any-weather shoes. In the summer I wear sandals (gotta let the tootsies breathe!), and in the winter I wear Uggs to ward against the cold (I have the ones with the super rubber sole, not the feeble felt sole). In the spring/fall I wear Danskos against the drizzle and chill. They don’t get soaked in rainy weather, and I can slip them off at the office and pull on cute shoes.

    Finally, I think they are actually pretty adorable with jeans. It’s a casual look, but it’s comfortable, walkable, and I can slip them off when I’m at a friend’s house. It’s not a professional look, and it’s certainly not elegant or chic, but they are great for casual, “off-duty” wear.

  20. I hate Danskos. I think they’re ugly AND they hurt my feet. Just in case you needed to feel supported, PB. 🙂

Comments are closed.