I so wish I hadn’t bought the Dansko Marcelle this past summer:

They are super-cute (much more so than in the photos) but I can’t get my feet to like them even though they’re heralded as the God of Comfortable Shoes.
Does anyone want to buy mine off me for $60? I’ve worn them about 5 times, they’re brand new and they’re worth almost twice that.
What I wish I HAD bought was this equally cute Mary Jane by Alegria. I would be wearing these suckers all over the place if I owned them. I know they look like Frumperina Footwear but they looked far cuter in person and not at all Earth Mother Granola:

Of course they don’t have my beensy-weensy size in the pewter but I’d be happy with the black:
I tried these on in New Hampshire and I thought they were less cute than the Danskos, but who cares about cuteness factor when your feet aren’t happy? [Although Alert Reader Betsy sternly reminds me that I must be careful with my words lest her intern think it okay to wear CROCS to church. It’s all relative, darlings! See my posts on the despicable contemporary tendency to make a false idol of comfort. – PB]


I started to ask what size are your Danskos but then you mentioned beensy-weensy – so they certainly aren’t for me. But for others – what precisely is beensy-weensy?
signed..another blasted Dansko lover
I believe the technical definition of beensy-weensy is “less than a US size 7.”
What size are the Danskos? I might be interested… [They’re 37. Size 6.5-7. – PB]
I’m sorry your feet don’t like the Danskos…mine never have liked them either. I think they are supremely uncomfortable. I’m occasionally willing to wear uncomfortable shoes, but they’ve got to be beautiful and high-fashion for a special occasion. Danskos are meant to be an everyday shoe, and everyday shoes should never hurt! I am happy for those who have Danskos-loving feet, but I can’t relate.
Speaking of everyday shoes, I must say that the alternative maryjanes seem kinda frumpfrump to me. They are bizarrely shaped and also somewhat childlike. I think maryjanes can easily fall into the same trap as jumpers–grown women should tread very carefully and think hard before wearing them.
Peacebang, I think your perfect everyday black shoe is still out there, waiting for you to discover it…good luck!
[Hi JBC – I know, the Alegria’s look very frumpy in photos and that’s why I didn’t want to try them on in the store. For some reason — who knows why — they delighted me! They’re just very cute and not little girly at all. Weird. But there you have it. The same thing with those Danskos, they’re just super cute. – PB]
I love my danskos. I have big flipper-like feet, though, so I like the structure.
The Alegria looks dreadful to me in pictures, though. It looks like the shoe equivalent of a Duck-mobile- you know, the tourist things that go on land and water. I shall take your word for it that they look better in person.
However, I hope you are careful of that last statement. There’s a huge risk of someone reading that and thinking, “What a relief! Peace bang said I could wear crocs!” Just today, I lectured a new intern about the need to wear decent footwear. So you might want to qualify what constitutes comfy but acceptable. [My GOD! You’re right! I shall amend that immediately! – PB]
I actually sort of considered buying a pair of crocs last week. I decided not to because I felt I owed it to Tim Gunn, but aren’t these actually kinda cute?
[ I think they’re TOTALLY cute and fine. And a far cry from the hideousness of the “classic” Crocs. I think Tim Gunn would absolutely accept these. – PB]
CC
I wear a Dansko 37! Shall we continue the logistical conversation over email?
Holy cannoli, Chalicechick, those are ADORABLE!! I love MaryJanes, and those are so cute.
Tim Gunn would NEVER approve of plastic shoes. And they would give Stacy and Clinton the vapors. I agree with ixnay on Mary Janes for females over the age of six.
PB–Check out Gentle Soles. I just got some ballet flats, and I think I’m going to love them. Garnet Hill has some GS wedges that, if I could like wedges, I would love.
CORRECTION: My Danskos are a size 36, not 37!
I can speak highly to the comfort of the Alegrias. I bought an open-back clog in them with peace signs and “love thy neighbor” on them. I know, too cute for formal wear, but they are amazingly comfortable and fun to wear. And they are nowhere on the web, so I can’t show them to you. I think the Alegria Mary Janes are a tad odd but potentially way useful.
I bought those Alegria shoes specifically to wear with clericals for Sundays when I will be on my feet a lot. They are super supportive – and – if I’m honest, what really won me over was the butterfly on the side…beautiful resurrection symbol!