Taylor writes in to gush about the comfortableness and fashionability of these pointy-toe pumps called Fitzwells (scroll down on this page).
Is Taylor really a religious person whose seminarian friend wants to write a book about ministry and fashion, or is Taylor a spy for Zappos.com who wants free advertising on this blog? PeaceBang has her suspicions but she has decided to trust in Taylor’s authenticity and goodness, and to send him/her a kiss of peace for the recommendation.

PeaceBang,
I can vouch for the identity of Taylor. She is my daughter, a student at Princeton Theological Seminary, and an intern at a Presbyterian Church in the Dallas suburbs for the summer. She will probably email you as well, but I wanted you to have semi-independent verification. I’m a PCUSA pastor in Mooreville, NC, serving at First Pres. She is the one who made me aware of your website.
I appreciate what you’re doing. While our theology no doubt differs widely, we have common ground in a shared desire for clergy and church staff of both sexes to dress the part. Plunging necklines, tight sweaters, jeans with holes, flipflops or crocs, and enough piercings to be part of Blackbeard’s crew are not part of the “uniform,” as are not fashions more suited to Old Order Amish, 1950s Bible salespeople, or the cast of “That 70s Show.” Classic suits and ties and other such articles of clothing are needed for Sundays, and nice, pressed, classic-looking clothing will do for the rest of the week.
Why? I want my banker, my doctor, my financial planner, my dentist, my lawyer, and my counselor to look as though they have things reasonably well together and that they didn’t just wake up and run to work in the first clothes they could grab. I think most people have the same expectation of their pastors. In short, I truly believe your mantra that if we choose not to project an image intentionally, we will project an image unintentionally, and generally speaking, that unintentional image will be one that hurts, not helps, our ministries. I’m convinced the uniform shows your parishioners and communities that you are a capable person, well versed and well trained in your calling, who takes the time to look stylish and presentable without the extremes of faddishness or dowdiness, and thus you can be expected to perform your ministerial duties/roles/obligations/commitments in a competent and caring manner.
Two real life examples follow in a response now turning out to be much longer than originally intended…
1. At my previous church, a large PCUSA congregation in Houston, the clergy wore suits (and if male, with ties) with starched shirts to the office during the week, and only darker suits on Sundays, even though we wore robes and vestments. I freely admit that a suit and tie every day got old. But other staff and especially interns were given much more freedom in apparel. You know, freedom can be misused! There were a few occasions when I had no choice but to tell a staff member or intern that the cut of that particular top was not appropriate when you’re about to go somewhere with a van full of hormonally charged 8th grade boys, or that nose ring, shirt with sleeves short enough to reveal your Celtic Cross and Crown of Thorns tats, and torn faded blue jeans with flipflops ensemble was not a wise choice when you’re to give a devotion at the women’s circle monthly meeting. Why would I need to tell someone this at the 11th hour before their event or presentation? But it happened more than once.
2. At my current charge, we are business dress with suits on Sundays for clergy and staff, but more business casual during the week. My typical attire in the office are a pair of slacks, a starched dress shirt (usually Polo), and either a dress shoe or a nicer casual shoe, depending on the slacks. Sometimes a blazer will accompany this, especially in cooler weather. Is this hard? Not at all. I admit I had to be coached by others (wife and aforementioned daughter, to name two) at the beginning, but now it is nearly second nature. Today it is not unusual to see colleagues in ministry who:
1) attempt in vain to imitate Rick Warren (we’re in North Carolina, not southern California, for goodness sakes!),
2) resemble Pentecostal ministers from the 1950s,
3) look like Joel Osteen or guest hosts on TBN, or
4) give the appearance of just rolling out of bed with the most rumpled, wrinkled pullover casual shirt they could possibly find. I wonder what’s going on. What are they thinking? I know there are exceptions to the uniform, but exceptions are truly that–occasional circumstances and situations, not the rule of thumb itself.
Whew! Way too much venting. I feel better, though. My apologies. Keep up the good work.
Grace and peace,
Clay Brown
The Rev. Clay J. Brown, Ph.D.
I must disagree! This brand is very painful for me to wear–not because the heel is high or the toe is pointy, but because the little jell pads that are supposed to be cushy are excruciating and cause rubbing. I have wide feet and this only makes it worse. Its’ a shame because they have nice looking options on Zappos, but they have all hurt my feet terribly.
I have to disagree with Madgebaby. I ordered the Lana (not the Lana II) and really liked them. I have them in three different colors. The heel pad does take some adjusting to, but after one or two days you can’t even tell it is there. It may help to wear a heel liner in them.
I am with Madgebaby. Bought two pairs. They looked beautiful. I was enticed by the gel inserts in the sole. Suffering for fashion is not for me. Wide foot, high instep or bunions? Be not deceived I say.
Oh well. Taylor, a real, live seminarian, loves them and says she wore them for 8 hours the other day!
Oops, that’s “you’re.” Yes, I CAN spell.
Can’t say I care for the Fitzwells, but I loved the letter from Taylor’s terrific dad, with whom I served on a Big Committee in his previous presbytery. Fun and funny letter, just like Rev. Clay.
As for shoes, I will continue being my comfortable and unrepentant self in my chic AND comfortable little Coldwater Creek flats.