Oprah’s Makeover Team

And what is up with them?

I love Oprah, my friends.
I don’t watch her show very often because I’m almost always doing something else at that hour and if I’m not, frankly, I’d rather be reading.

Oprah’s show is pretty formulaic and I can’t stand the squealing lay-dees thing, but she does some wonderful things, she used to raise topics that no one else was talking about, and she’s a terrific human being.

That said, whenever I’m at the gym and happen to catch some of her make-over specials I can be heard on the elliptical cross-trainer going, “Oh HELL, what did they DO to that woman?” If I’m lucky enough to have a similarly concerned woman working out next to me, we dish together:
“Look how badly the top of that dress fits her!”
“That color is atrocious! No one should wear that color!”
“If she can’t walk in heels, they should have given her cute flats or boots. The poor woman is about to tip over!”
“Oh my gosh, that hairstyle makes her look ten years older than she did before.”

Meanwhile, the fashion advisors are talking a great game about how much of an improvement this new look is and I’m thinking, “Gads, I hope the viewers trust their eyes over some ‘expert’ on this.”

And that’s all I wanted to say to you. Trust your eyes. Educate yourself. Cast a critical eye on make-overs: some of them are inspiring and can give you great ideas, and some are wildly misguided.

By the way, since some of you asked: I think that Cindy McCain’s outfit on election night was singularly horrendous (bad, bad, unflattering cut, absolutely hideous color one friend described as “baby vomit”). Michele Obama’s dress was a little bit better, but not much (bizarre, distracting pattern in harsh colors, but at least it fit her well). However, I’m sure that she will be a glorious First Lady and look forward to her rocking some seriously great looks for America. There’s a woman who knows how to project an image!

Now for the visuals:


The First Lady-Elect in a Narciso Rodriguez creation that looked like this on the runway:

Cindy McCain in what I think may be an Oscar de la Renta suit:

9 Replies to “Oprah’s Makeover Team”

  1. I have to agree with you about Cindy McCain… That jacket DOES NOT FIT. And the colour washes her out.

    But I thought that Michelle Obama looked fantastic. The pattern was a bit “out there,” but as you said, the dress fit her perfectly, and she wore it with such beautiful confidence that I thought it was entirely successful. [To be honest with you, I never noticed the dress until a reader asked for my opinion and I went back and looked at it. I just think she’s luminous! And it was cute that the black and red matched Sasha and Melia’s dresses — so cute! – PB]

  2. Thank goodness you wrote about the last Oprah makeover show! I hadn’t had time to write you about it, but I was just horrified by that show. I think O was just going through the motions until the election was over and not putting much into the show.

    As to the women of the election, Cindy looks sick and tired. That suit did nothing for her.

    Michelle looked wonderful. It took me seeing the video of them coming out again to notice that she was wearing a shrug so she wouldn’t be sleeveless on an autumn night in Chicago.

  3. and Michelle’s dress looked SO much better on her than on the model. It is nice to see clothing on women who actually eat from time to time….

    Meow.

  4. I loved Michelle Obama’s election night sartorial choice. If she and her daughters had been dressed in colors that didn’t work together, I think her dress would have looked too busy.

    But the Matching Obamas, with coordinated dresses and ties look great (I hope they don’t make a habit of the matching game though…).

    They are one handsome First Family.

  5. I am looking forward to the next four years of seeing what Michelle Obama wears and does.

    BTW, Cindy McCain’s suit color was not baby vomit. That color comes from the other end of the baby. (This is from much recent experience.) Not a good color in any situation. [Hey Little Mama!!! So good to hear from you!! I think someone did refer to C McC’s suit color as “baby s***” but I forgot about that, not having changed many diapers in my day. -PB]

  6. That last Oprah makeover show was so sad–I don’t often watch her either, but that was so bad.

    She took these who were lovely and accomplished and all that, and made them into cartoon characters. High heels on a forest ranger? Good grief. So undignified and unbecoming to her PERSON.

    The worst was when the mom who cares for an autistic child came out looking like a fashion model and the husband beams and says something like now that’s the person I married. How absolutely offensive and demeaning to both marriage and motherhood.

    I won’t even get started on the backhanded compliments (Jersey drapes on ALL SORTS of bodies, that sort of thing).

Comments are closed.